
How to Settle Arguments Fairly
Failed to add items
Sorry, we are unable to add the item because your shopping cart is already at capacity.
Add to basket failed.
Please try again later
Add to Wish List failed.
Please try again later
Remove from Wish List failed.
Please try again later
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
-
Narrated by:
-
By:
About this listen
Arguments don’t need winners; they need resolution. Andrew and Cat share calm, practical ways to defuse conflict at home, with friends, and at work—so everyone feels seen, heard, and respected.
Big ideas- Stay calm first. Regulated nervous systems make regulated conversations.
- Listen to understand, not to win. Most “arguments” are unmet needs in disguise.
- Name the real issue. Clarify what the conflict is actually about before debating solutions.
- Feelings + needs > accusations. Use “When you ___, I feel ___; I need ___; could you ___?”
- Define the desired outcome. Agree on “what good looks like” before you continue.
- Two truths can coexist. Your perspectives can both be valid.
- Take breaks at impasses. Timeouts prevent escalation; return when cooler.
- Bring a neutral third party when needed. Therapist, mediator, or trusted friend.
The Fair-Argument Playbook
- Pause & breathe. Lower the temperature (box breathing: 4–4–4–4).
- State intent: “My goal is for us to understand each other and find a solution we both can live with.”
- Clarify the issue: “What do you think this is really about?”
- Reflective listening: “What I’m hearing is… Did I get that right?”
- Share with NVC: “When X happened, I felt Y. What I need is Z. Would you be willing to ___?”
- Outcome check: “By the end of this, I’d love for us to ___.”
- Perspective-swap: Briefly argue the other person’s side to show you get it.
- Agree on next step: One concrete action each.
- If stuck: “Let’s pause for 20–60 minutes and revisit at ___. We’re on the same team.”
Handy scripts
- Red-flag day: “Quick heads-up: I’m low-sleep/overloaded today. If I seem short, it’s not about you.”
- Boundary without blame: “I want to keep talking, and I need a 15-minute reset to stay respectful.”
- Repair after rupture: “I’m sorry for my tone earlier. Your point matters; can we try again?”
For parents & teams
- Ask kids/teammates to share how they’re feeling + what they need (not who’s “right”).
- Normalize check-ins: “What outcome are you hoping for?”
- Celebrate process wins (no interrupting, calm tone, staying on topic), not just “winning.”
When to get help
- Repeating stalemates on big life choices (money, parenting, moving, family size).
- Patterns of contempt, stonewalling, or scorekeeping.
- Bring in a counselor/mediator to create safety and structure.
Resources mentioned
- Nonviolent Communication — Marshall B. Rosenberg (feelings/needs framework)
Glimmers
- Andrew: Watching his son thrive at a first MMA practice—and the respectful community vibe.
- Cat: A surprise flower delivery (courtesy of Andrew and his mom) brightened a tough week.
Keep in touch
Questions, coaching, or topic requests: hello@fiveyearyou.com
More episodes & freebies: fiveyearyou.com
IG: @fiveyearyou
Affiliate note: As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases (Store ID: amp09-20 | Tracking...
No reviews yet
In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.