The Reality Between Us cover art

The Reality Between Us

The Reality Between Us

By: Aja Rutledge
Listen for free

This Season's Biggest Deal | $0.99/mo for 3 months + $20 Audible bonus

Auto-renews at $8.99/mo. after 3 months - terms apply.
Summary
The Reality Between Us explores what happens underneath relationships. Through the lens of trauma, nervous systems, self-awareness, and relational patterns, Aja Rutledge examines the forces quietly shaping how we connect, conflict, communicate, avoid, trust, and make meaning of our experiences. Most relationship advice focuses on behavior. This podcast explores what's driving the behavior. Rather than offering formulas or quick fixes, The Reality Between Us looks beneath the surface of our relationships, with partners, family, friends, coworkers, and most importantly, ourselves, to understand the hidden dynamics influencing how we show up and why we keep repeating the patterns we do. Because what happens between people rarely starts between people. Most relationship advice is looking in one place. We're going to look somewhere else.Copyright 2026 Aja Rutledge Hygiene & Healthy Living Personal Development Personal Success Psychology Psychology & Mental Health Relationships Social Sciences
Episodes
  • You Thought It Was Just A Relationship | #21
    Nov 18 2026

    Have you ever been in a relationship that seemed to be working well, only to eventually realize you were contributing far more than you understood? And we're not just talking about household responsibilities or emotional support. What if someone was relying on you to maintain their sense of self, their ability to function, or even how they perceived themselves in the world?

    We often assume people enter relationships wanting similar things. But what if we're not even using relationships for the same purposes? What if one person enters a relationship with an established sense of self, while another relies on that relationship to establish and maintain theirs? And what happens when these two ways of functioning come together without either person recognizing what's actually taking place?

    In this episode, we explore a dynamic through two terms: externalizers and internalizers. We examine how one person can unknowingly become responsible for another person's regulation and functioning, why these arrangements can initially appear mutual, and what begins to emerge when we look more closely at how each person participates in the relationship.

    In this episode, we explore:

    • The difference between externalizers and internalizers, and how their sense of self influences the way they function in relationships.
    • How someone can unknowingly become responsible for another person's emotional regulation, identity, and ability to function.
    • Why a relationship can appear reciprocal while primarily serving one person's needs.
    • How patterns of curiosity, reciprocity, and consideration can reveal what is actually happening within a relationship.

    Episode Thoughts to Sit With

    “I show up for you. I thought you were showing up for me, but when the rubber meets the road, I'm showing up for you and you're showing up for you. So who's showing up for me?”

    “Whose needs automatically are valid and get to have space? And whose needs need acceptance of proof before they even get to be honored as valid in the space?”

    “They are using the relationship to define how they perceive themselves in the world and to support how they function in the world.”

    “The thing is, we can see these things, we just rationalize it as something else because internalizers have been trained to prove their worth, to prove being chosen, to earn love.”

    _______

    Join me over on Substack at The Better Question, where we explore self-trust in the article Self-Trust Isn't a Hashtag.

    Sometimes we recognize that something isn't right in a relationship, but spend so much time questioning ourselves, explaining away behaviors, or trying to understand the other person that we begin to lose sight of our own experience.

    The article explores what it actually takes to develop self-trust, why it can't simply be achieved through positive thinking, and how it can change the way we navigate our relationships.

    I’m also hosting a live Ask Me Anything on Sunday, November 29! This session will be free for everyone to attend. Future live sessions will be exclusively for paid subscribers, so if you'd like to join us for future conversations and support the work, consider becoming a paid subscriber to The Better Question.

    _______

    If this episode resonated with you, share it with someone who might need to hear it.

    To get in touch about the show: ajarutledgecoaching@gmail.com

    Thank you for listening to The Reality Between Us.

    Show More Show Less
    35 mins
  • When What Kept You Safe Keeps You Stuck | #20
    Nov 11 2026

    I think one of the most interesting things about CPTSD is how much it can affect our lives without us even knowing it. Especially when it comes from childhood trauma, because so much of what we learned about ourselves and the world happened before we even understood what was going on.

