Gifts, Gratitude, and the Comparison Trap: When Holiday Expectations Collide with Real Life
Failed to add items
Add to basket failed.
Add to Wish List failed.
Remove from Wish List failed.
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
-
Narrated by:
-
By:
About this listen
The holidays are magical… and also kind of a dumpster fire. 😅
In this episode, Katie and Meagan talk about the comparison trap — that sneaky holiday spiral where it feels like everyone else is doing more, gifting better, decorating prettier, and making more “core memories”… while you’re over here wrapping a giant present with painter’s tape and holding on by a thread.
We get real about the pressure to “make it magical,” how social media fuels scarcity thinking, why kids don’t actually remember the perfect stuff, and how to build traditions that don’t burn you out. Plus: a simple (and powerful) idea for choosing a values word for the season — so you can experience the holidays the way you actually want to.
In this episode, we talk about:
The holiday comparison trap and why it hits so hard this time of year
The pressure to create “perfect” memories, gifts, photos, pajamas, and traditions
How social media quietly steals joy, presence, and emotional bandwidth
Scarcity thinking: “I’m not doing enough… I’m not enough”
Why more gifts don’t equal more connection (and what kids remember instead)
The difference between connection vs. performance (and how kids can feel it)
Traditions that energize vs. traditions that drain
“Forced family fun” and low-pressure ways to build holiday togetherness
A practical reframe: setting expectations that fit your real family
- Choosing a “values word” for the season (calm, connection, togetherness, etc.)
You’ll walk away with:
Permission to simplify (without guilt)
A clear filter for “Is this for connection or for performance?”
A reminder that kids remember presence, not perfection
A way to pick traditions that feel sustainable (not exhausting)
A simple intention-setting practice to guide the next two weeks
Download the worksheet here: https://awesome-unit-60406.myflodesk.com/nslacwby3e
📲 Hang out with us on Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/buttheyearsareshortpodcast/🌐 Learn more about the podcast:
https://buttheyearsareshortpodcast.com/👋 Work with us:
Meagan’s counseling practice: https://meaganjacksoncounseling.com/
Katie’s consulting & counseling work: https://www.katiezconsulting.com/