Episode 59: Toxic Positivity
When “Good Vibes Only” Goes Wrong
- “Just stay positive.” “Everything happens for a reason.”
- “At least it could be worse.”
We might mean well. But what happens when the person hearing those words just needs us to listen?
This week, Greg, Rich, Liam, and Sarah talk about toxic positivity, the pressure to put a cheerful spin on things when life is hard.
We share where we’ve heard it, how we’ve used it ourselves, and what helps us feel heard.
We get into faith, chronic pain, disability, childhood experiences, and the urge to fix things for people we love.
We also talk about comparing our struggles, the pressure to be “strong,” and setting boundaries when someone keeps brushing our feelings aside.
There’s room for hope, gratitude, anger, and grief in the same conversation.
00:00 Intro
01:18 What is toxic positivity?
06:14 Faith, good intentions, and feeling unheard
14:53 Why we rush to fix someone’s pain
22:11 Taking ownership when our words hurt
22:41 “Other people have it worse”
29:13 Can gratitude and grief exist together?
30:39 Social media and the parts we don’t see
32:14 When a boss or caregiver dismisses you
33:59 Asking what kind of support someone wants
34:27 Boundaries when someone keeps minimising your feelings
35:41 What honest hope sounds like
37:47 What’s on Your Heart This Week?
44:30 Closing thoughts and weekly challenge
The next time someone tells you something difficult, pause before offering reassurance.
Ask: “Would you like me to listen or would you like some help with the next step? And what would be useful?”
Then give them time to answer.
If you’re struggling yourself, try: “Today, I feel… And what I could use is…”
It might be rest, company, help, or space. It’s okay if you don’t know yet.
More episodes: https://kindnessrx.org/listen
Our online support groups: https://kindnessrx.org/groups
Mentioned by Sarah: Opportunities for Ohioans with Disabilities. Explore employment support and eligibility:
https://ood.ohio.gov/information-for-individuals/services/vocational-rehabilitation-services
Further watching: Susan David’s TED Talk, The Gift and Power of Emotional Courage:
https://www.ted.com/talks/susan_david_the_gift_and_power_of_emotional_courage
If this conversation helped, follow the podcast and share it with someone who could use it.
Contains strong language and discussion of grief, depression, chronic illness, disability, childhood trauma, and abuse. This is peer support and general information, not medical advice.
In the US, call or text 988 for crisis support, or visit https://988lifeline.org. If there is immediate danger or a medical emergency, call 911.