Is The Everlasting really a six-star read — and should you read it?

In this episode, we’re diving into one of the most talked-about books on BookTok and Bookstagram, often hailed as a top book of 2025 and a romantasy that the genre should be taking notes from. We start with a spoiler-free recap to set the stage, then break down our honest thoughts, reactions, and reflections.

We discuss why The Everlasting feels different from copy-and-paste romantasy, how it challenges reader expectations, and whether the hype actually holds up. From nuanced character dynamics to morally complex villains and layered themes, this conversation is all about what worked, what challenged us, and what lingered after the final page.

Finally, we answer the question everyone wants to know: who should read this book — and who might want to skip it. We also wrap up by sharing the 2026 book releases we’re most excited for, including upcoming sequels, romance standouts, fantasy favorites, and genre-bending reads we already can’t stop thinking about.

✨ In this episode:

• Spoiler-free recap of The Everlasting
• Honest romantasy discussion & genre critique
• Our ratings and final verdict
• Should you read this? Who it’s perfect for (and who it’s not)
• The 2026 book releases we’re most excited about

If you’ve been wondering whether The Everlasting lives up to the hype — or you’re looking for your next meaningful fantasy romance — this one’s for you.

✨ Follow @bookbitsclub on Instagram & TikTok for more book club chaos, recaps, recs, and reviews.