• Ep. 78 - Personal Encounters Pt.2
    Jul 9 2025

    We have another episode for you full of personal encounters, some of them sent in by you guys! Tune in because we have stuff like mimics, disappearing illnesses, and a magic music box!


    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Show More Show Less
    51 mins
  • Ep. 77 - The Story Story
    Jul 2 2025

    This episode is dedicated to Marlene's father, Ismael Gallo, who passed away 8 years ago, yesterday. His spirit lives on through his kids and grandkids every day!


    This week Marlene gets deep with dreams and Alyssa tells a story about the Story Inn!



    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Show More Show Less
    50 mins
  • Ep. 76 - Swampfoot
    Jun 26 2025

    This week we talk about Louisiana's Bigfoot, a.k.a. the Honey Island Swamp Monster! Oh and Marlene talks about a conspiracy, pretty on brand.



    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Show More Show Less
    43 mins
  • Ep. 75 - The Case of Maura Murray
    Jun 18 2025

    On February 9th, 2004, Maura Murray went for a drive...and she was never seen again.



    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Show More Show Less
    48 mins
  • Ep. 74 - The Day The Music Died
    Jun 11 2025

    In this quick little episode we talk about the mark that three rock and roll legends left on a dance club in Iowa...



    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Show More Show Less
    27 mins
  • Ep. 73 - The Lady in White House
    Jun 4 2025

    This week WYFSS gets patriotic and talks about all of the ghosties hangin' out at the white house. Also, Marlene totally personally attacks Alyssa with her not so fun fun fact :)



    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Show More Show Less
    43 mins
  • Ep. 72 - The Giggling Granny
    May 28 2025

    This isn't your average every day granny...this is Nannie Doss, the giggling granny and you may want to steer clear of her.


    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Show More Show Less
    52 mins
  • Ep. 71 - Personal Encounters
    May 22 2025

    Finally...it's time for some personal encounters! It's about time we shared some of your experiences, and man are they creepy. Also, Marlene talks about rolie polies and a haunted doll, naturally.


    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 4 mins