Lie for the Team? cover art

Lie for the Team?

Lie for the Team?

Listen for free

View show details

This Season's Biggest Deal | $0.99/mo for 3 months + $20 Audible bonus

Auto-renews at $8.99/mo. after 3 months - terms apply.
Summary
The Thin Blue Line – Brotherhood or BetrayalIn our previous discussion, we examined the contradiction between an officer willing to sacrifice his life protecting an American citizen and an officer who, under different circumstances, violates that citizen’s rights.But I want to take this examination one step further.Because the abuse of governmental power does not always end with the individual who commits it.Sometimes the greater problem is what happens afterward.The fellow officers who witnessed it. The supervisors who review it. The administrators who investigate it. And the department that may decide its reputation is more important than the truth.Now consider another contradiction.How is it that an officer may be willing to risk his life protecting a stranger, yet be unwilling to risk his career protecting that same stranger from misconduct committed by a fellow officer?Think about that.He may be willing to confront an armed criminal. But is he willing to confront a dishonest colleague?He may be willing to run toward gunfire. But is he willing to stand before his sheriff and say that another deputy has violated the Constitution?He may be willing to risk his life in the line of duty. But is he willing to risk losing the approval of his fellow officers?That is an extraordinary question about human nature. And more particularly, about the relationship between loyalty and power.The expression ‘thin blue line’ means different things to different people. For many, it represents courage, sacrifice, professional solidarity, and the difficult responsibility of protecting society.There is nothing inherently dishonorable about solidarity among people performing dangerous work.But solidarity becomes a serious problem when it is transformed into unquestioning loyalty to the institution or to individuals within it.Because the oath of a public officer is not a promise to protect his colleagues from accountability. It is an obligation to discharge the duties of his office under the Constitution and the law.And when those obligations conflict, the choice tells us something important about the character of the individual.Imagine that a deputy witnesses another deputy threatening a citizen without lawful justification.He watches the confrontation escalate. He hears the citizen ask what law he has violated. He observes the officer becoming increasingly aggressive. And eventually, the citizen is handcuffed and arrested.What does the second deputy do?Does he intervene? Does he ask what offense was committed? Does he attempt to restore order? Or does he simply stand there, allowing his colleague to continue?Now consider what happens when the written incident reports are prepared.Does the second deputy accurately describe everything he observed? Or does he omit the misconduct?Does he repeat the first officer’s version of events without independent examination?Does he characterize the citizen’s objections as aggression while overlooking the conduct that provoked the confrontation?And what happens if body-camera footage later contradicts the report?Here we begin to see the difference between an individual abuse of authority and institutional protection of that abuse.One officer may have exceeded his authority. But others may now be participating in protecting the misuse of that authority.That is an entirely different level of responsibility.And once again, we encounter human nature.Fear of retaliation. Fear of losing friendships. Fear of being ostracized. Fear of losing a career. The desire to belong. The instinct to protect one’s own group. The temptation to avoid conflict when doing what is right may carry personal consequences.These are ordinary human weaknesses.But within institutions entrusted with coercive governmental power, those weaknesses can have extraordinary consequences.Because the citizen is not confronting an ordinary private organization. He is confronting an institution capable of depriving him of liberty.And if that institution protects its own misconduct, where does he turn?Now consider the role of the supervisor.A complaint is filed. The citizen presents a recording. The recording raises serious questions about the officer’s conduct.Does the supervisor independently examine the facts? Does he identify the applicable law? Does he determine whether the officer possessed the authority he exercised?Or does he begin with an assumption that the officer acted properly because he belongs to the department?And what happens when the department’s public statements are contradicted by the evidence?Does protecting the institutional reputation become more important than correcting the wrongdoing?This is how the exercise of power can acquire another dimension.The institution begins exercising its power not merely against the citizen, but in defense of its own authority.And what began as an improper encounter may become an institutional failure of accountability.The problem can extend beyond the ...
No reviews yet
In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.