• Poppi Worthington: Three Courts, Three Answers (England, 2012)
    Nov 7 2026

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

    Episode notes

    At two minutes to six on the morning of the twelfth of December, 2012, a 999 call was made from a house in Barrow-in-Furness. Poppi Worthington was thirteen months old. She had been put to bed healthy the evening before, and she was unknown to child protection.

    Her death was examined in three different rooms, under three different standards of proof, and each reached a different kind of answer. A Family Court judge found, on the balance of probabilities, that her father sexually assaulted her, and could not say how she died. A coroner found that she was assaulted that night, that the assault did not kill her, and that she died of asphyxia in an unsafe sleeping environment. No criminal court has ever heard the evidence. Her father has never been charged, and he denies any wrongdoing.

    This episode follows the primary record: Mr Justice Peter Jackson’s two fact-finding judgments, the High Court judgment setting out the findings of the second inquest, and published reporting on the police watchdog’s report, the serious case review and the prosecution decisions. It covers the first hours after her death, the delays and lost evidence, a safeguarding meeting that accepted an inaccurate medical explanation without challenge, the ten months the surviving children spent at home before proceedings began, a first inquest held without evidence, and a safeguarding board that decided no review was needed.

    For social workers and other professionals, six strands: the first hours after an unexpected infant death, explanations accepted without challenge, protecting surviving children while another agency investigates, what professionals knew and did not connect, who reviews the review, and how we explain different standards of proof to families.

    Content note: This episode discusses the death of a child and a finding of sexual assault. The details are not described. The findings are attributed to the judge or coroner who made them, and nobody has been convicted.

    Sources: F v Cumbria County Council and M (Fact-Finding No. 2) [2016] EWHC 14 (Fam); Cumbria County Council v M and F (Fact-Finding No. 1) [2014] EWHC 4886 (Fam); R (Worthington) v HM Senior Coroner for Cumbria [2018] EWHC 3386 (Admin); published reporting on the serious case review (2016) and the police watchdog’s findings (2017).

    Show More Show Less
    59 mins
  • BJay Johnstone: The Notification That Was Never Recorded (Tasmania, 2012)
    Nov 4 2026

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

    BJay Johnstone: The Notification That Was Never Recorded (Tasmania, 2012)

    On the tenth of August, 2012, a nurse at the Mersey Community Hospital rang child protection about an unborn baby. The call was never recorded, and nobody phoned her back. When she rang again two months later, the baby was two days from being born.

    BJay Adam Johnstone was born on the fourteenth of October, 2012. He lived for forty-five days. Before his birth he had been flagged, and the day after he was born child protection rated his future risk as high. Over the next nineteen days, a midwife, a child health nurse, two child protection workers, two family support workers and a GP saw him. A member of the public in England rang police to report her concern. By the afternoon of the day he was taken to hospital, child protection was discussing closing the case.

    This episode follows the finding of Tasmanian Coroner Olivia McTaggart, handed down in June 2017 after twenty-three hearing days. It covers the lost notification, the decision to discharge him, the bruises that were each explained and accepted, the handover between services that left nobody holding the risk, and the police report that never reached child protection. It also explains the legal outcome: the father pleaded guilty to ill-treating BJay and was sentenced in 2013, but has never been convicted of causing his death. The coroner found, on the civil standard, that he inflicted the fatal head injury.

    For social workers and other professionals, the episode draws out six strands: pre-birth planning and discharge decisions, bruising in infants who cannot move, handover and ownership of risk, family violence and coercive control, information held in silos, and how reassurance spreads through a case.

    Content note: This episode discusses the death of an infant and family violence. The medical detail is not described graphically.

    Sources: Finding of Coroner Olivia McTaggart into the death of BJay Adam Johnstone (Tasmania, 26 June 2017), news coverage of the inquest, and the Tasmanian Government's response to the recommendations.

    Show More Show Less
    52 mins
  • The Baby the System Never Met: Teegan Hayes Case file
    Oct 31 2026

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

    Teegan Rose Hayes was born healthy in Devonport, Tasmania, in October 2011. Twenty-four days later, she died. The state's child protection service did not know she existed until she was in intensive care, even though it had been receiving reports about her family since 1997.

    Fifteen notifications were made before she was born. Thirteen were closed at the first stage. In 2018, Coroner Olivia McTaggart found that Teegan's death was accidental, caused by suffocation while she slept in her mother's arms. She also found that it could have been prevented if child protection had properly assessed and acted on the warnings.

    This episode follows the notifications one by one, from a paediatrician's concern about a toddler to an anonymous call three months before Teegan's birth. It looks at cumulative harm, at what happened to the file after her death, and at the findings of the service's own review.

    For professionals, the episode draws out six practice strands: closing notifications at the front door, cumulative harm, reliance on self-report, assessing parents with intellectual disability, the unborn baby, and what a service does after a child dies. It ends with six reflective questions.

    This episode discusses the death of an infant. Details are kept non-graphic. There was no inquest, so the episode draws on the coroner's written finding and news reports, and it says where information could not be found.

