As a native New Yorker and Mets fan, it would be impossible for me to address the best in baseball without paying respect to “the Franchise” himself. Hall of Famer Tom Seaver, one of the greatest pitchers in baseball history who represented the very heart of the New York Mets, passed away on August 31, 2020. To understand what Seaver meant to the game and to the NL East underdogs, look no further than acclaimed sports journalist Wayne Coffey’s They Said It Couldn’t Be Done. Chronicling the rise and unexpected triumph of the 1969 Miracle Mets, this listen follows “Tom Terrific” and his teammates as they catapulted from league laughingstock to World Champions. What really makes this audiobook soar is the familiar, warm narration of the incomparable Gary Cohen, who has been the beloved play-by-play announcer for the Mets on SportsNet NY (SNY) for 15 years.

For professional ballplayers, there are few honors as aspirational and humbling as being inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame. From Lou Gehrig to Hank Aaron to Willie Mays to Ted Williams, golden placards of men-turned-legends line the walls of Cooperstown, representing the very best the game has to offer. In this comprehensive collection, biographies of every inductee into the Hall—from its inception to 2014—give listeners a glimpse into what makes a player truly great. To lend an even more intimate touch, Hall of Fame position players offer their own perspective in a series of essays woven throughout the narrative. The result is a listen that offers an in-depth history of baseball’s giants and a window into how sports superstars become national heroes.

Every fan has experienced this moment: you’re sitting in the stands, chowing down on a hot dog, your eyes glued to the field. The count’s 3-2 and you’re on the edge of your seat as the batter steps back towards the plate. He’s nearly struck by the pitch and you’re sure he’s about to walk when you see the home plate ump hammer his fist forward, and you realize he’s been called out. And though it might be painful to watch, Keith Law, senior baseball writer for The Athletic, argues that what we might deem a terrible call may actually have its roots in psychology and cognitive science. In The Inside Game, Law sets out to analyze the motivation behind vexing decisions in baseball, from the choice to swing to the deliberations behind some of the biggest trades in history. This fascinating and fun delve into the biases, belief systems, and behavioral patterns that can lead to seriously misguided decision-making just might give you a better understanding of the reasoning behind those frustrating trades and calls.

On April 15, 1947, Jackie Robinson made history when he shattered the color barrier that kept professional baseball segregated. The Hall of Fame inductee originally played for the Negro League’s Kansas City Monarchs before being signed to the Brooklyn Dodgers, where he made tremendous strides for the civil rights movement, particularly in regards to sports and entertainment. In his touching and inspiring memoir I Never Had It Made, Robinson details his time with the Dodgers, the discrimination and abuse he routinely faced during his trailblazing MLB run, and his life after retirement. While you might be familiar with his illustrious career, the heart of this listen lies in hearing Robinson explain, in his own words, which are brilliantly voiced by actor and activist Ossie Davis, stories from his childhood, the devastating impact of Jim Crow laws, and the anguish of helping his son through addiction only to tragically lose him in a car accident. Though he endured great pain throughout the course of his life, Robinson exhibits an admirably strong sense of determination and grace that is second to none. And it’s that exact depth of character that made him a hero on and off the field.

It’d be impossible to craft a list of the best baseball audiobooks of all time without tipping our caps to former World Series champ Jim Bouton and his adored (and controversial!) diary-memoir, Ball Four. This author-narrated irreverent retelling of memories made in the season of 1969 made quite a stir when it was initially published, as it was among the first to strip the uptight veneer off of sports reporting and recount events as they really happened, even when they verged on uncouth. It earned him censure from then-commissioner Bowie Kuhn, teammates, and adversaries alike—Pete Rose of the Cincinnati Reds, for one, generated headlines with his own obscene opinion shouted towards Bouton from the dugout, while others labeled him a traitor or a social pariah. But what Bouton achieved in exposing the previously unseen life of the professional athlete—the womanizing, the drug use, the foul language and off-color jokes, the frustrations with coaches and managers—was quite remarkable. His refreshing honesty and humor humanized larger-than-life American heroes and paved the way for sportswriters to come.

There’s nothing quite like the beauty and exhilaration of a baseball stadium. From stunning architecture to the contrast of perfectly manicured grass and deep, ruddy sand, ballparks are one-of-a-kind structures that reflect the city, traditions, and character of the home team. Pulitzer Prize-winning architecture critic Paul Goldberger serves up an exquisite history in the aptly titled Ballpark, taking a cross-country, century-spanning journey from Brooklyn’s Union Grounds to Cincinnati’s Palace of the Fans to Baltimore’s Camden Yards. Goldberger uses his expertise to analyze how the American ballpark reflects shifts in socioeconomics and the prospects of urban development and growth. If you ever wanted details beyond the diamond, this listen is a joyful exploration of the parks we love and the future of stadiums to come.

