1.2 million Americans. Forty-seven days. The end of the First World War — and a commander carrying a private grief almost no one knows about. Our conversation with Dr. Mitch Yockelson.
One afternoon in 1915, a general in El Paso grew tired of a telephone that wouldn’t stop ringing, picked it up, and barked “Hello” into it. The reporter on the other end went quiet, then asked him to confirm the fire at his home in San Francisco.
He hadn’t heard. By the time he reached the house, his wife and three of his children were dead; only his young son had been carried out alive. He rode the train west sobbing the whole way, identified them at the morgue, and stood in the wreckage saying the same thing over and over. They had no chance.
His name was John J. Pershing. Three years later he would command the largest and deadliest battle the United States has ever fought — and almost no one you know can name it.
It isn’t Gettysburg, Antietam, or D-Day, or the Battle of the Bulge. It’s the Meuse-Argonne: forty-seven days in the autumn of 1918, more than a million American soldiers, over 26,000 of them killed. It broke the German army and ended the First World War at eleven o’clock on the eleventh of November. And it has slipped almost entirely out of American memory.
Pushing back against that forgetting is more or less Dr. Mitch Yockelson’s life’s work. He’s an investigative archivist at the National Archives, the author of Forty-Seven Days, and about as authoritative as it gets on Americans in the Great War. He tells it from the paper — the orders, the after-action reports, the letters home — and then he tells it through the people who were there. A few he left me thinking about:
The future of the American century was standing in those woods. A field-artillery captain named Harry Truman, firing the guns. A young tank officer named George Patton, shot on the first morning. Douglas MacArthur, going forward without a helmet. What did the Argonne make of them?
A “Lost Battalion,” cut off behind German lines and running out of everything — and the battle-pigeon that lost a leg carrying out the message that saved them. It’s still on display at the Smithsonian.
A conscientious objector, rejected twice, who walked out of that forest having captured 132 Germans.
Two New York socialites who volunteered as nurses, saw what the field hospitals held, and never made it home — for a reason that will stay with you longer than you’d like.
A second enemy, invisible, killing Americans in their own trenches faster than the Germans could.
And a young man from Baltimore — thirty minutes up the road from where we recorded this — who was killed at 10:59 on the final morning. One minute before the guns fell silent. Running at a machine-gun crew that was waving at him to stop.
Mitch answers all of it, the way only someone who has held the documents in his hands can.
He also has a theory about why the country forgot its own largest battle. I’m not going to give it away.
If you want more history told like this, subscribe — it’s free, and it’s the surest way to catch the next one. And if you’d like to help us keep making them, become a paid subscriber; that’s what keeps this going.
— John Fenzel, Heroes’ Path
Support the show
Learn • Serve • Lead • Remember
🎧 Never miss an episode—subscribe on YouTube or grab the RSS.
Follow & join the conversation ➔ @HeroesPath on X, Instagram, LinkedIn • #HeroesPathPodcast