Confessions of a Shop Owner cover art

Confessions of a Shop Owner

Confessions of a Shop Owner

By: Mike Allen
Listen for free

Summary

Confessions of a Shop Owner is hosted by Mike Allen, a third-generation shop owner, perpetual pot-stirrer, and brutally honest opinion sharer. In this weekly podcast, Mike shares his missteps so you don’t have to repeat them. Along the way, he chats with other industry personalities who’ve messed up, too, pulling back the curtain on the realities of running an independent auto repair shop. But this podcast isn’t just about Mike’s journey. It’s about confronting the divisive and questionable tactics many shop owners and managers use. Mike is here to stir the pot and address the painful truths while offering a way forward. Together, we’ll tackle the frustrations, shake things up, and help create a better future for the auto repair industry.© 2026 Mike Allen Economics Leadership Management Management & Leadership
Episodes
  • Ep 89 - Sam "Awesome" Freeman & Ethan Whidden | Why You Don't "Need" an A-Tech
    May 8 2026

    My marketing before and after signing up with Turnkey Marketing is pretty scary. In a good way. Get your marketing right today HERE

    Tekmetric opened my eyes to just how much a good SMS will do for a shop. Their software is top of the line, and with them, so is my shop. Try them for yourself HERE

    Make your techs happier with Detect Auto. They'll stop getting "check noise" or "check vibration" from advisors with the customer concern tool. It will CHANGE YOUR LIFE. Book a demo HERE

    For years I thought I could handle the hiring process on my own. But, after far too many bad hires, it was clear I needed help. Promotive came through for me with a rock star hire in just a few days and I couldn't be happier. Swallow your pride and bring in Promotive for that open position you have at your shop today. You can thank me later. Learn more HERE

    AI for Shop Owners: Open the Hood of the Future is happening June 12-13 at Carfix in Raleigh, NC. Use AI to your advantage! Register HERE


    Sam Freeman is the Partner Manager with Promotive Ethan Whidden is a Sales Representative. Today, they share with Mike what they've learned about the challenges of recruiting in the automotive repair industry. They discuss the unrealistic expectations shop owners often have when looking for that elusive “A tech” and why most owners should reconsider what they truly need in their shops. The conversation covers the importance of clear communication—both when hiring and when working with vendors—and the need for accountability on both sides of the hiring process.

    Timestamps:

    00:00 - The reality of open bays & shop hopping
    01:14 - Walking the trade show floor & exhibitor life
    03:23 - Ethan Whidden on joining Promotive, shop culture, and genuine conversation
    07:27 - Mike Allen confesses: why he hesitated to use Promotive
    08:45 - Effort vs. results in recruiting—Matt Lofton’s tough love
    09:01 - Why most shops think they need A-techs (and why they’re wrong)
    14:47 - Defining technician levels (and what “A-tech” really means)
    17:26 - Expectations vs. reality: shops, techs, and unicorn hires
    18:09 - The shop owner who took “unrealistic” to new levels
    19:31 - Diagnosing your real hiring needs
    20:01 - Chaos coordinators & fixing the front office
    21:02 - You don’t need a unicorn—you need to be a better owner
    24:01 - Shop competition: Mario Kart, go-karts, and Monopoly battles
    27:02 - Epic neighborhood parties and community building
    33:06 - Localized guerrilla recruiting vs. Promotive (can you DIY?)
    34:03 - Why shop owners make terrible customers for vendors
    35:09 - Communication, unspoken expectations, and messy outcomes
    37:58 - Candidate screening, accountability, and whose fault is it, really?
    41:41 - Hiring stories: ghosting, no-shows & offers used as leverage
    51:14 - Why techs really leave—(hint: it’s not always money)
    01:00:05 - What you SHOULD pay your B-techs and A-techs in 2026
    01:06:09 - Boasting moms, cheer championships, and motivation
    01:11:08 - Code yellow, code red: shop bathroom confessions

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 18 mins
  • Ep 88 - Ashley Butler & Rochelle Gotsdiner | Scale Your Repair Shop by Doing This
    May 5 2026

    Register for Tekmetric's Tektonic Conference in Huston April 9-11 and use Code CONFESSIONS500 for $500.00 off. HERE

    Turnkey Marketing takes the stress of doing something I'm not good at off my plate. And gives it to someone who is. Click HERE for more.

