One Giant Leap

The Apollo Program in Historical Context

One Giant Leap explains the hows and whys of the Apollo program, and the whys are what makes the story coherent and compelling. Fishman starts with the context of what the Soviets were accomplishing in the late 1950s, and how that affected attitudes in the US. Next we get President Kennedy's evolving thoughts on whether the US should even try to compete with the Soviets, eventually deciding that "If we can beat the Soviets to the moon, we should," and finally the well-known declaration about landing a man on the moon before the decade is out.

Next comes the hard part, figuring out how to get to the moon, and developing the technology to get there. Again, Fishman puts the situation in context, noting the state of technology in the late fifties & early sixties. Even integrated circuits were new. Space suits, rockets, the lunar lander, and the 1 cubic foot computer were all fascinating chapters in the book. I loved hearing all these details of the decade-long program where so many pieces had to come together to get the success of Apollo 11.

This is not a biography of astronauts, but rather a biography of the Apollo mission, with historical context to make every point clear and comprehensible. The narration was excellent--clear and enjoyable to listen to. I loved this book and hope you will too.

12 of 12 people found this review helpful

Worth a Listen

I’m kind of a space and history geek, so I enjoyed this book. But even I thought it could have used some editing. Those who don’t have a burning interest in the subject will likely find it tedious.

4 of 4 people found this review helpful

This book explains why this was the last leap

Charles Fishman gives an entertaining and instructive account of the mad race to the moon. He details the harrowing mishaps and courageous acts of the astronauts. Much of the scientific advances are set in the context of the sixties. The Vietnam war was raging and the anti-war movement was in full swing. Even though Kennedy put the moon race expenses as second to the amount Americans spent on tobacco products. Having lived through this time I was reminded of how exciting it was.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful

Loved It

Loved this book! I learned so many interesting things about the race for the moon

3 of 4 people found this review helpful

Fascinating story

I was in my twenties when the events of this story of sending a man to moon happened - but I knew only a very small bit of the story - this book should be listened to or read by all of us. It is a tribute to so much intelligence, courage and practicality that it is simply astounding and inspiring.

One Giant Mishmash

In the 1960s we had rockets that could put men in orbit and take us to the moon. Now we don't. In the 1960s publishers had editors and fact checkers. If this book is any indication, now we don't.

The bottom line is that this book is badly organized and much too long. The author is very inefficient in his writing, which is made worse by extreme repetition. There are also some glaring factual errors. "Frank Wright" was not one of the Wright Brothers (how could this error possibly happen in a book on aerospace?). Ed White was not a Mercury astronaut (again, a fundamental error).

My estimate is that this book could have covered the same material much more cogently and elegantly in 10 hours instead of 15 (which would reduce the hardcover page count from 480 to 320). Apparently, the author and publisher didn't think a good editing was worth the trouble.

Nevertheless, the book is worth reading for Apollo junkies. The material about the Apollo Guidance Computer is fascinating. The information regarding Kennedy's private misgivings about the program is new (at least to me) and interesting. The final chapter summing up the meaning of Apollo has a lot of interesting parts, but, again, is much longer than it needs to be. I think that the author is probably right that Apollo ushered in the age of computer technology more than an age of exploration.

If you already know a lot about Apollo and have the time and the patience, you might want to listen or read this. If you are looking for a good general retrospective on the Apollo program or Apollo 11, there are many better choices, including A Man on the Moon by Andrew Chaikin, Failure Is Not an Option, by Flight Director Gene Kranz, or Carrying the Fire, by Apollo 11 Command Module Pilot Michael Collins.

The narration is pretty good, thank goodness.

Enjoyed it

Especially interesting was the frank discussion of the economics and wavering political support related to NASA through the years as well as the impact, years later, of technology we take for granted today, that then, was built from scratch to facilitate the moonshot.

Giant read

Riveting, well constructed account of a now misunderstood time in American history. An easy listen.

Interesting but repetitive

Lots of good new detail about the computers and science of space flight. However too much unnecessary repetition. The book could have been half as long while still retaining content.