Episodes

  • E9: Dr. Jekyll and Joe Leggett
    Nov 16 2026

    Within the story of Jim Creighton is another story. A man who was loved by so many, that they did not, or chose not to see the addict and con man lurking just beneath the surface. Catcher Joe Leggett helped Jim Creighton become the best pitcher in the world, but Leggett also deceived widows and orphans. He robbed and cheated, and finally, one day, at the age of 50, he left his wife and children, and disappeared, never to be seen again. For 150 years the whereabouts of Joe Leggett remained a mystery, until historian Tom Gilbert uncovered the truth. This is the full story of Joe Leggett, hero and villain.

    Show More Show Less
    50 mins
  • E8: The Road Trip That Started It All
    Nov 9 2026

    Road trips and national tours are commonplace today, but in 1860, not one baseball team thought it a good idea to take the show on the road. There were numerous reasons not to even consider the idea. But one team, the Brooklyn Excelsiors sacrificed their season and a shot at the title that meant so much to them, to share this new, wonderful game, with the rest of the country. This is their story.

    Show More Show Less
    20 mins
  • E7: The Day Professional Baseball Was Born
    Nov 2 2026

    Today the idea of paying to see a baseball game is perfectly normal, but there was a time when this notion was insane, and this new breed of human, known as the fan, was considered out of their minds. In this episode, I explore with a number of expert guests, the very beginning of professional baseball, and how it changed so much in America.

    Show More Show Less
    18 mins
  • E6: The Ugly Truth of Amateurism
    Oct 23 2026

    Over the last 100+ years, we've come to associate amateur sports (Olympics, college sports), with purity, sanctity, honor. In many cases, athletes trying to turn professional and make money from their performance has been seen as dirty, dishonorable. This conflict is at the heart of a scandal surrounding Jim Creighton, and it has to do with a skewed understanding of where amateurism came from in the first place. Tonight we discover the truth.

    Show More Show Less
    41 mins
  • E5: Jim Creighton Lives?
    Oct 16 2026

    In this episode, I talk to a living, breathing reincarnation of Jim Creighton, to shed light on historical mysteries that have been lost to time. I'll also talk with Tom Gilbert to figure out exactly how fast Creighton was throwing, and what the difference between his speed and the speed of his contemporaries would look like today. Here's a hint. It would have looked bonkers!

    Show More Show Less
    30 mins
  • In Search of the White Whale: A Talk With Brian Gaffney
    Oct 9 2026

    The knuckleball is not only the most mysterious, most fascinating pitch in baseball, it might also be the most interesting phenomenon in all of sports. In this episode, I talk with journalist and documentarian Brian Gaffney about the story of the knuckle ball and how his three sons pursued this elusive pitch, and are still pursuing it. The full story can be found in Brian's book, The School of Hard Knucks, recently published and available online.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 3 mins
  • E4: An Instruction Manual On How To Destroy Hitters
    Oct 1 2026

    We've been talking about how Jim Creighton broke the game of baseball. In this episode, we pull back the curtain and see exactly how he did something no other player could do.

    Show More Show Less
    42 mins
  • E3: The Lightning-Fast Game Called Baseball
    Sep 24 2026

    If you lived in New York in the 1850s, you would have heard of a game catching on that was extremely fast-paced. Blink and you'll miss it. What was this lightning-quick game? Baseball. Hard to believe, but this was the reality at the time. And then, in 1859, in stepped a pitcher who did something that stunned the baseball world. And the game would never be the same.

    Show More Show Less
    29 mins