©2003 Roger T. Ames and David L. Hall; (P)2007 BBC Audiobooks America
The Dao de Jing is a classic piece of world literature. Translated many times by scholars with different agendas (in recent times New Age translations for instance) , with each translation bearing the hallmarks of the cultural or academic focus of the translator.
This translation claims to give the Dao de Jing a philosophical investigation, the authors being I believe professional philosophers of western origin who teach/ taught at Beijing University.
Much of the explanatory phrasing in the commentary sections is unnecessarily turbid and academic.... not at all accessible without multiple listenings. In their defence the translators do rephrase their sentences in different ways i.e. "In other words..." or "put another way....".
To sum up, unless one is supremely academically attuned, multiple listenings of this translation of the Dao de Jing would work best....and that this may not be such a bad thing... I just put it on when I'm driving long distance.
Clarification of the phrase "the swinging gateway of heaven" and the exposition of the "Wu forms"
The minnows swimming below the bridge on the How River.
Yes Chapter 20 I found moving
Such an old text. Now with grave finds 500 years older than previous texts..but still with no punctuation marks, can we really get close to what the text is trying to say?
"Unless you are a sinologist"
I am fluent in modern Chinese, but the narrator's pronouciation is so awful that I couldn't understand what he was saying without going back to the ancient original. This translation also suffers from too many commentaries, two hours introduction and 81 commentary made this book very unwieldly, the philosophical translation (or rather, philosophical commentaries) also render this edition arcane at best, but if you are a sinologist, I think this book will still be of interest to you.
"Dear heavens, what a train wreck"
If this were a meal, it would be a chicken, boiled until all flavor is lost and poured down the drain.
I have many translations of the Tao Te Ching. Every new translation usually brings some wonderful contribution to the experience, but I have yet to discover what the contribution here is.
I usually enjoy insightful commentary on the text many translations offer. I love the glimpses of cultural insight and explanations many translations and commentaries provide. This reads like an academic treatment that was refused for publication by philosophical journals.
The translation is ineloquent and sterile. The commentary is pretentious and haughty. It takes more than three hours of self-congratulatory introduction before the translation even begins.
Even in translation, it's clear from the whole of available translations the Tao Te Ching is a work of eloquence and beauty. Alas, neither has managed to survive this edition.
Definitely a great read that sheds light on many of the otherwise vague passages in the Dao.
"best self help book EVER!"
It seems that 2400- 2600 years ago there was a lot of thinking going on. Socrates. Siddhartha, and Lao Tzu. and all of it so applicable today that it seems fresh. and matured.
"Not what I expected"
I expected an explanation of the Dao De Jing. I got philosophy geek speak that made a confusing manuscript much more confusing! Maybe if you are a Philosophy major this book is for you!
"A Bit Hard Going"
If you are going to buy this bear in mind that it doesn't get into the Dao itself until half way through the recording. The first half is taken up by all the explanation about the translation and the justification behind their interpretation. I understand the complexity of translating something like the Dao De Jing but it was a little confusing listening to a 4 hour introduction. Several times I wasn't sure whether they had actually started talking about the Dao but they hadn't so bear this in mind. If you want to get straight into it, skip to part 4.
Report Inappropriate Content