Episodes

  • EP 331 - LEGACY SEQUELS with Wahab Shayek
    Nov 4 2025

    What exactly are LEGACY SEQUELS, and why would anyone love them? Filmmaker and comedy writer Wahab Shayek is here to explain -- using LIVE FREE OR DIE HARD (2007) as his prime example. Wahab wrote Playmates, a short heist comedy that was selected to screen at the Tasveer Film Festival. He is also a proud (self-proclaimed) Cabello Bro 4 Life. Episode Links: Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

    Show More Show Less
    49 mins
  • EP 330 - SUI SCARE IT: ENCOUNTER WITH A LATCHING ENTITY with Tessie Herrasti
    Oct 27 2025

    In this final SHUT UP I SCARE IT episode, actress Tessie Herrasti recalls the time when an EVIL ENTITY latched onto her trapezoid. Tessie's Website Tessie's IG Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

    Show More Show Less
    49 mins
  • EP 329 - SILVER BULLET (1985) with Macklen Makhloghi
    Oct 20 2025

    Actor, writer and improviser Macklen Makhloghi wants us to SHUT UP AND SCARE about the wonderfully surface-level Stephen King film SILVER BULLET (1985) -- a movie where nothing really pays off, but no one cares that it doesn’t. Episode Links: Macklen's IG Macklen's Twitter Thread Corner Honeymoon Improv Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

    Show More Show Less
    57 mins
  • PREVIEW: Shut Up Sasha & Joe Ep. 25: Like a Turtle Without a Shell
    Oct 14 2025

    Here’s a FREE PREVIEW of our latest Check-In Episode, aka "Shut Up Sasha and Joe." To hear more, head to https://www.patreon.com/c/ShutUpILoveItPodcast

    Check-In Episode # 25: Killing things in your script. He was a Gilmore boy all along. Believing a cartoon when a turtle crawls out of its shell.

    A little backstory: During the LA fires, Joe was near the Eton fire, Sasha was right by the Kenneth fire, and we were checking in on everyone -- each other, our friends, anyone who crossed our minds. This is when we remembered something important: we’re old friends with a lot of ridiculous history. So we decided to make it a thing—a weekly check-in where we catch up, talk about all the stuff outside the usual episode topics, reminisce about the Golden Age of Improv, spill the hot goss, and share whatever pop culture or art has us hooked that week.

    These weekly check-ins are now living over on Patreon. If you love the podcast and can’t get enough of this undeniable chemistry, come hang out with us there.

    Show More Show Less
    2 mins
  • EP 328 - SUI Scare It: THE REAL GHOSTBUSTERS with Gil Baron
    Oct 14 2025

    Producer and comedy man Gil Baron is back ​for a SHUT UP ​I SCARE ​e​episode about THE REAL GHOSTBUSTERS, the animated spin-off of the 1984 classic film that he calls “a perfect intro to horror.” Nostalgia for it has even struck people who grew up in Siberia. Episode Links: Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

    Show More Show Less
    57 mins
  • EP 327 - SUI Scare It: TRICK'R TREAT (2007) with Shane Hartline
    Oct 6 2025

    Actor and comedian Shane Hartline (Obi-Wan Kenobi, Station 19) is back for our very first SHUT UP I SCARE IT! Shane’s heart forever belongs to Sam, the pumpkin-headed trick-or-treater from the spooky cult favorite T​RICK'R TREAT (2007). Episode Links: Shane's TikTok Shane's IG Shane's X Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

    Show More Show Less
    55 mins
  • PREVIEW: Shut Up Sasha & Joe Ep. 24: Behind The Curtain
    Sep 30 2025

    Here’s a FREE PREVIEW of our latest Check-In Episode, aka "Shut Up Sasha and Joe." To hear more, head to https://www.patreon.com/c/ShutUpILoveItPodcast

    Check-In Episode # 24: Alien: Earth. The inner workings of the podcast. Covid and throwing up.

    A little backstory: During the LA fires, Joe was near the Eton fire, Sasha was right by the Kenneth fire, and we were checking in on everyone -- each other, our friends, anyone who crossed our minds. This is when we remembered something important: we’re old friends with a lot of ridiculous history. So we decided to make it a thing—a weekly check-in where we catch up, talk about all the stuff outside the usual episode topics, reminisce about the Golden Age of Improv, spill the hot goss, and share whatever pop culture or art has us hooked that week.

    These weekly check-ins are now living over on Patreon. If you love the podcast and can’t get enough of this undeniable chemistry, come hang out with us there.

    Show More Show Less
    2 mins
  • EP 326 - Shut Up I Rewatch MOONLIGHTING with Rachael B
    Sep 30 2025

    Welcome to our first ever SHUT UP I REWATCH IT! Writer and Army veteran Rachael B joins us to revisit MOONLIGHTING, the hit ’80s TV series starring the feuding Bruce Willis and Cybill Shepherd. Episode Links: Rachael's IG Joe's Patreon Mr. Owl's Website

    Show More Show Less
    50 mins