Why Smart Tech Companies Miss the Warning Signs | Tim Banting cover art

Why Smart Tech Companies Miss the Warning Signs | Tim Banting

Why Smart Tech Companies Miss the Warning Signs | Tim Banting

Listen for free

View show details

This Season's Biggest Deal | $0.99/mo for 3 months + $20 Audible bonus

Auto-renews at $8.99/mo. after 3 months - terms apply.
Summary

The warning signs are often there. The difficult part is telling a successful company that its next big idea might be the wrong one.

Tim Banting, founder and principal analyst of So What? Now What?, joins Simon Dudley on B4Obvious—Before It Was Obvious for a conversation about competitive intelligence, unified communications, technology strategy and the uncomfortable business of seeing change before people want to acknowledge it.

Tim’s journey begins with the British Army’s Royal Signals and work alongside intelligence analysts during the Cold War. Watching small signals become meaningful patterns helped shape the approach he later brought to market intelligence: look beyond the announcement and work out what it means—and what somebody should do next.

The conversation follows his move through Cisco and Microsoft into industry research, including Current Analysis and Omdia, before establishing his own business. Having worked on both sides of the research relationship, Tim offers a perspective on how vendors buy intelligence and how analysts turn information into useful advice.

Tim and Simon revisit changing approaches to enterprise telephony, expanding product portfolios, softphones and Cisco’s Umi consumer telepresence bet. They discuss what happens when companies become insulated from customer reality, and why selling another feature is not the same as solving another problem.

Microsoft, Skype, Lync and Teams provide further examples of a collaboration market that kept changing direction. The discussion also considers AI-generated content, authenticity and the value of judgment when information is increasingly easy to produce.

For younger professionals, Tim explores practical education, trades and the idea of T-shaped skills: deep expertise in one area combined with the communication and commercial abilities that make that expertise useful.

In this episode:
- Military intelligence, weak signals and identifying consequential patterns.
- Competitive intelligence inside Cisco and Microsoft.
- Vendor strategy, customer needs and the danger of corporate bubbles.
- Unified communications, IP telephony and changing collaboration platforms.
- The difference between reporting news and delivering actionable insight.
- AI, career resilience and developing T-shaped skills.

Listen if you work in competitive intelligence, product strategy, AV, IT or unified communications—and want to ask better questions before the market makes the answers obvious.

Follow B4Obvious for candid conversations about business decisions and industry change. Hosted by Simon Dudley.

Guest-page companion

Conversation topics

  • Introduction to Tim Banting and His Journey
  • Military Intelligence and Its Impact
  • The Rise of IP Telephony
  • Cisco's Role in the Telecommunications Revolution
  • Challenges and Innovations in Video Technology
  • The Business Model Behind Cisco's Success
  • The Shift from Cisco to Microsoft
  • Transitioning from Vendor to Analyst
  • Navigating Market Research and Insights
  • Skepticism Towards AI and Future Trends
  • Advice for the Next Generation
  • The Importance of T-Shaped Skills
  • Unanswered Questions and Reflections
  • Nostalgia and Industry Insights
  • Corporate Acquisitions and Market Dynamics
  • The Future of Neat and Market Positioning
  • Market Trends and Competitive Analysis
  • Challenges in the Tech Industry
  • The Role of AI in Business
  • Data Privacy and Compliance Issues
  • Emerging Technologies and Market Opportunities
  • Meeting Room Technology and Refresh Rates
  • The Evolution of Video Conferencing
  • AI and Its Implications in Meetings
  • The Future of Video Technology
  • Legal and Ethical Considerations in AI
  • The Impact of GDPR on Technology
  • Market Opportunities in Europe
  • Personal Reflections and Global Perspectives

About Tim Banting

Tim Banting is a market intelligence analyst and the founder of So What Now What, as described in this interview. His work focuses on turning announcements and market information into useful implications and actions. In conversation with Simon, he looks back at the experiences that shaped his approach to technology, observation and independent analysis.

Full guest page, show notes, articles and transcript

  • Connect with Tim Banting on LinkedIn
  • Watch the full interview
  • Download show notes (.md)
No reviews yet
In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.