    Elite Worldwide has CHANGED my business and life through their one-on-one coaching. Use them like I do HERE

    For years I thought I could handle the hiring process on my own. But, after far too many bad hires, it was clear I needed help. Promotive came through for me with a rock star hire in just a few days and I couldn't be happier. Swallow your pride and bring in Promotive for that open position you have at your shop today. You can thank me later. Learn more HERE

    AI for Shop Owners: Open the Hood of the Future is happening June 12-13 at Carfix in Raleigh, NC. Use AI to your advantage! Register HERE


    Today, Ashley Butler and Rochelle Gotsdiner join Mike Allen to break down how to scale your repair shop through strong processes. Ashley shares how clear communication and consistent customer updates can set your shop apart—because most of your competitors get it wrong daily. They also chat about how embracing AI and innovative training methods can solve the industry’s notorious people problem and unlock serious growth.

    Timestamps:
    00:00 Why “saying yes” matters and how to stop losing business
    03:56 Ashley Butler introduces her shop story and scaling to 14 stores
    04:46 How Ashley Butler structures her week for maximum impact
    08:42 Succession planning, family business, and running on “auto-pilot”
    10:18 The secrets to working with your spouse without disaster
    12:05 Turning crisis into opportunity: Creating a top-tier training center
    14:51 On a mission for talent: Training novices into flat-rate techs
    15:56 Why community involvement and university ties pay off
    18:18 Maximizing space, remodeling battles, and why your waiting room matters
    20:39 The “speed” advantage: Serving customers before they even ask
    27:31 Game-changing customer communication habits—so the phone never rings at 3pm
    32:22 Trust, integrity, and what it really takes to keep your reputation bulletproof
    35:14 Shop processes, procedures, and how competitors make you look good
    35:59 Integrating AI into shop training and HR: first steps and big potential
    41:10 How anyone can build custom AI tools for their shop
    43:35 Private equity, big chains, and why it’s opportunity (not threat!) for indies
    46:11 Guerrilla recruiting: real-world tactics for poaching top techs and advisors
    49:57 Shop owner black belt: Using networks and timing to score the best deals
    51:26 Why perfect policies don’t exist (and that’s okay!)

    Show More Show Less
    57 mins
  • Ep 87 - Coaching Call #16 | Maximize Repair Orders with Prebuilt Tickets
    Apr 28 2026

    If you're like me and aren't good at marketing, don't do it on your own. Let the experts handle it. Touch HERE for more on Turnkey Marketing.

    Tekmetric transformed my shop. Plain and simple. Want that for yours? Touch HERE

    When I used the maintenance tool for the fist time with Detect Auto, my mind was blown. My advisors had the same reaction - and then SO MUCH MORE TIME. Learn more about Detect Auto and book a free demo now!

    AI for Shop Owners: Open the Hood of the Future is happening June 12-13 at Carfix in Raleigh, NC. Use AI to your advantage! Register HERE


    In this episode, Matt Lofton and Mike Allen talk through Mike's shop's performance in March. Matt talks about the importance of pre-building estimates and leveraging tools like Detect Auto to maximize tech average quote and streamline workflow. Mat also shares his approach to combating misleading "vanity flush" services in the market, emphasizing transparent communication with customers.

    Timestamps:

    00:00 – The “Vanity Flush” Confession: Why $99 Services Aren’t What You Think
    02:24 – eBay Hero Cards, Shop Swag, and Why Autographs Still Matter
    04:14 – Record First Quarter, March Recap, and Looking Ahead
    05:50 – Fly With the Eagles Recap: What High Performers are Learning
    08:52 – DIY Shop AI: How to Create Your Own AI Agents and Save Big
    12:03 – Struggling with Close Rates? Blame (or Bless) Your Advisor
    14:09 – Prebuilding Estimates for Maximum Tech ARO
    16:13 – Setting Up Customers: Deferred Work, Maintenance, and Upsells
    17:33 – BG Programs, Fluid Service Sales, and Overcoming Industry Myths
    20:01 – How Corporate Store Pricing Drives Shortcuts (and Dirty Tricks)
    23:05 – Value-Add vs. Price-Only: The Ruth’s Chris Cheeseburger Analogy
    24:49 – How to Fill Tomorrow’s Bays with Opportunity, Not Just Oil Changes
    28:16 – The Pit Stop Program: Getting Customers Back 4x Fast
    30:48 – The Loyalty Cliff: Retaining vs. Losing First-Time Customers
    33:12 – Risky Repairs and the Real Cost of Saying “Yes”
    39:45 – Ritz Carlton vs. Motel 6: Finding Your Shop’s Sweet Spot
    43:04 – Social Media “Rage Bait”: Marketing Tactics and Lessons Learned
    44:58 – Worry About Your Own Shop! Why Community Trumps Competition
    48:21 – Peer Groups and Getting Ahead—Why You Shouldn’t Go It Alone

    Show More Show Less
    59 mins
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_c
No reviews yet
In the spirit of reconciliation, Audible acknowledges the Traditional Custodians of country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.