This week we rewatch Out of Mind, Out of Sight, and wow… this episode hits hard. We talk invisibility as a metaphor for high school loneliness, Cordelia’s surprising depth, Buffy feeling sidelined even with friends, and why Marcy’s story is both terrifying and heartbreaking. We also get into Angel’s return, first-ever Angel and Giles interaction, Hellmouth physics, and that chilling government ending. 💬 Which character did you relate to most in this episode — Buffy, Cordelia, or Marcy?

This week we’re rewatching Nightmares, the episode where everyone’s worst fears come to life. We talk test anxiety, naked-in-class dreams, spiders, clowns, Buffy being buried alive, and vampire Buffy looking way too cool. We also unpack why the episode works so well as a dream, how budget limits actually helped it, Giles’ iconic lines, and that uncomfortable ending with Billy. Which nightmare hit closest to home for you — the exam, the clown, or being buried alive?

We’re split on The Puppet Show. Creepy puppet masterpiece? Or the weakest Buffy episode ever? We talk Snyder’s debut, Sid’s questionable jokes, Cordelia being Cordelia, and that rushed ending. Plus Buffy reboot theories and parallel-universe chaos. Comment below: Do YOU love or hate this episode?