In this episode of the eras series, we go back to one of the biggest choices public health ever made.
At the end of the nineteenth century, public health was out in the street. Rapid industrialization and mass immigration were colliding with growing urban poverty, and Progressive reformers and housing advocates were working alongside labor organizers to change the conditions that made people sick. For a couple of decades, that mission was pursued in earnest.
Then in 1910, Abraham Flexner published a report on American medical education. It was commissioned by the Carnegie Foundation and covertly funded by the American Medical Association, and its standards ended up deciding who got to practice medicine and who didn’t. Within fifteen years, 89 of the country’s 155 medical schools had closed, including five of the seven schools training Black physicians. Homeopathic and naturopathic programs went with them, and so did midwifery training. Community healers lost legitimacy and legal standing in one move.
At the same time, William Welch was building public health education at Johns Hopkins around the laboratory and handing housing and urban reform off to other fields. Welch and Flexner landed on the same answer: move the discipline into the clinic and the lab, away from the street-level work that used to define it.
I follow that choice through a brief Depression-era window back toward the old mission, and on to 1974, when Canada’s Marc Lalonde and Rockefeller Foundation president John Knowles made individual behavior the focus. By then, the individual body was the only unit of intervention anyone still had a mandate to touch.
Then I bring it back to our work. The shortage of Black doctors in underserved communities today, and the trust gap that shortage produces, has a paper trail that leads to 1910. If your organization is trying to rebuild trust with communities, or you’re being asked to do community engagement on a funder’s terms, this history is part of the work.
--
🔗 Stay Connected
Take the Quiz → Discover where your organization most needs storytelling
Let's connect on LinkedIn
Lean more about how we can work together at https://madisonmurphybarney.com/entangled-health
Reach out with questions and inquiries at mbarney@entangledhealth.com