When a teenage joyrider crashes a stolen car and ends up in a coma, a routine DNA test reveals a connection to a twisted unsolved murder from 22 years before.
Meanwhile, Karen Pirie finds herself irresistibly drawn into another mystery that she has no business investigating; a mystery that has its roots in a terrorist bombing two decades ago. And again, she finds that nothing is as it seems....
©2016 Val McDermid (P)2016 W.F. Howes Ltd
"A real page-turner and another McDermid triumph." (Observer, on The Distant Echo)
"A powerful story of murder and revenge...an exciting page-turner." (Sunday Telegraph, on The Distant Echo)
The change of voice, tone and accents was extremely well done and a pleasure to listen to. Several times I wondered if more than one person was reading.
What a great book, I enjoyed the twists and turns in this story. It had me guessing right to the end. I love that the writer had me guessing. Cathleen Mcarron did a great job with all the different voices. Audible yI will be looking for more books from this writer.
The storyline was quite complex but the narrator is incredible and her performance was astounding. I loved her accents, her passion and everything about her performance. She kept me wanting more from the book.
"Slow to start but ultimately satisfying"
I like Val McDermid’s books as she write so well, but sometimes shrink from her graphic details of murders. Thankfully this book is devoid of any gruesome descriptions of post mortems and doesn’t spend any time in the the minds of psychopaths relishing their deeds. There’s quite a bit of forensic detail thanks to the author’s close association with the world famous department at Dundee University. I did a FutureLearn course run by that University on forensics in which Val McDermid actively participated. She has also written a book on the topic.
The book meanders for quite a time as two separate stories are introduced, but gathers momentum after about 40 out of 62 chapters. I didn’t mind the slower pace as we got to know the various characters and learn some interesting facts about forensics and the laws relating to privacy. The author indulges her political beliefs over the treatment of Syrian refugees seeking asylum in Scotland: all very laudable but a bit of a diversion that slows the pace of the novel. Par for the course the chief character, DCI Karen Pirie, is a bit of a maverick going off at tangents and getting into trouble with her superiors, but she’s an engaging, sympathetic and at times funny character.
I did enjoy the book and thought the slower pace reflected the more realistic time course of investigations in real life, even if the crimes were unusual.
At first I thought it was to be a four star listen but by the end I thought it rated higher than that as the author carries the two stories forward such that I was keen to find out what happened next as one lead after another seemed promising and then went nowhere.
The narrator is excellent as she creates many different voices making the book seem like a dramatisation.
"Great narration of a rather pedestrian story"
The narration of this book was amazing and what ultimately kept me listening. So many different voices, Cathleen McCarron deserves an Oscar!
The story was interesting enough, but it was wordy and with a lot of non-essential information which slowed the action down, like the biographical detail of the show biz producer who died in the air crash, which never came into the plot again.. Much of the plot was predictable, with heavy signalling of events. I can't imagine many Chief Inspectors get to choose the cases they feel like investigating.
To be honest, I was relieved when it came to an end and I could finally turn it off.
Enjoyed the book but did think the ending left you hanging without closure, needed one more para
"Brilliant book and narration"
Another great book by Val McDermid. The narrator Cathleen McCarron deserves a special mention. She is everything a brilliant narrator needs to be. Her characters are easily distinguished from each other and her accents are all seemingly authentic. Nothing to distract from the plot as it bowls along. McDermid's characters are so well drawn and McCarron does them full justice.
"a few loose ends"
Enjoyed this but felt it ended a bit abruptly. I was a bit perplexed when the narrator said it was the epilogue as I thought there were still a few loose ends to be tied off within the main story.
"Struggled with it"
Usually love these books but could not get in to this one. Not sure if it was the story or narrative but found it irritating
This was my first Val McDermid book,and it most certainty will not be my last. I enjoyed the whole storyline and colourful characters, excellent read
"Very enjoyable if less exciting than of old"
Nearly gave up as the initial readers interpretation which was so broadly Scottish I felt uncomfortable But glad I carried on listening because the reader demonstrated her skills later on
Like very much that a second episode of the new heroine has been introduced but less sure of the story
Very enjoyable and fast moving plot. Shame didn't realise it was the fourth in the series! But will catch up! Linda Brown.
This story is not as gory as some of the authors books, more gentle people focused. I enjoyed it a lot
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.