great yarn

This book listens well if yo know something about the rigging of a sailing ship. If you are new to this world you will probably get lost in the incredible detail and and miss the truly hard, yet amazing, life of a sailor.

17 people found this helpful

Sailing to Mexican California

Being a native Californian, I've read several histories of the area and many of them cite passages from Richard Henry Dana's "Two Years Before the Mast". I hesitated to buy the audiobook since I found the English rather archaic, the original book having been published in 1840. But I took the plunge and was pleasantly surprised.

Dana's later, distinguished career as a maritime lawyer came through in his scholarly prose and I came to enjoy his writing style. Why did the Harvard educated son of a prominent Boston family ship out as a common sailor? His book answers this question and hints of his later advocacy for the oppressed and as a foremost abolitionist.

Dana's "Before the Mast" is a vivid account of life aboard a merchant ship from a deckhand's perspective. His descriptions of sail and rigging handling get a bit technical but he does it so well that even I, a landlubber, generally understood the varied and often dangerous tasks of a seaman. And I could see Mexican California as Dana described it.

The narrator, Jim Killavey, did a superb job of conveying Dana's brilliant grasp of events and sensitivity to the human condition. This book is truly a classic.

29 people found this helpful

Spectacular book

I am a leisure sailor and I found this book truly amazing. It gives an incredible insight in a sailor's life in the mid 19th Century. It also gives an intriguing perspective on an important but obscure part of America's history: the start of the colonisation of California by US American inhabitants. I am not a native English speaker so I cannot assess the quality of the accent used by the narrator, but I was very happy with the style of the audiobook.

20 people found this helpful

Timeless yarn

This book gives incredible insight into what it was like to be a common sailor back in the days of the "tall ships." A must listen for anyone into history - or sailing. Read very well in what sounds like an authentic "Yankee" voice.

19 people found this helpful

Essential California history and vivid story

This book is a jewel in that it captures every day life in the 1830s in a way that was very improbable. The documentation by an educated man on a seafaring adventure is time travel for us.It is a must read for anyone interested in California history with its description of California under Spanish rule. It is rich with nautical methods and terminology which compel the reader to dig deeper into sailing knowledge.

Poor narration mars the story

The story is a decent, but not spectacular, example of the old-time "sea story" genre. The narrator has a modest, but noticeable, New England accent, which fits the book.

Unfortunately, the narration is deadpan and monotone, and has been audio-edited very, very badly. Chapter headings follow on to the last sentence of the preceding chapter with no pause at all, as if part of a single run-one sentence.

Sailing terms are mispronounced.

I'll make a note of the narrator, in order to avoid other books which he has done.

Unexpected disorder

Would you try another book from Richard Henry Dana and/or Jim Killavey?

Dana was one of my favorite authors in the Harvard Classics or Five Foot Book Shelf and will remain so. Listening to this narrator is like listening to pigs playing Mozart, and be payed to do so.

What did you like best about this story?

The authors descriptive narration is dragged down by the reader.

How did the narrator detract from the book?

From page one or was it simply his first mono tonal attempt at ruining a literary classic.

Was Two Years Before the Mast worth the listening time?

NO

Any additional comments?

I have noted the narrator as one to never listen to again and I will delete the purchased book, it is to bad that someone such as Marsters or Brick could not have narrated the book I would buy it again

meh

But for the horrible narration, this book might have been a five out of five. The narrator has a strong New England accent, and his reading of the text is painfully choppy, with a long pause after every sentence. He also mispronounces all of the sailing terms, which is annoying to any veteran of sea terminology. This book should be read in print to preserve the real and plentiful virtue of the narrative against such inept narration.

5 people found this helpful

boring

I gave this book a three star rating because of the abismal reading, probably on a par with a seventh grade student. The reader had obviously not done any research into correct pronunciation and gave the impression of being thoroughly bored by his job. This spoils an excellent historical document which is well written and more than worth the read, but not the listen.

5 people found this helpful

Stultifying

I had read this years ago as a child and now wonder how I ever got through it. I think what truly kills this book is the awful narration. Think of all of the boring teachers, professors, or instructors you have suffered through and then think of this narrator, who I think was going for a "matter of fact" tone, but instead merely achieved excruciatingly boring.

3 people found this helpful