More Eddings than Tolkien

Would you try another book written by Brian D. Anderson or narrated by Derek Perkins?

In short no. The main protagonist was whiny and not really likable. I think it is a combination of the performance and lack of character depth that causes this.

Has The Godling Chronicles: The Sword of Truth, Book 1 put you off other books in this genre?

Not at all, I love this genre and will continue to read book from it.

Would you be willing to try another one of Derek Perkins’s performances?

Probably not, I found that the performance was disappointing, Gewey in particular is performed in such a whiny way that it was quite annoying.

What character would you cut from The Godling Chronicles: The Sword of Truth, Book 1?

Salma'tia and also Lee's confrontation with the Elf.

Any additional comments?

This story would probably make a great introduction to the genre. For more well read genre buffs you will not find this in any way satisfying. I came to this book having just read (listened to) Elantris by Brandon Sanderson and The Skull Throne by Brent Weeks both of those books are fantastic and this book just couldn't live up to the precedent.

Gewey is too whiny and snivelling for a protagonist, we get that he wants everyone to do the right thing, you don't need to reinforce it with wide-eyed innocence at every possible decision.

The book ends in an odd place, there's not really a cliff hanger as the "big climax" happens quite a bit before the end of the book and then it just tapers off into a nothing side story.

It's predictable at almost every point in the story, surprise! this character who appears kind isn't!

I don't think I will buy the second novel. Which will be the first time I ever let a series of books go unfinished (and I bought book 11 of the Wheel of Time after the disaster that was book 10 !)

3 people found this helpful

bare bones.

this book seems like a 1st draft. how it made it to publishing I have no idea. the characters are cliché which I can understand and can live with, but in terms of their development and consistency it is abysmal. Lee starfinder (the protagonist's mentor) is a douche. How Gewey or any other character haven't punched him in the face yet, I have no idea. for a mentor, he has a worrying case of bipolar. one moment he is praising Gewey for a spur of the moment recklessness, next moment he is berating him (a beginner) for his lack of experience during training. not even women would play you hot and cold to this extent. there is a severe lack in continuity in terms of character personalities.

also, chapter 3 (i think. forgive me if i recall incorrectly) where does one begin? I understand that you want to dedicate an entire chapter to giving Lee a back story by letting Lee give a camp fire story. but the way the author writes it makes it feel as though Lee is reading out his life story from a book rather than orally telling it. It was a tough chapter to overlook.

all in all, it is passable.....barely. the ideas although cliche are fine. but lacks skilful presentation. the book tries to do too many things at once and does not give the appropriate effort required to flesh them out. much more thought required. and definitely hire some better proof readers.

the narrator does his best with the material he has been given, but I can understand if he lost the will to put in anymore effort without actually having to re write the entire book itself.

2 people found this helpful

If you wrote a book while stealing all your ideas

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

Not really, i keep on hoping its a late bloomer but so far im still stuck with the poor spotty oik.

What was most disappointing about Brian D. Anderson’s story?

he feels like he has raped Chris P and Tolkien for ideas and with no clue or no decent publishers has vomited his gooey proceeds onto the pages. a poor info dumping mess i would say.

What aspect of Derek Perkins’s performance might you have changed?

altering your voice for different characters is seen a a good idea.

Do you think The Godling Chronicles: The Sword of Truth, Book 1 needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

im curious where will he go. like Geordie shore or keeping up with the Ks u cant look away from the drivel.

Any additional comments?

Only if your rich or have credits burning a whole in yore account buy this. only for the people with serious time or brain cell to kill

1 person found this helpful

Great book to listen to

Where does The Godling Chronicles: The Sword of Truth, Book 1 rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

Great book to listen to. Very easy listen story runs at a fast pace

What did you like best about this story?

Never a dull moment

1 person found this helpful

Just feels wet

What did you like best about The Godling Chronicles: The Sword of Truth, Book 1? What did you like least?

The scope is good, there is plenty of story the get involved with. The book is just childish, the twists are barely twists, everyone is really nice to one another, no real character depth.

What could Brian D. Anderson have done to make this a more enjoyable book for you?

Been a bit more gritty and no so weak.

Any additional comments?

I did read that this was aimed at teens but thought I would give it a try anyway, if you're in the same boat I would advise against it. The story has no bite and just plods through, they do this, they meet them, they become friends, no real excitement. The narration on the other hand was very good.

1 person found this helpful

a good start, i think this could be a long journey

If you could sum up The Godling Chronicles: The Sword of Truth, Book 1 in three words, what would they be?

really strong start

What did you like best about this story?

this has the potential to grow into something very interesting. I Iike the way that even in the first book parts of the story elements twist together and hope to see it develop in interesting ways. This seeding of plots reminds of the early books in the songs of ice and fire series

Have you listened to any of Derek Perkins’s other performances? How does this one compare?

I really like Derek Perkins performances, i think that he adds a real something to a story. His performance is great a usual.

Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

Laugh or cry , not really but it did keep me engaged and i will continue with the rest

1 person found this helpful

meh!

I probably wouldn't have finished this book if I was reading it myself. I found it very hard to care about the characters and the constant info dumps from characters narrating their own life events seemed dull. also the convenience of objects or characters turning up at the right time with no good reason just stank.... here have my hugely valuable magic sword. why? because you seem like a nice guy and it will be a plot point later in the story. oh come on!

2 people found this helpful

Narrator is terrible

Any additional comments?

A pretty good story really but the narrator lets it down by using the same voice for most of the characters.