You’re Probably Right cover art

You’re Probably Right

You’re Probably Right

By: Michael C Murray
Listen for free

This Season's Biggest Deal | $0.99/mo for 3 months + $20 Audible bonus

Auto-renews at $8.99/mo. after 3 months - terms apply.
Summary
You’re Probably Right is a long-form podcast for people who feel out of step with surface-level advice and easy answers. Each episode looks at relationships, social dynamics, belief systems, and the quiet patterns that shape how people treat each other, especially the parts nobody prepares you for. There are no quick fixes here. Just clear thinking, lived experience, and conversations that trust the listener to keep up. Hosted by Michael C Murray. If this podcast brings you value, help keep it going. Support the show: buymeacoffee.com/yprpodcast ☕️Michael C Murray Relationships Social Sciences
Episodes
  • Congratulations, You’re Their Type. That Makes You Replaceable.
    Nov 16 2026

    Being told “you’re exactly my type” can feel incredible, especially if you have not felt genuinely desired in a long time. But what if being somebody’s type is not as reassuring as it sounds?

    In Episode 395 of You’re Probably Right, MCM asks what happens when somebody falls for your age, appearance, culture, status, personality or sexual chemistry before they ever really learn who you are. Preferences are normal. Attraction matters. But being somebody’s preference does not automatically mean they understand you, value your character or are capable of building the kind of relationship you actually want.

    The episode looks at cultural preferences, attraction to older or younger partners, physical appearance, sexual chemistry, money, generosity, insecurity and the intoxicating feeling of finally being somebody’s ideal. Sometimes the danger is not only that they are attracted to a fantasy. You may become so flattered by being wanted that you stop asking whether you would actually choose them.

    That distinction matters. Somebody can find you irresistible and still be dishonest, inconsistent, selfish or completely wrong for your life. Extraordinary sexual chemistry does not establish relationship compatibility. Being intensely desired does not establish character. And somebody making you feel exceptional does not automatically make them an exceptional partner.

    MCM also asks where our “type” comes from in the first place. Perhaps you say you like older men, but what you are really looking for is stability. Perhaps you say you prefer wealthy partners, but what you really want is security. Perhaps you are attracted to a particular cultural background because you associate it with acceptance, familiarity or qualities you experienced somewhere else. The problem begins when a real person is expected to keep performing the fantasy attached to the category.

    And then there is the trap for the person being desired. When somebody seems fascinated with you, you may begin changing yourself to preserve that attention. You dress differently. Spend more money. Become more agreeable. Hide parts of yourself. Try to remain the person they originally found irresistible. Eventually you may not know whether they still want you or merely the version of yourself you have been exhausting yourself trying to maintain.

    The relationship can even end while the audition continues. You still dress for them. Still improve yourself hoping they notice. Still try to satisfy the requirements of being their type even though the role is no longer available.

    Episode 395 is about attraction, culture, fantasy, sexual chemistry, generosity, identity, insecurity and the difference between being wanted, being understood and actually being loved.

    Because somebody can find another person your age. Another person with your appearance. Another person from your cultural background. Another person who fits the same description.

    But they cannot find another person with your exact history, experiences, personality and everything that makes you who you are.

    Maybe the problem was never that they wanted somebody like you.

    Maybe they were simply looking for somebody who looked like you.

    And there is an enormous difference.

    Episode 395

    You’re Probably Right with MCM
    Entertainment first. Everything else is just bonus opinions.

    Connect: yprpodcast@gmail.com
    Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/youre-probably-right/id1551574121
    Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/1L65QCDAGp1h5Vca5zwE7X

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 25 mins
  • How to Beg Your Ex to Hurt You One Last Time | That Final Message
    Nov 15 2026

