light entertainment - with Sanderson magic

Still not 100% convinced that chalk drawings are serious foe........but hey, who cares....it was still good fun, and worth spending an audible credit on. If you enjoy Sanderson's story-telling, and in need of some fun, light relief, then you won't be disappointed.

One thing Sanderson is never: predictable. Yes, it's not quite as strong as Stormlight, or the last WoT books, but still worthy of a listen. It has some humour, and, typically, a good solid twist near the end that leaves you wanting more. I'll be watching out for the sequel....

Thank you Mr Sanderson for keeping my commute tolerable.

20 people found this helpful

If it wasn't for you meddling kids....

Not as good as other Brandon books, but that may be that this is a y a book.
I had trouble imagining chalk drawings being a threat to anyone's life, and it sort of played out as a not so good, full metal alchemist, crossed with a Pokemon competition. And a war against chalk monsters. I guess they must live somewhere without rain.
Anyway as the story goes on it gets to a "if it wasnt for you meddling kids" moment but then ends before you realize it.
I suppose it's my fault listing to a y.a book but you have to try these things.
I look forward to Brandon returning to his adult books. And would still recommend and younger listeners to give it a try.
All his other books I gave a 5 but this is a 3 for me

13 people found this helpful

Good, but no sign of a sequel to complete the stor

3 stars because this sequel has been abandoned by the author. No point in buying it as the story is incomplete

4 people found this helpful

Fantastic!

Would you listen to The Rithmatist again? Why?

Yes, because the story was so complex, filled with twists and turns, that I'd want to listen again to pick up areas that I missed first time round.

What other book might you compare The Rithmatist to, and why?

Ender's Game. The central heroes have a similar feel. They are both underdogs, but ones that are liked by other characters in the stories. You can't help but love them.

What does Michael Kramer bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you had only read the book?

Michael Kramer's voice is becoming quite a familiar one for me, as I've listened through the majority of the Wheel of Time books with him, and listened to the Mistborn series. I like his skills at characterisation, and lose myself in the audible telling almost as much as if I were reading the book myself.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

The battle moments in the book were very exciting, and the details made them very easy to imagine.

Any additional comments?

I'm now looking forward to listening to another Brandon Sanderson novel. He's pure genius!

9 people found this helpful

Chalk This Up As A Success

I'd already read the ebook and thoroughly enjoyed it. When I saw this on offer I had to buy it.

The pace of the storey is spot on and the characters are mainly likeable, with the exception of one of the professors (but he's meant to be a target of your dislike).

Brandon Sanderson's range of magic systems is superb and this book contains a unique one. Well thought out and believable.

Overall a well recommended listen.

3 people found this helpful

Good start to a new YA series

Brandon Sanderson does it again – yet another unique, in-depth magic system that left me wanting more. This time Brandon Sanderson tries his hands at young adult but is equally enjoyable for adults. Not my favourite from him, but I will definitely be listening to the sequels when they are available.

Story – 3.5/5

Wow – how many unique, easy to understand yet complex magic systems can one man come up with (apparently he has many more as well according to an interview). I get the impression that he develops the magic system, and then the story around it, but I could be wrong. If you like magic systems, then this book is definitely up your street.

This book reminded me a lot of Harry Potter actually. It is set in a school for magic users (or Rithmatists), weird things are happening around the school that a couple of students are helping to investigate, you still get your typical teenage issues that they like to moan about (teachers, what’s fair etc). In that respect you are not getting anything new. I would say though that the magic system is far superior. The limitations, rules and drawbacks are explained well enough in advance so that a powerful move cannot be overpowered later by an even more powerful one when the author decides he want to add something in a later book.


Performance – 4.5/5

Michael Kramer is probably my favourite narrator out there. Before I listened to anything of his, I was worried that his Southern USA accent would grate on me. It only takes about 10-15 minutes to get used to though and now I can enjoy some of the best fantasy novels on offer by a great voice actor and narrator.

There was one downfall of listening to this in audiobook form, there are clearly Rithmatic diagrams at the start of each chapter in the physical book that they attempt to explain on the audiobook. It didn’t detract from the overall story as you got a general gist, but I think seeing gives a more in depth understanding of the magic system. I got around this by looking up the diagrams on the internet when I wasn’t listening – I would recommend you do the same.


Overall – 4/5


Definitely suitable for adults – I am a 27 yr old man.

Apologies for the star ratings not matching the written review, I am forced to round halves on Audible.

11 people found this helpful

Brilliant

Loving Brandon Sanderson for sometime now, I was happy to see a new book out by him and haven't been let down. Although this book is very light reading compared to some of his other books, it is fabulous in its complex detail.
Definately a YA Novel in context. But one of those classics that i don't think you need to be a certain age to enjoy it, thankfully...
I have greatly enjoyed the last 2days of listening and now am a bit at a loss for what to do and keep feeling the need to draw circles in chalk... Shame we have carpet to...
I will definately be listening to it again...
The only downside is that i think the book must be illustarted at the begining of each chapter and although it is described and detailed very well I want to see the lines...
I hope you get the same enjoyment as I have from this book.

10 people found this helpful

Another excellent outing with Sanderson & Kramer

Once again Brandon Sanderson shows off his fantastic imagination for creative and original magic systems, their complexity of use/execution and exciting play out. While Michael Kramer once again provides top notch 10/10 narration and dedicated effort in his voice acting.

3 people found this helpful

Fascinating

A good arithmetic twist this book will probably rank along with Harry Potter and the Left Hand of God. Could not put it down.

3 people found this helpful

Sanderson finds another hit formula

Brandon Sanderson is becoming one of my favourite writers at present. This is the first book in a series for young adults, but that shouldn't put you off. This was a light read before I stated Sanderson's Words of Radiance - which i am expecting to be a fairly heavy read.

The magic system used within this book is genius - Chalk drawings. It was nice to have details of the magic system described a little after every chapter. This allowed the reader to get up to speed with the magic system without a massive info dump at the beginning.

The story follows Joel, a student at a Rithmatist school. Even though he is not a Rithmatist himself, he is assigned to a professor to look into a number of recent incidents. Of course, no YA novel is complete unless it has a quirky opposite sex person, and this was filled in by Melody.
Together they work through a number of missions for their professor, sometimes getting into trouble while others finding the convenient clues that adults failed to notice. This is exactly what i would expect from this type of book.

I listened to the audiobook version and Michael Kramer did another sterling job. The only complaint is Michael's voices are very similar to his other audio records.

I will most certainly be on the lookout for the next book in this series.

4 people found this helpful