    Hosted by a social worker with more than fourteen years of industry experience.

    Subscribe, rate and share with someone who works in child protection.

    Show More Show Less
    54 mins
  • The Principal Who Called: Katelynn Sampson Case file
    Oct 28 2026

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

    Katelynn Sampson: (Case File)

    In the early hours of 3 August 2008, a woman in a Parkdale apartment building in Toronto called 911 and said her daughter had choked on bread. Paramedics found seven-year-old Katelynn Sampson dead, with about seventy injuries on her body. Two months earlier, a judge had signed an order making the woman on the phone Katelynn's permanent legal guardian.

    This is the case file on Katelynn Sampson. I trace how her mother, struggling with addiction, placed her with a friend to avoid losing her to the system. I cover how a guardianship order was granted without the court hearing about the guardians' criminal history or their earlier child removals. I also cover how a school principal's call about burns and bruises fell into the gap between two overlapping agencies, and how nobody ever spoke to Katelynn herself. I follow the 2012 guilty pleas of Donna Irving and Warren Johnson to second-degree murder, and the 2015–16 coroner's inquest. It ended on what would have been her fifteenth birthday with a verdict of homicide and 173 recommendations. I say plainly what I couldn't find, including how many of those recommendations were carried out.

    I also draw on more than fourteen years of social work practice to look at six areas, with a focus on the child's voice. The episode ends with questions for professionals.

    Chapters (approximate):

    • Cold open: the 911 call
    • Bernice Sampson and the decision to ask a friend
    • Donna Irving and Warren Johnson: what the records held
    • Four agencies, one family
    • The school: absences, bruises and the calls
    • The guardianship hearings
    • The last three months
    • The pleas and sentences
    • The inquest and the 173 recommendations
    • Six strands for professionals
    • Questions to take back to your practice

    Content note: The episode discusses the abuse and death of a child. The script deliberately leaves out some details from the court record. discretion advised

    Show More Show Less
    53 mins
  • Two Years Missing: Christian Choate Case file
    Oct 24 2026

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

    Christian Choate: Nobody's Gonna Miss Him Anyhow

    In the first days of April 2009, a thirteen-year-old boy died in a dog cage in a trailer in Gary, Indiana. He weighed less than fifty pounds. Within a week, his father and stepmother had buried him in concrete behind the trailer park and driven the rest of the family to Kentucky. When anyone asked where Christian Choate was, they said he had run away. For two years, nobody filed a report.

    This is the case file on Christian Choate. He was found because his sister, who had been forced to help hide his body, finally told their mother where it was. I follow the Indiana Department of Child Services' contact with the family, including:

    • eight investigated allegations;
    • a 2005 custody order that gave Christian to a father with a felony record and a substantiated abuse finding;
    • complaints in 2007 and 2008 that focused on the household and not on each child;
    • a school that wrote about Christian's absences, after which his father withdrew him to homeschool him;
    • a doctor who was told Christian was being locked up at night and didn't report it.

    I also cover the Times of Northwest Indiana's finding that at least thirteen people may have known, DCS's statement that it did everything it legally could, the former child protective chief who said "We failed him," and the 2012–13 pleas and sentences. Riley Choate received eighty years and Kimberly Kubina thirty-five. I say plainly what I couldn't find, including the DCS and Ombudsman Bureau reviews, which were never released, and any discipline for anyone outside the family.

    I also draw on more than fourteen years of social work practice to look at six areas, from what an investigation looks at to what "everything it legally could" is worth. The episode ends with questions for professionals.

    Chapters (approximate):

    • Cold open: "He ran away"
    • Christian's early life and the 2005 custody order
    • The household and its history
    • DCS contacts in 2007 and 2008
    • The school, the homeschool decision and the doctor
    • Christian's last years and Christina's story
    • The death and the two years of silence
    • Discovery and the thirteen people who may have known
    • DCS's response
    • The courts: pleas, sentences and appeal
    • Six strands for professionals
    • What I could not find
    • Questions to take back to your practice

    Content note: The episode discusses the abuse and death of a child, including confinement in a cage, and systemic failures in child protection.

    Show More Show Less
    49 mins
  • The Boy Who Told Everyone: Anthony Avalos full case file
    Oct 21 2026

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

    Anthony Avalos: Thirteen Calls, One Home (Case File)

    Episode description (for the podcast feed or YouTube):

    On 20 June 2018, a woman in Lancaster, California, called 911 and said her ten-year-old son had fallen. Anthony Avalos was taken to hospital in cardiac arrest, with a severe brain injury and bruising and burns from head to toe. He died the next day.

    Anthony was not a child nobody knew about. Over about three years, teachers, counsellors, a vice principal, a sheriff's deputy, an aunt and an uncle all contacted Los Angeles County to say something was wrong in his home. The county visited, scored the risk, and left him there.

