Episodes

  • Lesbian Cruise Confidential: Danny Pellegrino Spills Everything Iconic

    Lesbian Cruise Confidential: Danny Pellegrino Spills Everything Iconic
    Aug 25 2025
    Danny Pellegrino turns Bravo commentary into life advice I didn’t expect.

    Danny Pellegrino (Everything Iconic) joins me for a wide-ranging chat about all things Bravo, WORKOUT, Dad Life, and everything in between. Danny’s mix of humor and cultural insight makes him one of the sharpest voices covering reality TV, and our chat is equal parts hilarious and revealing. We break down WORKOUT Season 3, Episode 3 — Jackie Warner’s lesbian cruise, workplace hookups, and the mysterious disappearance of the mud run. Danny shares his obsession with lesbian drama, thoughts on Bravocon, and how gay representation on reality TV has evolved. But then he turns the tables on me. Danny asks about my dating life, my so-called uncle fetish, and why my audience deserves more of my authentic self. His advice about SHOW PONY is blunt, funny, and surprisingly inspiring — and I actually take it. If you love Bravo, reality TV, and conversations that go deeper than gossip, this one’s essential listening.
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 32 mins
  • From Rachel Zoe to Jackie Warner: Reality TV’s Wild West with Elizabeth Kott

    From Rachel Zoe to Jackie Warner: Reality TV’s Wild West with Elizabeth Kott
    Aug 19 2025
    It’s a sunny Hollywood backyard chat with Too Niche? host and vintage Bravo expert Elizabeth Kott — the woman who convinced me to start Show Pony in the first place. Elizabeth worked with Rachel Zoe back in the day (yes, she shares what it was like to work for her), and she knows the Bravo era, LA culture, and reality TV from the inside out. This episode is a double-header:
    • Workout Season 3, Episode 2 Recap – Jackie Warner, Sky Sport & Spa, and all the Bravo chaos of 2007.
    • Netflix’s The Biggest Loser Documentary (“Fit for TV?”) – how reality TV mocked fat people and why cruelty passed as entertainment.
    Plus, we get into the good stuff:
    • I spill tea on producing Tori Spelling’s reality show and the behind-the-scenes of negotiating brand deals in reality TV.
    • The disgusting state of LA’s The Grove — how it’s turned into a dystopian influencer catwalk where everyone dresses like a whore (thank you, social media).
    • The toxic state of online culture and unattainable beauty standards that keep recycling from one era to the next.
    • LA then vs. now: from Rachel Zoe’s fashion reign to Jackie Warner’s fitness empire to today’s influencer mess.
    It’s Bravo nostalgia, reality TV industry secrets, and an unfiltered state-of-LA breakdown — all from the backyard, with iced drinks and plenty of shade.
    Show More Show Less
    45 mins
  • Manifesting The Lion's Gate Portal with Lara Marie Schoenhals from S.U.P - Season 3 Of Workout Recap!

    Manifesting The Lion's Gate Portal with Lara Marie Schoenhals from S.U.P - Season 3 Of Workout Recap!
    Aug 11 2025
    S.U.P's Lara Marie Schoenhals and I unpack vintage Bravo mess, tats I got while high on pills, and our dogs wage squeaky toy warfare all in honor of Workout season 3! Show Pony tackles the Season 3 premiere of WORKOUT with a Sexy Unique Podcast crossover event: Lara Marie Schoenhals joins me to break down the vintage reality TV chaos of Workout Season 3 — and create some new drama of our own. We cover Jackie Warner’s new hair, her new girlfriend, and behind-the-scenes Bravo gossip you won’t hear anywhere else. I teach Lara about the politics of Fire Island Pines, I confess the worst tattoos I’ve ever gotten (thank you, prescription painkillers), and our dogs go feral in a squeaky toy showdown. It’s Bravo nostalgia, pop culture gossip, and unhinged storytelling — from the queen of Sexy Unique Podcast and the host of Show Pony. If you love Bravo reality shows, messy lesbian love stories, or chaotic podcast energy, this episode’s for you.
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 4 mins
  • Reunion Bombshell & Spray Tanning My Labubu (Show Pony Ep. 16)

    Reunion Bombshell & Spray Tanning My Labubu (Show Pony Ep. 16)
    Aug 4 2025
    After last week’s confrontation with Andy Cohen, I found out the Workout reunion was available to stream after all. So this episode is me walking that back—recapping the reunion, eating shit, and trying to make it right. The original plan was to do this with Justin Martindale while we got a spray tan from Sugared and Bronzed. But he overslept, so I ended up doing the recap in my living room with the spray tan girlies. It ended up being the most fun segment ever… until I realized the mics didn’t record. So this one’s mostly narrated. I also meet up with my longtime best friend and reality TV producer Lindsay Weiglein on the roof of the mall to try and salvage what’s left—of the episode and of my credibility. Somewhere in the chaos, we end up spray tanning a Labubu.
    Show More Show Less
    32 mins
  • FINALE FEVER: Confronting Andy Cohen and Cruising A Gay Park with H Alan Scott

