This week, we’re revisiting two stories that have stuck with us long after we first covered them.

Colleen brings back Tayler’s telling of Resurrection Mary, the infamous Chicago ghost legend known for eerie sightings, unexplained disappearances, and a story that continues to haunt decades later.

Then Tayler revisits Colleen’s deep dive into Mark Twitchell, the so-called “Dexter Killer,” whose calculated crimes and disturbing obsession with the fictional series made this one of the most unsettling cases we’ve covered.

Some stories don’t fade with time—and these are two we couldn’t leave behind.

This week on IGSTTY, Tayler takes us inside the terrifying San Pedro Poltergeist—a case centered around a woman named Jackie, whose home became the site of relentless, unexplained activity. We’re talking objects moving on their own, violent disturbances, and a presence that refused to stay quiet. Is it a true poltergeist… or something even more unsettling?

Then Colleen dives into the chilling and infuriating story of the John du Pont and the Foxcatcher murder—the shocking killing of Olympic gold medalist Dave Schultz. What started as an opportunity for elite training at Foxcatcher Farm spiraled into paranoia, control, and ultimately, tragedy. It’s a case of wealth, power, and a man who never should have been allowed to go unchecked.

From a house that may not have been empty… to a man who was unraveling in plain sight—this episode is unsettling in all the ways that matter.

Spotted: one haunted furnace, one anonymous letter writer, and a room full of people who definitely should not trust their mail. XOXO, XGSTY Pod 👀💌👻

Hey Upper East Siders… or should we say, Bottle Shop 48, your favorite chaos agents took the stage for a special live show, and let’s just say the gossip was deadly.

Tayler brings the heat with the haunted horrors of Sloss Furnaces, where tragic deaths, ghost sightings, and the terrifying legend of Slag prove some places never let the past stay buried.

Then Colleen delivers the ultimate blind item: the Circleville Letter Writer, the anonymous menace who turned a quiet Ohio town into a paranoia-fueled nightmare of threatening letters, dangerous traps, and small-town secrets.

Ghost stories, true crime, live laughs, and enough suspicious behavior to keep everyone on the suspect list… sounds like our kind of night.

You know you love us.
XOXO, IGSTTY Pod