Send us Fan Mail
Is Halloween secretly pagan, or did the Church build it from the start? The honest answer is that serious historians still disagree, and this episode walks through why.
For years, I let the "Halloween is pagan" claim stand by staying quiet. This time I went back to the sources, including a 2024 reassessment by historian Ronald Hutton, and found that the story is more contested than either side admits. I also found two places where my own earlier essay was wrong, and I correct them here.
In this episode:
- How All Hallows' Eve, All Saints' Day, and All Souls' Day developed, and why the November 1st date is disputed
- What the Liber Pontificalis does and does not say about Pope Gregory III
- The evidence for and against the Church absorbing Samhain, including syncretism, the Pantheon, and the Hill of Ward excavations
- What Hutton rejects about the "Celtic New Year," and what he does not
- The Pomona myth and how it spread for two centuries
- Souling, the Danse Macabre, and where trick-or-treat really comes from
- A pastoral conclusion on why Christians do not have to give up the season
Read the written version with full citations: Hallowed Halloween? The Christian Origins of a Contested Holiday
From the Wilderness is a podcast about faith, scripture, and honest questions, hosted by Sean Williams.
Read the essays this series is built on at From the Wilderness on Substack. If this episode meant something to you, check out Sean Williams Designs, faith-based apparel built around the Armor of God and St. Michael, at https://seanwilliamsdesigns.com. Firs time listeners use code "WILDERNESS" at checkout for 20%.