Ep. 039 | Part 1 - 6 Keys to Managing Conflict in a Church Revitalization
Failed to add items
Add to basket failed.
Add to Wish List failed.
Remove from Wish List failed.
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
-
Narrated by:
-
By:
About this listen
Hosts: Bart Blair (Director of Church Revitalization, Assist Church Expansion) & Nathan Bryant (Executive Director, Assist)
TLDR: Key Takeaways-
Conflict is normal in churches - 75% of 14,000+ surveyed churches experienced conflict; it's not an exception, especially during revitalization
-
Conflict differs from resistance - Resistance to change requires different handling than general congregational conflict between members
-
Face reality: conflict will come - Change creates conflict; prepare your leadership team to expect and plan for it rather than being blindsided
-
Move toward conflict quickly but wisely - Address issues within 48-72 hours to prevent escalation, but take time to pray and process first
-
Always go face-to-face - Never resolve conflict through text or email; digital communication strips away tone and escalates tension
-
Bring a witness - Leaders should include an elder or team member when mediating conflict to ensure accountability and accurate reporting
Conflict is one of the most challenging aspects of leading a church through revitalization. In this episode, Bart Blair and Nathan Bryant tackle the reality that 75% of churches experience some level of conflict - and provide practical keys for navigating it successfully.
Why Is Conflict So Common in Churches Going Through Revitalization?Church revitalization creates a perfect storm for conflict:
-
Change itself generates tension between longtime members and new vision
-
Power dynamics shift as leadership structures evolve
-
Resource scarcity creates disagreements about priorities
-
Unspoken expectations lead to assumptions and misunderstandings
-
Communication gaps allow gossip to fill the vacuum
According to the Faith Communities Today (FACT) study of over 14,000 congregations, the top sources of church conflict are:
-
Member behavior (44%)
-
Money and finances (42%)
-
Worship style (41%)
-
Leadership style (40%)
-
Decision-making processes (39%)
-
Program priorities (30%)
-
Theology and doctrine (26%)
Before diving into conflict management strategies, it's important to understand that resistance to change is different from general congregational conflict. Resistance specifically relates to pushback against new initiatives, while conflict can arise from interpersonal issues, behavior problems, or disagreements unrelated to revitalization efforts.
This episode focuses on managing conflict that occurs between members and maintaining unity - a primary responsibility of church leadership.
Key #1: Face Reality - Conflict Will ComeScripture Foundation: "Count it all joy, my brothers, when you meet trials of various kinds, because you know that the testing of your faith produces perseverance." - James 1:2-4
How Should Pastors Prepare for Inevitable Church Conflict?Rather than being surprised or defensive when conflict emerges, church leaders must:
-
Normalize conflict without treating it as catastrophic