Colette is worried about her daughter not finding a suitable man and remaining unmarried. She tries to persuade Abigail to accept the offers of marriage but she argues back, wanting to focus on her career as a schoolteacher. Her mind quickly changes, however, when she meets a handsome visitor to their Amish community. Abigail falls for him hard until she finds out some shady information about him from a previous girlfriend. Will she break up the budding romance or give him the benefit of the doubt?