Narration not for me

I enjoy Mary Beard and I found the content interesting - others have covered this in their reviews. I was looking forward to something narrated by Phyllida Nash, but somehow this disappoints. I think it is her knack of breaking sentences, albeit long ones with a few subclauses, into rather strange chunks. In some places, it almost sounds like she is running out of breath. Eg “First, the Romans were not by nature more belligerent than their neighbours | And contemporaries.”

31 people found this helpful

The tale of Rome on a grand scale. Fascinating.

A massive undertaking packed with not just historical facts, but the human side of the story too. Rationally looking at some of the stories of Rome and putting them into context. Absolutely fascinating.

19 people found this helpful

Narration needs re-editing in parts

Thus was a brilliantly researched book and at times very very easy to listen to but there are a number of sections where you can hear that the narrator has recorded and then re recorded parts where she's unsure of the pronunciation of certain words.

16 people found this helpful

BCE overload

Thoroughly enjoyed it but if I never hear the term BCE ever again it will be too soon

11 people found this helpful

Interesting and erudite

What made the experience of listening to SPQR the most enjoyable?

Mary Beard is one of our leading Classical scholars and yet this is a very entertaining and readable (or listenable) book. Rather than being a flighty survey of the period, Beard provides an accessible, clear and interesting broad account of Rome without watering it down.

What was one of the most memorable moments of SPQR?

Beard's use of recent scholarship within a solid survey of the period.

Have you listened to any of Phyllida Nash’s other performances? How does this one compare?

Pompeii by Mary Beard. Another fine performance.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Probably not - you would want to dip into this and reflect before moving onto the next chapter in order not to be overwhelmed by the depth of the text.

44 people found this helpful

Brilliant!

Where does SPQR rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

Very very highly. Mary Beard has provided me with a much needed overview of Roman history. It's a cleverly crafted book, moving steadily forward through the historical dimension but pausing from time to time to explore the big themes in depth or to meet the big characters. And it's not just the big names it introduces us to; some of the most moving episodes concern ordinary people whose lives we can only glimpse through the archaeology, perhaps an inscription on a gravestone.The author always tells us what evidence lies behind the historical consensus, sometimes questioning it and sometimes admitting to lack of conviction. It was often funny and irreverant and never dull or self important.

What other book might you compare SPQR to, and why?

Other good histories such as Robert Goodwin's Spain.

What does Phyllida Nash bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you had only read the book?

A model narrator. She animates Mary Beard's prose (which hardly needs animating) and, importantly, stays in the background.

Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

Very satisfying.

37 people found this helpful

I'm struggling

Is there anything you would change about this book?

I love watching Mary on TV as she brings the subject to life with her passion and huge knowledge. In this audio book the knowledge is there but I am missing her unique story telling. The narrator does her best but obviously doesn't really know what she is talking about and although I love this topic, I've had three goes at this and it just sends me to sleep. Disappointed.

30 people found this helpful

Dates became wearing

Living in Italy I've done a lot of reading about the history. Whilst the information is great in this book I found the date references, in almost every sentence, quite wearing after a while. I'm not sure if it was me but I also felt we were jumping about in time a bit.

5 people found this helpful

some bring history to life

this puts it to sleep!

I love Roman culture, but this just drags. skips the fun bits and gets hung up on the impartiality, as if there is such a thing.

4 people found this helpful

Passion and Majesty

"Who could be so indifferent or so idle that they did not want to find out how, and under what kind of political organisation, almost the whole of the inhabited world was conquered and fell under the sole power of the Romans in less than fifty-three years, something previously unparalleled?" – Polybius (c. 200 – 118 BCE)

Mary Beard is everything one could ask from an academical mind writing for anyone else rather than one’s most immediate peers. A gifted scholar, she’s also a great writer and storyteller; a great teacher, that is, she knows that knowing isn't enough without the ability to share that knowledge. That to teach is to always remain a learner oneself.

Ms Beard knows how to unfold her story. The most thrilling audiobook I’ve listened to this autumn hasn’t been the new Galbraith thriller nor the David Mitchell ghost story, it has been Ms Beard’s version of Rome. The book is masterly chiseled out of marble. One of its strengths is that it doesn’t sell its vision as the definite word, but rather as one version, as reflected in the subtitle for the book, where instead of the pompous definite article it reads ”A History of Rome” instead. I also had to get the book so that whenever I was unable to listen, I could at least steal an occasional glance or two at it. It’s that good.

I’ve had a soft spot for Roman history not only for the interesting and larger-than-life stories the era presents, but also because of its centrality in the spreading of the early Christian Church, as well as the evolution of the Latin language and its influence on two that I happen to a be a teacher of. Beard’s new book is a welcome breath of fresh air to this interest of mine, and in history in general.

Where does one start with the history of Ancient Rome? From the ”beginning”? From the ”end?” Ms Beard starts from 63 BCE, the year of Cicero’s consulate and the Catiline conspiracy. From there she reaches all the way back to the mythical beginning, proceeds to the age of kings before the Republic, and advancesuntil the 2nd century CE, well into the golden age of the Empire. Her constant focus is the Senatus Populusque Romanus, the senate and the people of Rome, so she ends her book at 212 CE, when the emperor Caracalla made every free inhabitant of the Empire a full Roman citizen. This structure works well. She’s able to look at the big picture, plunge in and discuss details, move back and forth in time, and emphasize connections between ideas and events.

Ms Beard also proves her experise and academic maturity with her historical skepticism, and the book is full of he fine humour as well as an obvious passion for knowledge. All of this presented with great majesty of style.

Phyllida Nash’s narration is exquisite and really gets the conversational tone of Beard’s writing. This audiobook successfully transcends a mere ”reading”. It’s like Nash and Beard are telling all this just for me as we’re walking through Villa Borghese and marvelling at the cityscape, full of new and old.

”Pompeii: The Life of a Roman Town” is also available, also read by Nash. It’s a must. This year we’ve also been treated to Peter Fankopan’s ”The Silk Roads: A New History of the World” so there’s a lot to be excited about if you love gazing at the horizon.

55 people found this helpful