Is It Cool or Just Nostalgia? cover art

Is It Cool or Just Nostalgia?

Is It Cool or Just Nostalgia?

By: Jeffrey Andy Michael & Mike
Listen for free

About this listen

We all remember the most awesome things from our childhood as we grew up over the years. But are all those cool things still as great as you remember? Or does it all just seem that way due to the rose-colored lenses of nostalgia? This Podcast aims to answer that very question across a range of topics. Are you a disco kid? Did you grow up during the greatest decade for music and hairbands? Are your favorite memories all from the final years of the 20th century? Then you're in good company as Jeffrey, Andy, Michael, and Mike (Yes, we have two of them) answer the question: Is it Cool or Just Nostalgia?

Check us out on YouTube for the video version of this podcast!

Is It Cool or Just Nostalgia 2025
Art
Episodes
  • 012 - Cowabunga Comeback?! - Diving Back into the Original TMNT Movies
    Aug 15 2025

    The Turtles turn 35! 🐢 We’re revisiting TMNT (1990) and Secret of the Ooze (1991) to see if they still kick shell in 2025—or if they’re just pure nostalgia. Cowabunga or cringe? Let’s find out!

    🔎 WE DIG INTO:

    🐢 How Jim Henson’s Creature Shop brought the Turtles to life with groundbreaking animatronic suits that still look amazing in HD

    🗡️ Why the darker, grittier tone of TMNT (1990)—closer to the Mirage comics—helped it smash box office records as the highest-grossing independent film of its time 🎭 How Secret of the Ooze pivoted to lighter comedy and fewer on-screen weapons after backlash from parents’ groups

    🎤 The legacy of Ninja Rap and Vanilla Ice—campy perfection or pure cringe?

    🏆 Which one actually holds up: the gritty original or the cartoonier sequel?

    📖 CHAPTERS 📖

    00:00 Intro

    01:59 The dissection begins...

    41:47 Cool vs Nostalgia Results

    💭 LET US KNOW: Which one of these classic flicks is your fav? Who's your favorite turtle? Drop your thoughts in the comments!

    The eternal struggle is fought here between what is genuinely cool and timeless for every generation versus those things that are pure nostalgia and only seem great because of your childhood memories. Whether it’s Ghostbusters, Star Wars, James Bond, Super Mario, Star Trek, or Marvel Comics vs DC, we cover all our favorite things from the 70s, 80s, 90s, and 2000s. After each of us thoroughly discuss the episode’s topic, the group votes to decide whether it is still Cool or Just Nostalgic.

    🔔 SUBSCRIBE for more retro pop culture deep dives!

    Check our YouTube channel!

    🧠 Search terms Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 1990 review, TMNT Secret of the Ooze, TMNT Jim Henson, Steve Barron TMNT, Vanilla Ice Ninja Rap, Tokka and Rahzar, Shredder, Casey Jones, April O’Neil

    #TMNT #TeenageMutantNinjaTurtles #90sMovies

    Show More Show Less
    57 mins
  • 011 - Twisted Metal 2: Still ON FIRE or Burned Out? 🔥
    Jul 31 2025

    🎮 TWISTED METAL 2: LEGENDARY CHAOS OR NOSTALGIC TRASH? 🎮

    Welcome Nostalgia Hunters! Today we're diving into the PlayStation's most BRUTAL vehicular combat game - Twisted Metal 2 from 1996! But here's the burning question: does this demolition derby masterpiece still deliver the same adrenaline rush in 2025, or are we just remembering it through rose-colored rearview mirrors?

    🔥 WHAT WE'RE COVERING:

    - Breaking down the most iconic characters and vehicles

    - How 1996 gaming holds up against today's standards

    - Who the hell is Calypso?

    - Comparing original PlayStation graphics to modern standards

    - Why vehicular combat games basically disappeared

    - Can anyone even get past the first level!?

