Is Autism Overdiagnosed? How Psychiatrists Assess Adults
Failed to add items
Add to basket failed.
Add to Wish List failed.
Remove from Wish List failed.
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
-
Narrated by:
-
By:
Is autism overdiagnosed? In Part 2 of our autism series, two adult psychiatrists ask why U.S. autism prevalence went from about 1 in 150 to about 1 in 31, what should count as a mental disorder, and how to evaluate an adult who arrives asking whether they have autism.
What we cover
* Why autism diagnoses have climbed, from about 1 in 150 children around 2000 to about 1 in 31 in 2022, and whether better recognition or a shift toward naming ordinary traits as disorders explains most of the rise.
* What DSM-5 changed: Asperger's syndrome and childhood disintegrative disorder folded into autism spectrum disorder, no other specified autism category, and the AuDHD label that appeared once autism and ADHD could be diagnosed together.
* How the share of autistic children with intellectual disability fell from about three in four to 30 to 40 percent, and a paper that counted an IQ of 86 as average or higher.
* What should count as a mental disorder: social values, anything professionals treat, statistical rarity, distress or disability, and Jerome Wakefield's harmful dysfunction model, compared with the DSM's distress or impairment wording.
* Why the disorder label matters for accommodations, the wide gap between unable and unwilling, 15-minute diagnoses, Stanford's 38 percent disability registration and ads for LSAT accommodations.
* The adult evaluation: a conversational mental status exam drawn from the Autism Mental Status Exam (interest in others, eye contact, gesture, language, pragmatics, stereotypy, sensory sensitivities, preoccupations), the childhood history, and the main mimics.
Clinical takeaways
* Set a conversational frame. Small talk about hobbies and interests shows spontaneous social behavior that a question and answer interview hides.
* Ask patients to describe their life without diagnostic terms. It can take several questions before a patient stops reporting labels such as executive dysfunction or rejection sensitivity.
* Read each exam finding against its mimics: poor eye contact can come from social anxiety, paranoia or severe depression, and stereotyped movements can be tics, seizures or tardive dyskinesia after years of antipsychotics.
* A true neurodevelopmental disorder has a childhood course. Ask about school, repeated grades, special education, testing referrals, friendships and a best friend, even when the history is decades old.
* When the first major dysfunction appears in adulthood with no other diagnosis, consider maladaptive personality style, burnout or a poor fit with work, while allowing that autistic traits may contribute.
* If the answer to the question of autism is no, the visit is not finished: give a formulation of where the distress comes from and what to do about it, which may take more than one meeting.
Watch the video
Watch the full episode, with chapters and slides, on YouTube: Is Autism Overdiagnosed? How Psychiatrists Assess Adults.
Related episodes
* Autism Diagnosis Explained: DSM-5 Criteria, Autistic Traits & the Difficult Differential
* Diagnostic Hierarchy Explained: Why Patients Get 5 Diagnoses
* ADHD Is Not the Only Diagnosis: Differential and Diagnostic Hierarchy
For education only. Not medical advice.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit psychofarm.substack.com