Send us a text
In this episode, Richard talks with Ted Peters about UFOs as a cultural phenomenon. A Lutheran theologian, Ted Peters has been a central figure in the long-standing dialogue among scientists, philosophers, and theologians. He has a long-standing interest in UFOs—now called UAPs (Unidentified Aerial Phenomena)—dating back to his childhood.
Although many of us tend to dismiss UAP believers as kooks, Ted stresses that they tend to take science and technology very seriously. We also noted the publication of an article in 2017 in The New York Times, which has contributed to more serious academic investigation into UAPs.
At the same time, Ted thinks that UAP believers may elevate science and technology too much, seeing them as the only means of saving society from self-destruction. The logic goes like this, if earthly science and technology cannot provide salvation, then perhaps an advanced science and technology from another planet will save us.
Since the 12th century, thinkers have debated whether the discovery of intelligent extraterrestrial life would undermine—perhaps even destroy—traditional religions. Ted did extensive surveying on this question. He discovered that most religious people, regardless of tradition—Christian, Jewish, Buddhist, etc.—do not see the prospect of extraterrestrial intelligence as a challenge to their faith.
Our discussion included the decline in public trust for science and technology. He emphasized the need for religious people to support scientists and defend evidence-based science. He also highlighted the battle between good, evidence-based science versus bad, “alternative” science that is not evidence-based. At the same time, Ted asserted that most people continue to trust good, evidence-based science. He noted that even the anti-vaccine movement grew out of an article published in a peer-reviewed scientific journal 25 years ago. Unfortunately, the article’s conclusions were deeply flawed and the journal subsequently retracted it. But, at the point, the anti-vaccine movement had already gathered its own momentum.
At the end of our interview, Ted stressed the difference between UAPs and the legitimate discussions in Astrobiology concerning the ethical and theological implications that would arise, if extraterrestrial life is discovered.
For further information, check out these sources.
Follow Ted’s blog, “The Voice of Public Theology,” on Substack, www.tedp.substack.com/
Ted’s book, UFOs: God's Chariots?: Spirituality, Ancient Aliens, and Religious Yearnings in the Age of Extraterrestrials, published by Weiser, 2014.
Helene Cooper, Ralph Blumenthal, Leslie Kean, “Glowing Auras and ‘Black Money’: The Pentagon’s Mysterious UFO Program,” The New York Times, 16 December 2017.