    And when you've been operating a certain way your entire life, how would you know there's another way? How would you know that something you've always considered part of your personality might actually be something you learned to do to survive? Or that the way you're interpreting what's happening in your relationships might have more to do with what happened years ago than what's happening today?

    In this episode, I'm sharing some of my own experiences with CPTSD, what I came to understand about myself through healing, and how those experiences shaped the way I saw myself, other people, and the world.

    In this episode, we explore:

    • How CPTSD can develop through repeated experiences and influence our identity, perceptions, and relationships.
    • Why protective adaptations developed during childhood can become so familiar that we mistake them for personality.
    • How emotional flashbacks can affect our ability to respond to present circumstances.
    • How beliefs shaped by earlier experiences can prevent us from recognizing and receiving the connection and support we want.

    Episode Thoughts to Sit With

    "But you have to start to learn who you are again. You have to experiment with ways you want to be in the world, literally trying things out, testing if this, you like this. How does this feel? What feels authentic to you? Even if it's completely contrary to how you think you're supposed to act in this situation or who you think you were and what people expect of you over here.”

    “... it's a journey and a process of like you're shedding and creating you simultaneously.”

    “They have a story that they believe about their life and what happens to them, and they're only going to pay attention to the parts of the dynamic that fit that story.”

    _____

    Join me over on Substack at The Better Question, where I've created a three-part Audio Notes collection called Self-Awareness as a Defense. It explores how self-awareness isn't always an indication of someone's desire to grow. Sometimes, it can actually function as a defense against growth.

    If you're interested in understanding that distinction, head over to The Better Question and explore the collection. While you're there, consider becoming a paid subscriber to support my work.

    _____

    If this episode resonated with you, share it with someone who might need to hear it.

    To get in touch about the show: ajarutledgecoaching@gmail.com

    Thank you for listening to The Reality Between Us.

    Show More Show Less
    32 mins
  • A Different Kind of Compatibility | #19
    Nov 4 2026

    We talk a lot about compatibility in relationships. Do we have the same values? Do we want the same things? Do we enjoy being around each other? But what about the way our minds work? Or how much we're growing as people? I think there are some really important parts of compatibility that we don't give nearly enough attention to, and sometimes those are the very things affecting why a relationship doesn't feel quite right.

    Have you ever been in a relationship where you just couldn't seem to connect with someone in certain ways? Maybe you couldn't have the kinds of conversations you wanted to have, or you started noticing that you and the other person were growing in very different directions. And sometimes you're both growing, but that doesn't necessarily mean you're growing together. These things can affect friendships, family relationships, and romantic partnerships, and I think they're worth paying more attention to.

    In this episode, we explore:

    • Why intellectual capacity and personal growth are often overlooked aspects of relationship compatibility.
    • How differences in the way people think, learn, and engage with ideas can affect connection and intimacy.
    • What happens when two people grow at different rates, even when both are committed to personal growth.
    • Why caring about someone doesn't necessarily mean you can connect with them in all the ways that matter to you.

    Episode Thoughts to Sit With

    “There are people in the world that if you can't stimulate my intelligence, nothing else is going to be stimulated.”

    “One person's trajectory of growth or rate of growth can outpace the other in such a way that they're not going to be compatible.”

    “...if I don't say anything about the ways that I'm impacted, now I'm self-abandoning, or if I'm going to say something so it doesn't happen again, now I'm teaching.”

    _______

    Join me over on Substack at The Better Question for more of what I'm thinking about and exploring.

    Last week I published When Shame Hides in Plain Sight, which builds on some of what I discussed in the podcast episode Under the Influence of Shame. I explore how shame doesn't always look the way we expect it to, and how it can show up in the very behaviors we assume mean someone doesn't feel shame at all.

    If you're interested, head over and read it. While you're there, subscribe or consider becoming a paid subscriber to support my work.

    _______

    If this episode resonated with you, share it with someone who might need to hear it.

    To get in touch about the show: ajarutledgecoaching@gmail.com

    Thank you for listening to The Reality Between Us.

    Show More Show Less
    18 mins
No reviews yet
In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.