Sam Darnold Over Jordan Love? Super Bowl Rings vs Reality in the NFC QB Debate cover art

Sam Darnold Over Jordan Love? Super Bowl Rings vs Reality in the NFC QB Debate

Sam Darnold Over Jordan Love? Super Bowl Rings vs Reality in the NFC QB Debate

Listen for free

View show details

About this listen

 The Seattle Seahawks just won the Super Bowl — and somehow, that has turned into a national conversation about Sam Darnold being better than Jordan Love. In this hour of Jen, Gabe & Chewy, the crew reacts to hot takes suggesting Darnold has surpassed Love simply because he now owns a championship ring — and the discussion quickly becomes a deeper debate about how we evaluate quarterbacks in today’s NFL. 021126 JGC Hour 1 🏈 Are we ranking quarterbacks… or teams? The core issue is simple: Super Bowls are team accomplishments. Yes, Darnold played well in Seattle’s postseason run. Yes, he had a strong NFC Championship performance. But the Seahawks’ defense dominated New England in the Super Bowl — and the offense played clean, mistake-free football. The hosts ask the obvious question: Would multiple NFC quarterbacks have won with that Seahawks roster? Their answer: absolutely. 🧠 Ring culture distorts the conversation Jen points out that NFL fans and media repeatedly fall into the same trap: Joe Flacco’s elite postseason run elevated him beyond reason Nick Foles outdueled Tom Brady and briefly became untouchable Now Sam Darnold is being pushed into a tier his full résumé may not support Jordan Love, meanwhile, is being judged off one bad playoff half in Philadelphia — while his full-season body of work gets ignored. The frustration isn’t about tearing Darnold down. It’s about applying consistent logic. 📊 The metrics say something different The crew leans into the numbers: Advanced metrics don’t show Darnold separating significantly from Love Love’s arm talent and ceiling remain elite Love’s turnover numbers are being exaggerated without context As Chewy explains, quarterbacks hit their peak later than most positions. Love is still ascending. Declaring Darnold clearly superior now feels premature at best. 🧩 The Packers comparison problem One text message from a listener reframes the debate: Does it bother Packers fans that Sam Darnold now has the same number of Super Bowl rings as Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers? The show addresses that directly: Championships are team wins. Favre and Rodgers didn’t lose rings — their teams did. That doesn’t diminish Darnold’s achievement. It simply places it in context. 🏟️ Where does Jordan Love rank in the NFC? The crew runs through NFC quarterbacks: Matthew Stafford Dak Prescott Jalen Hurts Jared Goff Brock Purdy Sam Darnold They conclude that Love comfortably sits in the top tier — even if the exact order is debatable. One thing is clear: A Super Bowl ring alone doesn’t automatically vault someone ahead of him. ⚖️ The bottom line Sam Darnold deserves credit. The Seahawks earned their championship. But rewriting quarterback hierarchies based on one postseason run ignores the bigger picture. Jordan Love’s trajectory hasn’t changed because Seattle won a ring. And sometimes, the loudest takes say more about recency bias than reality. 🎧 A sharp, heated, and necessary conversation about quarterback evaluation, ring culture, and why context still matters — only on Jen, Gabe & Chewy. Jordan Love, Sam Darnold, Seahawks Super Bowl, NFC quarterback rankings, Packers quarterback debate, NFL Super Bowl champions, ring culture NFL, quarterback evaluation, ESPN Milwaukee, Jen Gabe and Chewy
No reviews yet
In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.