Brutally Honest BYU Pod cover art

Brutally Honest BYU Pod

Brutally Honest BYU Pod

By: Josh Crowley
Listen for free

This Season's Biggest Deal | $0.99/mo for 3 months + $20 Audible bonus

Auto-renews at $8.99/mo. after 3 months - terms apply.
Summary

BYU sports. Unfiltered opinions. Questionable expertise. Two brothers bleeding blue. Come for the Utah slander, stay for the Greg Wrubell glazing.

2026 Josh Crowley
Basketball Football (American)
Episodes
  • BYU’s Holy War Heartbreak: Where Do We Go From Here?
    Nov 11 2026

    BYU drops a painful Holy War to Utah, and Josh and Nate are working through it. Four interceptions, missed opportunities, and a comeback that fell just short—what decided this game, and what needs to change?

    But the season isn’t over. With BYU landing at No. 10 in the College Football Playoff rankings, there’s still plenty to play for. We discuss the renewed playoff hope, whether we actually want another shot at Utah, and why Baylor is anything but a routine bounce-back game.

    Plus: why the Holy War belongs on rivalry weekend, Kendra’s unintentionally devastating postgame snack selection, our Baylor score predictions, and some early BYU basketball takes.

    Would you rather get a rematch with Utah in the Big 12 Championship or take an at-large playoff spot? Let us know in the comments.

    Subscribe to Brutally Honest BYU Pod for unfiltered BYU talk with Josh and Nate. Cougs by a billion. Forever.

    #BYU #BYUFootball #GoCougs #HolyWar #CollegeFootball #CFP #Big12

    Show More Show Less
    31 mins
  • The Best (and Worst) Game of the Year | BYU vs. Utah
    Nov 4 2026

    The best—and worst—game of the year is here. Bring on the Holy War.

    Josh and Nate are leaning into the nerves, the rivalry, and some serious 1996 vibes as BYU heads to Salt Lake City to face Utah. We explain why we like this matchup for the Cougs, why Bear Bachmeier and the passing game should take center stage, and what BYU’s defense can do to make life difficult for Devin Dampier.

    Plus: LJ Martin’s availability, Preston Rex’s return, the special teams concerns we can’t ignore, and why recent struggles against UCF and Arizona State haven’t shaken our confidence.

    We also get into what makes this rivalry personal, where passionate fandom crosses the line, Morgan Scalley’s approach compared with Kyle Whittingham’s, and why “it’s just another game” will never work for us. There’s even time for a uniform rant and a score prediction that requires Utah to finish with negative points.

    BYU fans: confident, terrified, or both?
    Utah fans: give us all the smoke. Drop your predictions below.

    Subscribe to the Brutally Honest BYU Pod for more unfiltered BYU football talk.

    #BYUFootball #HolyWar #BYUvsUtah #GoCougs #CollegeFootball

    Show More Show Less
    38 mins
  • BYU’s Excuses Are Getting Old | Was UCF a Fluke—or a Warning?
    Oct 29 2026

    A week after beating Notre Dame, BYU leaves Orlando with a crushing 39–31 double-overtime loss to UCF—and plenty of questions. Josh goes solo this week to break down the missed opportunities, predictable playcalling, and why the travel and emotional-letdown excuses aren’t cutting it.

    Where was the offensive creativity? Why did throwing beyond the sticks feel like a trick play? And was this just BYU’s worst Saturday—or a warning about what’s ahead?

    Plus, a message for the Notre Dame fans celebrating in our comments, a look ahead to Arizona State’s Halloween visit to Provo, and Josh and Nate’s score predictions as the Cougars try to get back on track before the Holy War.

    Nate is out battling a kidney stone this week. Keep him in your thoughts and prayers—we need our guy back!

    👇 What concerns you most after UCF? Leave your take and your BYU–ASU score prediction in the comments.

    Subscribe to the Brutally Honest BYU Pod for honest takes, brotherly banter, and the highs and lows of Cougar football.

    #BYUFootball #GoCougs #Big12Football #BYUvsASU #BrutallyHonestBYU

    Show More Show Less
    19 mins
No reviews yet
In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.