Started 'meh' then got better.

Rough start for me but improved along the way. The attempts at Australian accents and women's voices are cringe worthy. I'll probably get the sequel.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

excellent sci fi

loved this book a lot. Great story and excellent narration. on to blood of heroes!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Narrator Squeezing out voices

Almost all the voices are unrealistic. Sounds like he's squeezing out the voice.
IDK, but it's really distracting.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Outstanding

This series is one of the most brilliant audiobooks available. So many great scifi concepts. A great performance and story. Highly recommended.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great original sci-fi delivered well!

This story is a great original and simple take on the sci-fi realm. It's a simple story written with everything simplified as much as possible, which makes it incredibly easy to follow and digest, although, for me, this had the side effect of making some points feel shallow.

The only two characters I really sympathised with and felt much for were Ibarra and Valdor, and to a slightly lesser extent Elias, but neither of them felt like they got the character exposition that they deserved, considering their sheer importance to the story and their own heft of power within the story.
And I get the impression that the full jist of what Stacey truly is will be explained in future books, but the hints at her biological makeup felt both underdone and overdone, considering the lack of an immediate answer to them within these two first books.

Some of the story -again just my perspective not quite an objective observation- felt rushed, or oversimplified.
Just like it's great simplifying sci-fi technical talk to make it easy to follow, it's also important to have just enough meat and potatoes behind it to make you feel that the characters are impassioned about it and give it a heavier importance to the story.

Before listening to the story, I was convinced to purchase based on a QA with Richard Fox I read. He mentioned those points I did above from a positive light, and my criticisms of them is purely from how I like to enjoy a sci-fi. The story itself seems to be very well written and delivered.
But one point in the QA which I did find very contradictory was the question and answer regarding why Humanity (modern day?) haven't heard from an alien civilization yet.
I believe that RF gave three possible explanations and used the third (There's something out there silencing civilizations before they can begin to use interstellar communication) to explain the why in this story.
And yet there is initial contact with the Alliance probe which propels the story forward. This point is in line with RF's answer, and the probe even explains why it decides to make contact considering Ibarra's discovery and how it can be used to propel Humanity forward.
Later, it's revealed that the probe is from an Alliance of alien species, which again feels in line with that answer, giving the impression that they were only perhaps a dozen or so different races.
But in the 2nd book, it's revealed that there are (perhaps) hundreds of races in the Alliance. And that many of them were already capable of advanced space flight and interstellar contact prior to the Xaros and the Alliance contact, contradicting the why for why the stars are so silent.
This point stood out to me and really knocked me off track on enjoying the story as much and I felt shook the core motivation of the story.

My next point that reeeeaaaallllyyyy bothered me was the Australian character. I am Australian, partly raised in US as well so I personally have a very in-between accent. But NEVER have I heard an accent as stereotypically atrocious as the one delivered in this narration.
Upon hearing it and realizing it was meant to be Australian, I tried to focus on the dialogue rather than how it was spoken and found that the "Australianisms" used were, likewise to the narration, stereotypically atrocious.
The most "Australian'ish" accents and speaking I've ever heard have been in Darwin, and they didn't hold a candle to the Australian in this.

My negative points aside, for the most parts, the narration was well done, but how bad the Australian part was put me off so much that I couldn't give that more than a 2-star rating.

The story is well written and brings a new take to Humanity expanding into the stars and contesting with peaceful and waring alien races in an easy to follow and enjoyable fashion.

The characters, whilst I felt were overly simplified, were still solid characters and were shown in a way that can make you understand their motivations and views.

I will most certainly be working my way through the rest of the novels over time.

And I thank the author for putting the work into making this.

I would definitely suggest this story to any sci-fi lover out there.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

enjoyable

great voice acting, making each character stand out.
story was entertaining with moderate leaning on tropes

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

loved it!

Loved going back to this book over and over ahain. the performance is outstanding!!!! keep up the good work!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Enjoyable and gripping

Would you consider the audio edition of The Ember War to be better than the print version?

The audio book is exceptionally enjoyable and accessible when driving or relaxing while working around the house. With 2 Children it is not always easy to devote time a print version.

What does Luke Daniels bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you had only read the book?

The narration was excellent overall with good character vocal inflection. The only grating aspect is the Australian accent. As an Australian myself I find it over acted and hope I don't sound like that to others.

If you made a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?

Phoenix from the embers

Any additional comments?

This is a great story without some of the over hyped military macho ism. The characters have more depth and frailty than is generally seen is this genre. All up a great plot, well executed. I will definitely work through the series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Want modern gripping Sci fi this story is the one.

This story has modern tec, ideas. when u think you coming to the story peak a new level kicks in. love to see this in a movie.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great experience.

This audiobook gets better each time I listen to it. I am carried away to another time and place.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!