Some Decent Sci-Fi but with Poor Audio Quality

1. "The Ice Owl" by Carolyn Ives Gilman. Narrated by Vanessa Hart

Story: 2.5 out of 5.

Echo of well-known human historical trends playing out in other world contexts. Character development was good, but story arc could have been much more imaginative.

Narration: 2 of 5.

The talent of the narrator (which seemed well above average) was trampled by the lack of audio quality: sounded like someone whispering through a long pvc pipe, with every "s" sound the loudest. Had to stop when using cheap earphones as it was unlistenable; better earphones shortened the length of the pvc pipe but fundamental shortcoming remained.

2. "Angel of Europa" by Alllen M Steele. Narrated by Tom Dheere.

Story: 3 of 5
Decent realistic and plausible"near future" story of Europa exploration. Basic mystery story reasonably done with space backdrop.

Narration: 3 of 5
The narrator's English was unadorned American midwestern--but almost devoid of emotion or inflection. The parts of the story that had snatches of German sounded more authentic and natural, leading me to think German is his native language--and wishing the whole story could have been in German to get the better voice performance. Recording quality below average

3. "The Ants of Flanders" by Robert Reed. Narrated by Adam Epstein

Story: 4 of 5

Entertaining and imaginative story of how Earth fits into a larger tapestry when a spaceship lands on earth, told from perspective of a totally believable teenager of the millennial or maybe Gen-X variety. The story rewards the reader by taking several large leaps in development that are both unexpected yet plausible. The end is particularly satisfying and succeeds where so many stories fail: ending in a new and fascinating place that is far from where it started, and leaving the reader with excitement, questions, and a hunger for more.

Narration: 3 of 5

It's not clear at the beginning, but the somewhat bland and disinterested tones of the narrator actually help put the reader inside the head of the ambivalent teenage protagonist. Maybe that was not the intent, but it was a welcome effect. Recording quality below average.

4. "The Man Who Ended History" by Ken Liu. Narrated by Nancy Linari

Story: 4 of 5

Fascinating take on the effect technology to allow individuals to virtually witness past events, focusing on the biological experiment atrocities of Japanese Imperial Army's Unit 731 in WWII China While overly long, story does a good job of capturing the the political unintended consequences of the technology and its application.

Narration: 3 of 5

Decent narration, but recording quality below average.

5. "Kiss Me Twice" by Mary Robinnette Koval
Narrated by Tom Dheere

Story: 3 of 5

Cop buddy murder story in very near future where one partner is Artificial Intelligence. Well done, but not a fan of the genre.

Narration: 3 of 5

Decent narration, but recording quality below average.

6. "The Man Who Bridged the Mist" by Kij Johnson
Narrated by Scott Peterson

Story: 3.5 of 5

Slower tempo storytelling than most sci-fi, but satisfying presentation of one episode of industrialization on a planet where its inhabitants don't yet fully understand the bio-diversity of their own environment. Decent examination of the societal impacts of early industry.

Narration: 3 if 5

Decent narration, but recording quality below average.

2 people found this helpful

Don't waste your money

This book wasn’t for you, but who do you think might enjoy it more?

Poor audio stories maybe good but you will not get pat the audio.

What could the authors have done to make this a more enjoyable book for you?

Hired better audio engineers.

What didn’t you like about the narrators’s performance?

Poor

What reaction did this book spark in you? Anger, sadness, disappointment?

Disappointment

1 person found this helpful

GOD CREATED HEAVEN, MEN CREATED HELL

PEOPLE DIDN'T KNOW ENOUGH TO BE PROPERLY TERRIFIED.
Anytime you see Allan Kaster's name on something, turn the other way. I should have know better, having been disappointed by Kaster before. This had four stories from authors, I had interest in. I had recently read stories by Gilman, Steele, and Kowal that were good enough to draw my attention to them. Reed is almost always reliable for a good story, so I took a chance on Kaster, figuring that there were surly one or two good stories in the batch. Wrong, wrong, wrong. When Kaster says Top, what does he mean. Top of the crap, top of the left overs after Dozier, Hartwell, Strahan and everyone else have picked the top stories, top of WHAT?

WE'LL MAKE THAT HARNESS, WHEN THE COLT IS BORN
Gilman and Kowal's stories were so bad, that I could not finish listening. Reed's story was silly, and Liu's story barely good enough to listen to. Steele's story was a little better. Kiji Johnson's story was the best and supposedly won a Hugo. As an experienced reader, let me tell you that awards are not a good indicator of rather a story is good or not. Early on I tried reading most of the award winners, figuring they were the best, WRONG. In this case it is the best read of the group, but not good enough to buy the collection.

There is also problems with the production of some of these stories. The first story sounds like the reader is in a sub basement reading through a mega phone. Some of the others also have problems. The narrators I did not think were terrible, but they won't be winning any awards for their performances. It sounds like they are just getting started in their careers and most will have to go back to their day jobs.

Also, don't bother looking for The Year's top Sci-Fi stories under in the category Science Fiction/Fantasy and Short Stories and Anthologies, as there are no anthologies included under that category, except WE Robots. You will not find any of Kaster's collections there, none of Dozier, George R.R. Martins or the many anthologies by John Joseph Adams. It seems to be the home of Neil Gaiman's stories. Audible is in bad need of a Science Fiction editor. They seem to be overrun with young editors that read Romance and Teen books.

17 people found this helpful

Haunting - a few of the stories

Haunting - the ghosts of a few of the stories have stuck with me through the completion of several other books...like memories you cant shake, one bittersweet, one thoughtprovoking , one humorous...but overall an enjoyable listen.

Mixed bag

Most of these stories were not very good. Only a couple, such as "Kiss me twice" and "The man who bridged the Mist" made slugging through the others worthwhile.