Child Protection Files: Real Cases, Real System Failures cover art

Child Protection Files: Real Cases, Real System Failures

Child Protection Files: Real Cases, Real System Failures

By: Jay Gill
Listen for free

This Season's Biggest Deal | $0.99/mo for 3 months + $20 Audible bonus

Auto-renews at $8.99/mo. after 3 months - terms apply.
Summary

Child Protection Files covers real child protection cases in depth- cases that have already gone through the courts, inquests, and public inquiries- so nothing discussed here is speculation about an ongoing matter.

Each episode goes beyond the headlines: the full timeline, the trial, the judge's own words, and the public inquiry that followed. But the real focus is the profession itself: the caseworkers, police officers, and doctors involved; the caseloads and supervision failures behind the individual decisions; and what, if anything, changed in child protection practice afterwards.

This isn't true crime for shock value. It's a closer look at how these systems work, where they break down, and what the people doing this work today can actually learn from cases that came before.

New episodes are posted [insert your schedule once you've settled on one]. Episodes contain detailed descriptions of child abuse and neglect; listener discretion is strongly advised throughout

If you have any feedback or want any specific case covered, please email me at files@childprotectionfiles.com

Jay Gill 2026
Social Sciences True Crime
Episodes
  • Poppi Worthington: Three Courts, Three Answers (England, 2012)
    Nov 7 2026

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

    Episode notes

    At two minutes to six on the morning of the twelfth of December, 2012, a 999 call was made from a house in Barrow-in-Furness. Poppi Worthington was thirteen months old. She had been put to bed healthy the evening before, and she was unknown to child protection.

    Her death was examined in three different rooms, under three different standards of proof, and each reached a different kind of answer. A Family Court judge found, on the balance of probabilities, that her father sexually assaulted her, and could not say how she died. A coroner found that she was assaulted that night, that the assault did not kill her, and that she died of asphyxia in an unsafe sleeping environment. No criminal court has ever heard the evidence. Her father has never been charged, and he denies any wrongdoing.

    This episode follows the primary record: Mr Justice Peter Jackson’s two fact-finding judgments, the High Court judgment setting out the findings of the second inquest, and published reporting on the police watchdog’s report, the serious case review and the prosecution decisions. It covers the first hours after her death, the delays and lost evidence, a safeguarding meeting that accepted an inaccurate medical explanation without challenge, the ten months the surviving children spent at home before proceedings began, a first inquest held without evidence, and a safeguarding board that decided no review was needed.

    For social workers and other professionals, six strands: the first hours after an unexpected infant death, explanations accepted without challenge, protecting surviving children while another agency investigates, what professionals knew and did not connect, who reviews the review, and how we explain different standards of proof to families.

    Content note: This episode discusses the death of a child and a finding of sexual assault. The details are not described. The findings are attributed to the judge or coroner who made them, and nobody has been convicted.

    Sources: F v Cumbria County Council and M (Fact-Finding No. 2) [2016] EWHC 14 (Fam); Cumbria County Council v M and F (Fact-Finding No. 1) [2014] EWHC 4886 (Fam); R (Worthington) v HM Senior Coroner for Cumbria [2018] EWHC 3386 (Admin); published reporting on the serious case review (2016) and the police watchdog’s findings (2017).

    Show More Show Less
    59 mins
  • BJay Johnstone: The Notification That Was Never Recorded (Tasmania, 2012)
    Nov 4 2026

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

    BJay Johnstone: The Notification That Was Never Recorded (Tasmania, 2012)

    On the tenth of August, 2012, a nurse at the Mersey Community Hospital rang child protection about an unborn baby. The call was never recorded, and nobody phoned her back. When she rang again two months later, the baby was two days from being born.

    BJay Adam Johnstone was born on the fourteenth of October, 2012. He lived for forty-five days. Before his birth he had been flagged, and the day after he was born child protection rated his future risk as high. Over the next nineteen days, a midwife, a child health nurse, two child protection workers, two family support workers and a GP saw him. A member of the public in England rang police to report her concern. By the afternoon of the day he was taken to hospital, child protection was discussing closing the case.

    This episode follows the finding of Tasmanian Coroner Olivia McTaggart, handed down in June 2017 after twenty-three hearing days. It covers the lost notification, the decision to discharge him, the bruises that were each explained and accepted, the handover between services that left nobody holding the risk, and the police report that never reached child protection. It also explains the legal outcome: the father pleaded guilty to ill-treating BJay and was sentenced in 2013, but has never been convicted of causing his death. The coroner found, on the civil standard, that he inflicted the fatal head injury.

    For social workers and other professionals, the episode draws out six strands: pre-birth planning and discharge decisions, bruising in infants who cannot move, handover and ownership of risk, family violence and coercive control, information held in silos, and how reassurance spreads through a case.

    Content note: This episode discusses the death of an infant and family violence. The medical detail is not described graphically.

    Sources: Finding of Coroner Olivia McTaggart into the death of BJay Adam Johnstone (Tasmania, 26 June 2017), news coverage of the inquest, and the Tasmanian Government's response to the recommendations.

    Show More Show Less
    52 mins
  • The Baby the System Never Met: Teegan Hayes Case file
    Oct 31 2026

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode!

    Teegan Rose Hayes was born healthy in Devonport, Tasmania, in October 2011. Twenty-four days later, she died. The state's child protection service did not know she existed until she was in intensive care, even though it had been receiving reports about her family since 1997.

    Fifteen notifications were made before she was born. Thirteen were closed at the first stage. In 2018, Coroner Olivia McTaggart found that Teegan's death was accidental, caused by suffocation while she slept in her mother's arms. She also found that it could have been prevented if child protection had properly assessed and acted on the warnings.

    This episode follows the notifications one by one, from a paediatrician's concern about a toddler to an anonymous call three months before Teegan's birth. It looks at cumulative harm, at what happened to the file after her death, and at the findings of the service's own review.

    For professionals, the episode draws out six practice strands: closing notifications at the front door, cumulative harm, reliance on self-report, assessing parents with intellectual disability, the unborn baby, and what a service does after a child dies. It ends with six reflective questions.

    This episode discusses the death of an infant. Details are kept non-graphic. There was no inquest, so the episode draws on the coroner's written finding and news reports, and it says where information could not be found.

    Hosted by a social worker with more than fourteen years of industry experience.

    Subscribe, rate and share with someone who works in child protection.

    Show More Show Less
    54 mins
No reviews yet
In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.