    You have one more thing you need your ex to understand. One final explanation. One message that will finally tell them exactly what they did to you. But what if sending it is really just asking the person who hurt you to hurt you one more time? In Episode 394 of You’re Probably Right, MCM examines the temptation to have that final conversation after a relationship has already ended. Maybe you were misled. Maybe they allowed you to keep investing while their feelings were already changing. Maybe you gave your time, money, affection, availability and emotional energy believing the two of you were building something together. None of that means somebody owed you permanent love. People are allowed to leave. But having the right to leave does not give somebody the right to deceive you while they are still there. The problem comes when you believe one more perfectly written message will finally produce the acknowledgement, apology or understanding that the relationship never gave you. What happens if they ignore it? What if they disagree? What if they minimize what happened? What if they apologize, but the apology changes nothing? Or what if they respond warmly and reopen an emotional door you were finally beginning to close? This episode explores rejection versus deception, generosity, dignity, accountability, unfinished conversations, unsent messages, unanswered questions and the dangerous desire to perfect an ending that may never feel complete. Sometimes you absolutely should speak. There may be a false accusation to correct, an obligation that remains unresolved or something genuinely important the other person needs to know. But sometimes you have already explained yourself. They understood. They simply did not respond the way you wanted. At that point, another explanation may not create understanding. It may simply expose you to another injury. MCM also looks at the difference between pride and dignity. Dignity does not mean pretending you were never hurt. It means recognizing that your pain has value without automatically giving continued access to the person who contributed to it. Write the message if you need to. Say everything. Then ask yourself whether sending it will actually accomplish something worthwhile. Because sometimes the final conversation is not the one you have with your ex. Sometimes it is the conversation where you finally decide that nothing more needs to be said. Episode 394. How to Beg Your Ex to Hurt You One Last Time. You’re Probably Right with MCM. Entertainment first. Everything else is just bonus opinions. Connect: yprpodcast@gmail.com. Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/youre-probably-right/id1551574121 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/1L65QCDAGp1h5Vca5zwE7X

    Show More Show Less
    2 hrs and 7 mins
  • Forget Attachment Styles, Maybe They Just Don’t Care About You? The Checklist
    Nov 7 2026

    What if you stopped trying to figure out their attachment style and simply asked whether they actually care about you in the way a relationship requires?

    In Episode 393 of You’re Probably Right, MCM gives you a simple ten question checklist to help you look at the relationship as it actually exists today. Not their potential. Not their best moments. Not who they were at the beginning. The current pattern.

    The questions look at safety, honesty, emotional responsiveness, accountability, effort, independence, reliability, affection, interest in your life, and appreciation. This is not a clinical or psychological test. It is simply a way to organize what you may already be experiencing and make it harder to explain away one disappointing incident after another.

    LISTENER SCORECARD

    For each question choose:

    A = rarely or never

    B = sometimes

    C = consistently

    Answer based on the current pattern, not isolated good moments. If you do not know, mark ? and leave it unscored.

    1. Wellbeing, safety and boundaries, 20 points
      A = 0
      B = 10
      C = 20

    2. Honesty and clarity, 15 points
      A = 0
      B = 7.5
      C = 15

    3. Emotional responsiveness, 15 points
      A = 0
      B = 7.5
      C = 15

    4. Accountability and repair, 10 points
      A = 0
      B = 5
      C = 10

    5. Reciprocal effort, 10 points
      A = 0
      B = 5
      C = 10

    6. Independence and growth, 10 points
      A = 0
      B = 5
      C = 10

    7. Reliability in difficult times, 10 points
      A = 0
      B = 5
      C = 10

    8. Affection and intimacy, 5 points
      A = 0
      B = 2.5
      C = 5

    9. Interest in your life, 3 points
      A = 0
      B = 1.5
      C = 3

    10. Thoughtfulness and appreciation, 2 points
      A = 0
      B = 1
      C = 2

    Possible total: 100 points

    Suggested discussion ranges:

    0 to 39.5, serious concerns

    40 to 59.5, significant unmet needs

    60 to 79.5, mixed or inconsistent care

    80 to 100, many positive patterns

    These ranges are only conversation starters. They are not clinically validated cutoffs and no score can tell you whether somebody secretly loves you or decide what you should do. A high score also does not override violence, coercion, threats, intimidation or serious safety concerns.

    ADDITIONAL REFLECTION

    What have you stopped doing for yourself?

    What have you accepted that you once believed you would never accept?

    What has this relationship cost you?

    What would you have to rebuild if it ended?

    Could you live with another five years of the same pattern?

    The point of the episode is not simply to decide whether the other person is good or bad. It is to look honestly at what you are receiving, what you are giving, what the relationship is costing you, and whether the relationship you actually have is one you can continue choosing.

    Episode 393
    Forget Attachment Styles, Maybe They Just Don’t Care About You? The Checklist

    You’re Probably Right with MCM
    Entertainment first. Everything else is just bonus opinions.

    Connect: yprpodcast@gmail.com
    Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/youre-probably-right/id1551574121
    Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/1L65QCDAGp1h5Vca5zwE7X

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 20 mins
No reviews yet
In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.