Scratches head

I have read all of Sawyer's novels and really loved them.
I didn't think this was up to those previous novels. It seemed mostly a biography of Oppenheimer with no real science fiction or alternative world he lived in. The only glimpse of Sci Fi was in the last 20 (or so) minutes of the novel. I guess I expected more fantasy and depth. It was well written but I kept waiting to see where this would take my imagination. It didn't get going until the last chapter. I guess I expected more from Mr. Sawyer.

It enjoyed the performance, the history but overall I was disappointed in the novel.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

History Up Close and Personal--with a Twist

Robert J. Sawyer has delivered again with The Oppenheimer Alternative. The first section of the novel is a closeup view of the development of the atomic bomb, including the marvelous idiosyncrasies of famous scientists such as Fermi, Szilard, Teller, Feinman, Einstein, and more--plus key non-scientists like General Groves.

The second part of the book explores what might have happened after Hiroshima and Nagasaki, where a mystery drives Oppenheimer and his colleagues to SAVE the world, much as the Manhattan Project permanently CHANGED the world.

Highly recommended.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Reads like classic sci-fi

This novel was published in 2020 but reads like Classic sci-fi from the 50s. Perhaps it's because the story begins in 1936 and ends in 1967. Told completely chronologically, the first 4 hours of the tale takes us from Robert Oppenheimer's life as a college professor, through his involvement with the Manhattan Project, Hitler's death in 1945, and the dropping of The Bomb on Japan. It reads like a well-written biography of all the key players in the race for the A-bomb.

Then it takes a turn into alternative history. Edward Teller wants something more devastating: a weapon based on nuclear fusion - the mechanism that powers the sun. But Teller's research leads to a terrifying discovery: by 2030, the sun will eject its outermost layer, destroying the entire inner solar system, including Earth.

Interesting concept for a new book, and I enjoyed it, but not as much as previous Sawyer novels - I think because of the older time period. But if you love classic sci-fi, this is a modern "classic" you shouldn't miss.

I met Rob at a SF writer's conference in LA some years back and he's a great guy. I've enjoyed all of his novels, but my favorite - still - is Calculating God. Look it up, it's a 5-star read!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

So far, a major disappointment

Haven’t finished yet, but so far I’m pretty disappointed. The story is uninteresting and slow to get going. I’ll stick with it, because its Robert Sawyer, and I’ve never had a book of his I don’t like, but thinking this might be the first...

**edit** So I just finished it, and while the end is better than the beginning, it just doesn’t have the interest I’ve come to associate with Robert Sawyer. There was potential here, but I don’t feel it was realized. The science fiction got lost in the history, it was almost like the author spent lots of time researching the history and wanted to squish everything he found out, relevant to his story or not, in to the plot. Would have been better if he’d taken the idea, and written his own history to go along with it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Fascinating....

Sawyer does it again! A totally original journey through the history of the dawn of the nuclear age. Sawyer and Bloomberg bring the giants of the day ( Einstein, Grove, Teller, Oppie! ) to life in this sprawling, unique and fun listen.

Revisionist history, with a hard sci-fi bend to it. For some reason, this offering really resonated with me. Hearing Bloomberg give voice to long passed historical characters was grand fun, and educational as well.

Highly recommended for a variety of listeners, including history buffs. Spend the credit and enjoy it!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Real characters saving the world

Robert J Sawyer's The Oppenheimer Alternative is an alternate history tale that is mostly historically accurate, but with a twist. All the major significant physicists of the mid 20th, especially those directly involved with the Manhattan project to develop the atom bomb are here. Most of the historical events are portrayed true. Added to the mix is the added feature of those same top secrets scientists discovering that the sun has undergone an event that will propagate out and destroy the Earth around 2028 and they plot in super secret to save humanity.

Sawyer stays largely true to the actual historical events including some of the painful and embarrassing personal and professional behind the scenes activities during one of the most secret, but also public periods for physics. While the eventual resolution is a bit rushed at the end, the solution is ambitious, but still based in science fiction physics.

The narration is well done with very good character distinction. Pacing is reasonable. Keep Google handy throughout as confirmation for some of the detailed historical events will be needed as the truth sometimes strains credulity.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

History with a twist!

The Oppenheimer Alternative by Robert J. Sawyer is an alternate history novel that follows the group of the world's greatest physicists that developed the nuclear fission bomb during WWII. But in this timeline, this group of intellectuals discover an impending doom for mankind even greater than the Axis powers, and after their creation ends WWII with nuclear fire in Japan, they set about trying to solve this new problem for humanity's sake.

All the characters in this novel are real historical individuals, and their separate personalities, personal drives, and clashing egos make an excellent back drop for a great scifi story. This novel surprised me with its ending, but it did end the best way possible after a bit of reflection. A solid novel, and historically accurate depictions and descriptions of people and history until the story takes its turn make for both a history lesson and a great alternative history scifi read. A solid 3 1/2 to 4 star read from Robert J Sawyer, who is quickly becoming one of my favorite authors.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Wow

Very creative thought out story thoroughly enjoyed the book and the historical similarities. Great read

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

a glimpse into a history and a alternate future

from the moment I picked up my first Sawyer book, I have loved this author and this one was just as awesome as the rest. I was seriously impressed with the accuracy of historical fact and scientific information. and even tying it into theories about Crystal sun explosions due to micronova, . there is, a whole catastrophism theory about what caused the end of the ice age, in the younger dryas. and why there is a nano diamond, black mat of crystalline structures both, pretty much everywhere on this Earth and also on samples found on the moon. this sun, explosion theory, is an actual thing haha that I have studied for the last several years. when I saw what this book was about I said I had to read it. I follow on YT suspicious observers, space weather, and he has a whole series on catastrophism and micronova sun cycles, and sun cycles in general. if you're interested in this topic after you read this book I would check him out. the book actually left me wanting a second in the series and continuation, of the story. maybe we'll get lucky and Sawyer, will write one. excellent book if you're into science, history, The History of science, world war II history, deep state and pentagon projects, etc with a little twist this one is for you. the characters are all personalable believable, and interesting but all well known names in the history of the atomic age. very much enjoyed it I hope you do too.

ps, the narrator, is also great and does recognizable voices for all of the main characters. well done excellent listen

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Optionheimer

There are other stories about Opie that may be better but I rather like the,” alternate history” of this one. It just drug on some and I don’t have interest in the not related film. Big fan of author but this one was ok.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!