When "I'm fine" feels safer than "I'm hurting": The cost of pretending in church
Failed to add items
Add to basket failed.
Add to Wish List failed.
Remove from Wish List failed.
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
-
Narrated by:
-
By:
About this listen
Send us a text
Have you ever walked into church, smiled, said “I’m fine,” and instantly felt the ache of pretending?
In this episode, Melissa and Jasmine unpack the hidden pressure many believers feel to appear “spiritually mature.” We explore how church culture can unintentionally reward masking - showing up polished, composed, and holy - when our souls are actually crying out for safety and connection.
You’ll hear honest reflections about:
- The loneliness that comes from feeling unseen, even in church.
- Why we equate vulnerability with weakness.
- How pretending keeps us disconnected from both God and others.
- Practical, grace-filled ways to begin unmasking, little by little, without losing your sense of safety.
- What it looks like to let others in when your heart is still in a tender season of healing.
This isn’t about church-bashing. It’s about healing the parts of us that learned to hide and remembering that God meets us most deeply when we’re real.
Reflection Questions:
- When was the last time you said "I'm fine" but didn’t mean it?
- What keeps you from being honest with your community or even with yourself?
- What would “one small act of honesty” look like for you this week?
👉 Subscribe to the podcast so you don’t miss future episodes, and follow Melissa on Instagram @melchanity for more encouragement and resources!