Why Me? cover art

Why Me?

Why Me?

By: Why Me? Suspense Stories with The Shadow Teller
Listen for free

About this listen

Ever stared into the shadows and felt them stare back? Ever questioned reality when the inexplicable occurs, whispering, 'Why Me?' This is your invitation to explore those chilling moments. 'Why Me?' is a suspense-horror anthology podcast, in the spirit of The Twilight Zonee, Tales from the Crypt, and Are You Afraid of the Dark?, delivering weekly uncanny stories and psychological thrillers designed to haunt your thoughts. Tune in for eerie encounters and tales of supernatural dread that will make you question everything.Why Me? Suspense Stories with The Shadow Teller
Episodes
  • Creepy Horror: Undeliverable
    Jun 28 2025

    New chilling psychological horror! A mailman's mundane routine becomes a terrifying loop concealing a dark secret. Dive into this eerie tale of guilt & unexplained phenomena. A scary story for Twilight Zone & supernatural thriller fans! Follow 'Why Me?' for haunting audio drama.

    Show More Show Less
    11 mins
  • The Kind Monster of Kai (Psychological Horror)
    Jun 27 2025

    New scary psychological horror! Kai's kind music brings terrifying erasure. An uncanny suspense tale for Twilight Zone & Tales from the Crypt fans. Get your chilling audio drama. Follow 'Why Me?' now for more creepy stories!

    Show More Show Less
    9 mins
  • Playback: A Chilling Tale of Twisted Memory
    Jun 22 2025

    Some places hold memories captive... and some secrets refuse to stay buried. In this chilling episode of 'Why Me? Hosted by The Shadow Teller,' we dive into 'Playback: A Chilling Tale of Twisted Memory,' where revisiting the past unleashes a terrifying truth.

    Leo returns to an isolated lake house, seeking solace in old memories, armed with an ancient MP3 player and their favorite song. But with each playback, the cherished past begins to corrupt, revealing distorted truths and a haunting, dark secret that Leo never remembered. This psychological horror audio drama masterfully builds dread, exploring grief, betrayal, and the horrifying realization that the real monster might be closer than you think.

    Inspired by the unsettling narratives of The Twilight Zone and the macabre insights of Tales from the Crypt, this suspenseful story delivers unexplained phenomena and haunting encounters that will linger long after the credits roll. If you crave chilling tales of psychological dread and stories where personal demons become terrifying realities, this episode is your next obsession.

    Don't miss a single terrifying tale. Follow 'Why Me? Hosted by The Shadow Teller' on Spotify to immerse yourself in more chilling audio dramas and psychological thrillers every week. Prepare to face the ultimate reflection."


    Show More Show Less
    10 mins

What listeners say about Why Me?

Average Customer Ratings

Reviews - Please select the tabs below to change the source of reviews.

In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.