In December 1900, three lighthouse keepers vanished without a trace from the remote Flannan Isles, a cluster of windswept rocks off the western coast of Scotland. The relief vessel arrived to find a chilling scene: a meal uneaten, a clock stopped, and no sign of life. What happened to the men of the Flannan Isle Lighthouse?

In this episode, we explore the historical facts, the strange details of the discovery, and the enduring theories—from violent storms and rogue waves to madness, murder, and the supernatural. Was it simply a tragic accident, or is there something more haunting at work on Flannan Isle?

👻 What You'll Hear:

• A retelling of the eerie disappearance of Thomas Marshall, James Ducat, and Donald MacArthur
• The unsettling discoveries made by the lighthouse relief crew
• Contemporary reports and official investigation details
• Theories ranging from natural disaster to paranormal phenomena
• Literary and cultural references inspired by the mystery

What do you think happened to the Flannan Isle keepers? Message us on Instagram or email us your theory—we’ll feature our favorites in next week’s episode.

🔗 Links & Extras:

• Map of the Flannan Isles

Join the conversation: Follow us on social media for updates, discussions, and to share your thoughts on this case.

Lurk on Facebook
Lurk on Twitter
Lurk on Instagram
We have a new Facebook Group join in the discussion! Lurk Podcast Facebook Group

New Merch Store!

We are also now found on YouTube- Lurk on YouTube

Background Music Royalty and Copyright Free Music
Intro and Outro music purchased through AudioJungle
with Music Broadcast License (1 Million)

Send us a text

Support the show