    This is the case file on Anthony Avalos. I start with who he was, and I draw on his fourth-grade teacher's account. I trace the county's file from the first hotline call, through risk scores that rated the family high and were overruled, to a voluntary program meant for low-risk cases, and a sheriff's investigation closed after one failed attempt to reach the man who lived in the home. I explain why the number of calls depends on who you ask. The county said thirteen, the family's lawyer said sixteen, and the home was visited eight times. I also cover:

    • the county's own review and the Los Angeles Times investigation that challenged it;
    • the state auditor's findings;
    • the 2023 trial, where Heather Barron and Kareem Leiva were each found guilty of murder with the special circumstance of torture and sentenced to life without parole.

    I say plainly what I couldn't find, including any disciplinary outcome for the workers involved and the result of the defendants' appeals.

    I also draw on more than fourteen years of social work practice to look at six areas, and end with questions for professionals.

    Chapters (approximate):

    • Cold open: the 911 call
    • Who Anthony was
    • Heather Barron and Kareem Leiva: what the records held
    • 2014: the first calls and the voluntary program
    • 2015: the vice principal, the deputy and the uncle
    • 2016: the last calls
    • Thirteen, sixteen or eight: counting the warnings
    • The last days
    • The county's review and the audit
    • The trial and the sentences
    • Six strands for professionals
    • Questions to take back to your practice

    Content note: The episode discusses the abuse and death of a child. The script deliberately leaves out some details from the court record. Discretion advised

    Show More Show Less
    50 mins
  • Seven Investigations: The Danieal Kelly full case file
    Oct 17 2026

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

    Danieal Kelly: On the Books (Case File)

    On 4 August 2006, in the middle of a record heat wave, an ambulance was called to an apartment in West Philadelphia. Danieal Kelly, fourteen, had been dead for several hours. She had cerebral palsy and weighed about forty-two pounds. The grand jury wrote that in her last days she begged for something to drink, until she could manage only one word: water.

    Danieal was not hidden from the authorities. The city's Department of Human Services had opened seven investigations into her family. A private contractor was being paid with public money to visit her home at least twice a week.

    This is the case file on Danieal Kelly. I start with who she was before the system lost her. In Phoenix she sang and went to an award-winning school, and one teacher called her "one of the sweetest students ever enrolled in this program." I trace the years of DHS contact, the private agency whose caseworker had the mother sign forms for visits that hadn't happened, and the fact that she was never enrolled in a Philadelphia school. I cover the grand jury's 258-page report and its central finding: a workplace where failure was rewarded with promotion, not punished. I follow the prosecutions, which came in several rounds:

    • Andrea Kelly pleaded guilty to third-degree murder and received twenty to forty years.
    • Daniel Kelly, the caseworker Dana Poindexter and the contractor's director each received two and a half to five years in 2011.
    • Laura Sommerer received probation.
    • The agency's founders were convicted of fraud in federal court.
    • No supervisor was ever charged.

    I say plainly what I couldn't find, including Andrea Kelly's current parole status and the terms of the civil settlement.

    I also draw on more than fourteen years of social work practice to look at six areas: invisibility, paper that replaces reality, the cumulative record, monitoring of private providers, accountability, and what a child protection system owes a child who cannot speak for herself. The episode ends with questions for professionals.

    Chapters (approximate):

    • Cold open: the heat wave and the ambulance
    • Who Danieal was: Youngstown, Phoenix and the girl who sang
    • Her parents and the move to Philadelphia
    • Seven investigations
    • MultiEthnic: the contractor and the blank forms
    • The people at DHS
    • Her last days
    • The cover-up and the grand jury report
    • The prosecutions
    • The federal fraud case
    • Six strands for professionals
    • Questions to take back to your practice

    Content note: The episode discusses the abuse and death of a child. The script deliberately leaves out some details from the court record. Discretion advised

    Show More Show Less
    52 mins
  • The Missing Boy of Canberra (Australia): Bradyn Dillon full Case file
    Oct 14 2026

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

    The Bradyn Dillon Case

    In February 2016, nine-year-old Bradyn Dillon was killed by his father in Canberra. In the two years before that, teachers, child protection, police, a GP, and a Victorian court had seen him. At least eight agencies across the ACT and Victoria had contact with him.

    This episode follows the case from the first school reports of bruising to the 2021 coronial findings. It covers how a father's lies went unchecked, how a disclosure made in Victoria never reached Canberra, how a case was closed because a frightened child "wasn't saying anything", and how one unenrolment left Bradyn off every list.

    Coroner Margaret Hunter found that Graham Dillon was a "master manipulator" and the sole person responsible. She also described "sliding door moments" where the system could have taken a different path, and made 17 recommendations.

    For professionals, the episode draws out six practice strands: hearing the child, cumulative harm and domestic violence, how assessments are passed on, cross-border information sharing, tracking children outside school, and workload and supervision. It ends with six reflective questions.

    This episode discusses child abuse and the death of a child. Details are kept non-graphic. Content is drawn from news reporting of the inquest and findings, and the episode says where information could not be found.

    Hosted by a social worker with more than fourteen years of industry experience.

    Subscribe, rate and share with someone who works in child protection.

    Show More Show Less
    51 mins