New York Yankees great Yogi Berra is foremost known for his skills behind home plate, but his so-called “Yogi-isms”—endearing and oddly inspirational malapropisms and perplexing quips—have taken on a legacy on their own. Amongst the most famous? Berra was quoted as saying: “Baseball is ninety percent mental. The other half is physical.” Mathematics aside, Bob Tewksbury would seem to agree. In Ninety Percent Mental, the former MLB pitcher and current Cubs mental skills coordinator gives listeners an inside look at the cognitive aerobics that baseball players employ every time they take the mound or step up to the plate. In both his writing and his narration, Tewksbury speaks with a well-earned sense of authority on the subject of sports psychology, discussing how players are able to wield mental tools like imagery and strategic planning to get in the zone and reach peak performance. This is a must-listen for any baseball fan who’s ever been curious about what’s going on inside their favorite player’s head.

If you’re looking for an audiobook that focuses on the history of baseball itself, Play Ball! is an excellent Great Courses pick. Written by baseball historian Peter Morris and Baseball Hall of Fame researcher and presenter Bruce Markusen, this comprehensive chronicle offers a glimpse into how a simple bat-and-ball game originating decades before the Civil War evolved into the booming industry and nation-defining pastime that it is today. In a series of 24 lectures narrated by Markusen himself, this listen is a balanced, complete retelling of the history of the game—and all the challenges, changes, and controversies that developed along the way. From the origins of gear like catcher’s masks to the difficulties faced by women and African Americans who took the field, Play Ball! offers up an informative account that will give you a new appreciation for the sport.

Though they might seem like relics of a bygone era, the collecting and trading of baseball cards is still a hobby with a dedicated following. If you want to learn more about how those glossy pieces of cardstock altered the history of baseball forever, check out journalist Dave Jamieson’s history, Mint Condition. After Jamieson learned there was no resale demand for his childhood baseball card collection nor card shops to visit, he decided to trace the rise and fall of the baseball card industry—from its origins as an advertising technique in packs of cigarettes and gum (the latter of which helped the sweets industry through the Great Depression) to the lucrative multi-billion dollar trade it had become by the 1980s. This audiobook deftly explores both the impact of cards on unions and the sport as a whole, as well as ins-and-outs of collecting, including card grading and value. The result is a loving, nostalgia-inducing portrait of enthusiasts. (And if you’re interested in the players immortalized in the cards themselves, follow this listen up with Brad Balukjian’s The Wax Pack, a rollicking series of interviews with those featured in a pack of cards from 1986.)

Fastball, slider, changeup, cutter, sinker, curveball, knuckleball, splitter, screwball, spitball: these are the titular pitches that Tyler Kepner, national baseball writer for The New York Times, examines in his charming, author-narrated K: A History of Baseball in Ten Pitches. A fascinating exploration of baseball history through the dynamics of how just a slight variation in the way a pitcher grips a ball can make a world of difference in trajectory and speed, K is brought to life by a colorful cast of characters whose innovations changed the art of pitching forever. Kepner—whose enthusiasm and mastery on the subject shine in both his writing and delivery—offers insights garnered from discussions with major league aces, including Nolan Ryan, Bob Gibson, and Mariano Rivera, crafting what just might be the definitive work on the background and mechanics of what makes a truly filthy pitch.

If you haven’t yet heard the story of Toni Stone, the first of only three woman to play professional baseball for the all-male Negro League’s Indianapolis Crowns, don’t miss Martha Ackmann’s excellent biography, Curveball. Ackmann follows Stone’s journey from a tomboyish childhood spent reading rulebooks and pitching for the local boys-only baseball team to her boundary-shattering big break. Sensing an opening when Black players began to join a newly integrated major league, Stone stepped up to replace home-run hero Hank Aaron on the Crowns before later taking a spot on Jackie Robinson's former team, the Kansas City Monarchs. Overcoming tremendous adversity on the field and off, Stone persevered through the sting of both racism and misogyny to emerge as one of sport’s greatest unsung heroes: an unapologetic, extremely talented young woman unafraid to break society’s rules in order to follow her dreams.