    FINALE FEVER: Confronting Andy Cohen and Cruising A Gay Park with H Alan Scott
    Jul 27 2025
    It’s the Workout Season 2 finale recap... but things get messy real fast.
    First, John corners Andy Cohen in New York after their SiriusXM show to ask about the missing reunion episode — and it turns into a heated moment caught on camera. Then back in LA, H. ALAN SCOTT (Newsweek, Parting Shot) joins for a deep dive into the finale, but the conversation quickly spirals into a glorious sideshow covering:
    • public cruising in a West Hollywood park
    • rich mean gays
    • What is Sniffies
    • John's Dick pics
    • horrible dog owners
    • a performance artist with pantyhose on her head rolling a giant ball of twine through the interview
    • and a baby Labubu perched on H. Alan's lap through it all.
    What starts as a recap becomes a performance piece. Welcome to Show Pony.
    Show More Show Less
    42 mins
  • LOUIS PEITZMAN - SUPERSIZED Bravo Deep Dive. Gay Porn, Graveyards, and The Iraq War on WORKOUT?

    LOUIS PEITZMAN - SUPERSIZED Bravo Deep Dive. Gay Porn, Graveyards, and The Iraq War on WORKOUT?
    Jul 21 2025
    In this supersized episode of Show Pony, I’m still technically on vacation—but when pop culture wizard Louis Peitzman (BuzzFeed, Vulture, NY Mag) agrees to sit down, you clear your damn schedule. Louis is a walking Bravo encyclopedia and a Beverly Hills local with real reality tea. We go deep—from lesbian chaos in the Jackieverse to gay porn subplots, graveyard visits, the Iraq War, and whether stressful pregnancies cause gayness (??). It all connects. Somehow. Doug’s life hangs in the balance, and it might be the most unhinged ep yet. Buckle up, pony people. 🎤 Topics Include:
    • The bleak state of modern reality TV
    • Jackie’s graveyard moment
    • Beverly Hills insider scoop
    • Iraq War / gay porn parallels??
    • “Do stressful pregnancies make you gay?” (We investigate.)
    👉 Subscribe, rate, and saddle up.
    🧠 Guest: Louis Peitzman | @LouisPeitzman
    📺 Rewatch: Workout S2E7
    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 4 mins
  • The Emergency Provincetown Episode with Eric Maxwell

    The Emergency Provincetown Episode with Eric Maxwell
    Jul 14 2025
    This is what commitment looks like, people. I flew, ferried, cabbed, collapsed—and still crawled into my Provincetown hotel bed to deliver this emergency episode of Show Pony with my BFF and towel-clad co-host, Eric Maxwell. Yes, we’re sweaty. Yes, we’re possibly hungover. Yes, we do recap Episode 6, Season 2 of Bravo’s Workout (Jackie loses it, Doug is DONE, and the emotional violence is at an all-time high). And somehow, despite being horizontal and under-air-conditioned, we remain ICONIC. 🧴 What’s inside:
    – A Workout recap with zero prep and maximum passion
    – Provincetown gossip, vacation rants, and sunscreen regrets
    – Friendship, filth, and feral hotel energy
    – John trying to be a podcaster and a slut at the same time Don’t miss this chaotic, short, and absolutely necessary mess of an episode. 👉 Subscribe. Like. Tell Jackie Warner we’re still obsessed. #ShowPony #JohnArthurHill #Provincetown #WorkoutBravo #JackieWarner #GayPodcast #BravoPodcast #EmergencyPod #LGBTQComedy #EricMaxwell #HotelConfessional
    Show More Show Less
    20 mins
  • JESSE from WORKOUT On The Record

    JESSE from WORKOUT On The Record
    Jul 6 2025
    One of Workout’s original breakout stars, Jesse joins John for his first in-depth, on-the-record conversation about the show — and it’s not what anyone expected. John thought this would be a light, campy reunion. Instead? Tears were shed. Spiritual truths were dropped. And what unfolded was one of the most surprising, moving, and human interviews Show Pony has ever done. Jesse opens up about fatherhood, marriage, and how his time on Bravo shaped him — for better and worse. This isn’t just nostalgia. It’s transformation.
    Show More Show Less
    47 mins