Alleged Inuit village where everyone mysteriously disappeared in 1930.

In this gripping episode of Murder Before Myths, host Casey dives into a haunting cold case from her own hometown—one that went unsolved for decades until a breakthrough in DNA technology brought long-awaited justice. What seemed lost to time is now a chilling reminder that the past never truly stays buried.

Meanwhile, Quenten takes us down a darker, more legendary path as he explores the terrifying tale of the Jersey Devil. Is it just a myth born from fear—or could something truly monstrous be lurking in the Pine Barrens?

True crime meets folklore in a twisted double-feature you won’t want to miss.

I

n this haunting episode of Murder Before Myths, Casey takes a deep look into the tragic 1988 murder of Gordon Church—a horrific hate crime that shook the nation and, years later, found justice through advancements in DNA evidence. It's a powerful story of loss, resilience, and long-overdue accountability.

Then, Quenten explores the chilling legend of Angikuni Lake, where an entire Inuit village is said to have mysteriously vanished without a trace. Is it folklore, government cover-up, or something far more sinister?

Two chilling stories—one rooted in fact, the other steeped in mystery.