    📖 CHAPTERS 📖

    00:00 Intro

    02:51 The dissection begins...

    37:47 Cool vs Nostalgia Results

    💭 LET US KNOW: Do you think Twisted Metal 2 still holds up today? Who's your favorite character?

    The eternal struggle is fought here between what is genuinely cool and timeless for every generation versus those things that are pure nostalgia and only seem great because of your childhood memories. Whether it’s Ghostbusters, Star Wars, James Bond, Super Mario, Star Trek, or Marvel Comics vs DC, we cover all our favorite things from the 70s, 80s, 90s, and 2000s. After each of us thoroughly discuss the episode’s topic, the group votes to decide whether it is still Cool or Just Nostalgic.

    🔔 SUBSCRIBE for more retro pop culture deep dives!

    Check our YouTube channel!

    TAGS: Nostalgia Critic, Detective Comics, Best things from our childhood, Best Movies of the 1970s, Best Movies of the 1980s, Best Movies of the 1990s, Best TV Shows of the 1970s, Best TV Shows of the 1980s, Best TV Shows of the 1990s, Vintage Toys, Retro, Classics Cinema, Throwback, Twisted Metal Season 2

    #TwistedMetal2 #TwistedMetal #PlayStation #90sGaming #RetroGaming #SweetTooth #PSX #GamingNostalgia #RetroReview #ClassicGaming #VehicularCombat #90sNostalgia #GamingHistory #PlayStationClassics #TwistedMetalSeries

    Show More Show Less
    53 mins
  • 010 - Can Today's Audience Handle The Naked Gun?
    Jul 16 2025

    🎬 THE NAKED GUN: TIMELESS CLASSIC OR NOSTALGIC CRINGE? 🎬

    Welcome Nostalgia Hunters! Before the newest sequel drops, we're diving deep into Leslie Nielsen's 1988 comedy masterpiece "The Naked Gun: From the Files of Police Squad!" But the real question is: does this slapstick sensation still pack the same punch in 2025, or are we just remembering it through rose-colored glasses?

    🔥 WHAT WE'RE COVERING:

    - Breaking down the most iconic scenes and one-liners

    - How 1988 comedy holds up against today's humor standards

    - Leslie Nielsen's comedic genius - still relevant or dated?

    - The controversy: jokes that landed then vs. now

    - Comparing Police Squad origins to the big screen adaptation

    - Why parody movies don't hit the same way anymore

    📖 CHAPTERS 📖

    00:00 Intro

    01:43 The dissection begins...

    33:02 Cool vs Nostalgia Results

    The eternal struggle is fought here between what is genuinely cool and timeless for every generation versus those things that are pure nostalgia and only seem great because of your childhood memories. Whether it’s Ghostbusters, Star Wars, James Bond, Super Mario, Star Trek, or Marvel Comics vs DC, we cover all our favorite things from the 70s, 80s, 90s, and 2000s. After each of us present an item related to the episode’s topic, the group votes to decide whether it is still Cool or Just Nostalgic.

    🔔 SUBSCRIBE for more retro pop culture deep dives!

    Check our YouTube channel!

    TAGS: Nostalgia Critic, Detective Comics, Best things from our childhood, Best Movies of the 1970s, Best Movies of the 1980s, Best Movies of the 1990s, Best TV Shows of the 1970s, Best TV Shows of the 1980s, Best TV Shows of the 1990s, Vintage Toys, Retro, Classics Cinema, Throwback

    #TheNakedGun #LeslieNielsen #80sMovies #ComedyMovies #RetroReview #PopCulture #MovieReview #80sComedy #PoliceSquad #ClassicComedy #MovieNostalgia #ComedyHistory #80sNostalgia #FilmReview #VintageComedy #SlapstickComedy #ParodyMovies #CultClassic #MovieAnalysis #RetroPopCulture #LiamNeesan #NakedGun

    Show More Show Less
    49 mins
No reviews yet
In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.