Field Manual For Pastors - Recentered Group cover art

Field Manual For Pastors - Recentered Group

Field Manual For Pastors - Recentered Group

By: Ed Underwood & Joshua Gordon
Listen for free

This Season's Biggest Deal | $0.99/mo for 3 months + $20 Audible bonus

Auto-renews at $8.99/mo. after 3 months - terms apply.
Summary
Field Manual for Pastors is a conversation between mentor to pastors Ed Underwood, founder of Recentered Group, and lay pastor Josh Gordon of TheLeadPastor.com. Ed spent forty years leading churches, soldiers, and firefighters through real crises. Each episode covers one practical piece of advice for a specific situation pastors face in ministry: a stalled decision, a difficult elder, a change that needs to happen carefully. Listen in for advice you learn in the trenches, not in seminary.2026 Christianity Spirituality
Episodes
  • Responding to the "You Never Listen..." Criticism
    Oct 26 2026

    Ed Underwood unpacks what's really behind the accusation "you never listen" and how a unified leadership team takes the sting out of it.

    This episode of our ongoing criticism series tackles a phrase that lands hard no matter how much work went into actually hearing someone: "you never listen." Ed Underwood walks through what's usually going on underneath that accusation and why it almost never has much to do with actual listening.

    We get into the difference between someone who's genuinely hurt and someone who's simply unhappy they didn't get their way, along with practical tools Ed's church used to prevent this kind of conflict before it started, from calendar planning to communication channels for smaller announcements.

    What You'll Learn
    • Why "you never listen" almost never means what it sounds like it means
    • How staying unified as a leadership team takes the personal sting out of criticism
    • The difference between someone who's genuinely hurt and someone who simply didn't get their way
    • What the wrong response to this accusation actually sounds like
    • When this kind of conflict crosses into needing church discipline
    • How storyboarding calendar priorities in advance can prevent this problem entirely
    • Why announcements are such a recurring flashpoint in church culture
    • What practical communication channels can absorb smaller complaints before they escalate
    Key Takeaways
    • Remind yourself the leadership team is unified before engaging with an accusation like this
    • Ask someone to get specific about what "not listening" actually looked like to them
    • Shepherd someone who's genuinely hurt instead of simply reaffirming a decision
    • Bring in other leaders when the same conflict keeps repeating without resolution
    • Plan your calendar's priorities together in advance to head off recurring conflicts
    • Create smaller communication channels so minor concerns don't need a public platform
    • Never respond to this kind of criticism through text, email or social media
    Show More Show Less
    19 mins
  • Handling the 'A Lot of People Think' Criticism
    Oct 19 2026

    Every pastor has heard the phrase, and every pastor dreads it. Someone tells you "a lot of people" are unhappy about a decision, and suddenly you're trying to defend yourself against a crowd you can't see and can't count. In this episode of the criticism series, Ed Underwood breaks down exactly why this vague kind of pushback works so well and what to do the moment you hear it.

    Ed's answer is simple but not easy: ask who, specifically, is upset. We talk through a real situation from a worship team decision, why this question protects both the pastor and the people actually involved, and what it means for a church's health when this kind of vague criticism keeps showing up.

    What You'll Learn

    • Why the phrase "a lot of people" is one of the most effective manipulative tools in a church
    • How to respond the first time you hear a vague reference to unnamed critics
    • Why sincere concerns and manufactured pressure require very different responses
    • What it means when someone still won't identify who's actually upset
    • How a pattern of vague criticism can reveal deeper issues in a church's culture
    • Why some seasons of ministry require a pastor to consider whether it's time to move on
    • What it looks like to lead through disagreement without giving away a false win
    • Why criticism should still never be answered through text, email or social media

    Key Takeaways

    • Ask who exactly is upset before responding to a vague claim of widespread concern
    • Set the expectation early that this kind of criticism will always be followed up on
    • Consider the source, since a trusted voice raising a concern deserves more weight than a stranger's
    • Refuse to give a decision away just because someone implies broad opposition
    • Treat a repeating pattern of vague criticism as a signal about your church's overall health
    • Bring people who are actually concerned into a direct, honest conversation
    • Recognize when the real issue is a leadership team, not a single decision
    Show More Show Less
    24 mins
  • When Someone Brings Up Your Past Mistakes
    Oct 11 2026

    This episode launches a new run inside the Field Manual for Pastors focused entirely on criticism, and Ed Underwood starts with the passage that changed how he receives it. In 2 Samuel 16, a man throws stones and curses at King David, and instead of striking back, David wonders out loud if God might be speaking through it. For Ed, that single moment reshaped forty years of how he handled being criticized.

    From there we get specific. What do you do when someone drags up a mistake you already owned, apologized for, and moved past? Ed shares stories from his own ministry, including a season where an old failure kept getting used against him, and walks through how to tell the difference between someone who is still genuinely hurt and someone using an old wound as a tool.

    What You'll Learn

    • How the story of King David and Shimei can reshape a pastor's whole relationship with criticism
    • Why criticism, even from an inappropriate source, can still carry something worth hearing
    • The four recurring ideas this series keeps coming back to
    • Why criticism should never be answered through email, text or social media
    • What it feels like when someone uses your own vulnerability against you
    • Common mistakes pastors make when an old failure resurfaces
    • How to recognize when someone hasn't actually let go of a past hurt
    • What it means to recognize when someone is speaking in code about an unresolved issue

    Key Takeaways

    • Sit with criticism before reacting, and ask whether there's something true in it worth owning
    • Build a small circle of people you trust enough to talk through hard feedback with
    • Never respond to criticism in writing, since it can be picked apart and used against you
    • When an old mistake resurfaces, ask what's really going on rather than getting defensive
    • Avoid pressuring someone into forgiving you, since that adds pressure rather than relieving it
    • Watch for a pattern of the same issue resurfacing in more general terms, and address it directly
    Show More Show Less
    28 mins
No reviews yet
In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.