The boys are making a stop in Hibbing, Minnesota to check out a strange dissappearance witnessed only by a child who was up late watching scary movies. Is it a werewolf? a vampire? A... phantom abductor (google it)? Well, today Sam and Dean are about to discover the one universal truth we all need to keep in mind - not every threat is supernatural. So grab your local sheriff and get ready to sprint. It's time to play the most dangerous game!

Do you have answers to the many, MANY ponderous questions we have over the course of these episodes? Shoot us an email at fangirlroadtrip@gmail.com

And we are back with part two of our 2025 holiday extravaganza - a special bonus episode featuring a dramatic reading of acts three and four of the original, unaired Supernatural pilot script! It's time to find out just what is going on in this version of the story. Is it better than the final, aired version? What stuck around and reappears in that script? All your questions will be answered in this extra special holiday gift.

A very special shout out to listener Dev for another incredible (and themed) piece of artwork featured on this episode - thank you so so much again!!

Do you have answers to the many, MANY ponderous questions we have over the course of these episodes? Shoot us an email at fangirlroadtrip@gmail.com

So many things can be solved with a good night's sleep. One thing that can't be are premonition-based nightmares about the deaths of strangers. Sam Winchester's shining powers are acting up again, and this time it's taking us to Saginaw, Michigan to investigate the deaths Sam is witnessing in his nightmares - both sleeping and waking ones. The boys hightail it to town, but will it be too late? Will they have a significant impact on the plot at all? Who's this kid that is brining an Emmy-worthy performance to this CW show? Let's find out.