Podcast Show Summary

Guest Details

Judge Andrew J. Peck, retired U.S. Magistrate Judge and Senior Counsel at DLA Piper, joins the podcast to discuss the evolution of eDiscovery, predictive coding, and the legal industry's slow adoption of technology.

Key Takeaways

1. The Slow Adoption of TAR & AI – Despite landmark rulings endorsing predictive coding (TAR), the legal industry remains resistant to change, relying heavily on keyword searches instead of embracing newer, more efficient technologies.

2. Judicial Understanding & eDiscovery Challenges – Many judges are now more tech-savvy than the attorneys appearing before them, but the legal profession as a whole remains hesitant to incorporate advanced analytics, email threading, and AI-assisted review into their workflow.

3. The Future of Generative AI in eDiscovery – While AI holds immense promise, Judge Peck warns of potential "AI tax" concerns, where discovery disputes over prompts and validation could hinder adoption, much like early TAR battles.

Action Items

• Legal professionals must educate themselves on AI & eDiscovery tools – Judge Peck emphasizes that technology can enhance efficiency, but lawyers must invest time to understand its application in legal practice.
• Judges should facilitate tech adoption by encouraging efficiency over outdated methods – Courts should push back on inefficient discovery practices, leveraging cost-saving technology where appropriate.
• Law firms should proactively engage their IT teams and tech experts – Understanding the scope of data production (e.g., hyperlink documents, Slack messages, texts) before stipulating discovery agreements can prevent costly mistakes.

Chapters with Timecodes

📌 [00:00:02] – Introduction by hosts Daniel Gold and Brandon Mack
📌 [00:01:32] – Welcome to Judge Andrew Peck
📌 [00:02:09] – Judge Peck’s history with the NeLI Conference
📌 [00:05:46] – The industry’s slow adoption of TAR and predictive coding
📌 [00:09:07] – Challenges with lawyer resistance to technology
📌 [00:15:15] – Expanding scope of eDiscovery: text messages, Slack, and hyperlinked documents
📌 [00:25:02] – The rise of generative AI in eDiscovery: promise & pitfalls
📌 [00:32:35] – The importance of validation and defensibility in AI-assisted review
📌 [00:37:04] – Future of AI in legal discovery and potential rule changes
📌 [00:42:05] – Advice for law students on embracing legal technology
📌 [00:44:50] – Closing remarks and upcoming Nellie Conference in 2025

Most Compelling Quote

"AI won’t replace lawyers, but lawyers who fail to embrace AI may find themselves replaced." – Judge Andrew J. Peck (Ret.)

Resources:

• Visit the NeLI's website at: www.ediscoveryleadership.org
• Visit UMKC School of Law: law.umkc.edu
  
• Hon. Andrew J. Peck (Ret.): https://www.dlapiper.com/en-us/people/p/peck-andrew-j
• Daniel Gold: https://www.linkedin.com/in/danielegold
• Brandon Mack: https://www.linkedin.com/in/brandonmack

Our Social Media:

• LinkedIn
• X (Twitter)
• Instagram
• Facebook