Send us a text

What separates a good elk caller from a great one? It's not just technical skill – it's understanding the emotional language of elk. Joe McCarthy, the innovative force behind Slayer Calls, takes us deep into the psychology and mechanics of effective elk calling in this fascinating conversation.

Joe's journey from rural Idaho law enforcement to revolutionizing elk call design began with necessity in the field. When reeds would fail during hunts, he started making his own, developing a unique ability to match the specific sounds of individual elk. This hands-on approach eventually led to his partnership with Slayer Calls, where they've reimagined diaphragm call design with their distinctive half-inch by five-eighths frame that maximizes both sound richness and control.

The most compelling insight? "The worst bugler on the mountain is the actual elk." Joe shares stories of massive bulls making thin, scrawny sounds while smaller elk produce deep, resonant bugles – challenging everything hunters think they know about "perfect" calling. This unpredictability is why Joe advocates for versatility over perfection, building calls that allow hunters to express the emotional context behind elk vocalizations rather than just mimicking standardized sounds.

We explore the revolutionary Enchantress call, which allows hunters to produce both bugles and cow calls without a diaphragm – making quality calling accessible to those who struggle with mouth calls or hunt infrequently due to limited draw opportunities. Joe's philosophy of keeping hunting affordable shines through when he recounts successfully calling in elk using improvised Lipton iced tea bottles when he'd forgotten his equipment.

Whether you're a seasoned caller looking to refine your approach or a beginner trying to understand the fundamentals, Joe's practical wisdom about practicing control before volume and focusing on actual elk recordings rather than human demonstrations will transform how you think about communicating with elk in the field. Ready to speak elk? This episode is your masterclass.

Support the show