Check out more selections from Oprah's Book Club.
©1999 by Janet Fitch; (P) and ©1999 Time Warner AudioBooks (Packaging Elements Only), A Division of Time Warner Trade Publishing
"...[an] impressive first novel.... her startlingly apt language relates a story that is both intelligent and gripping." (The New York Times Book Review)
There are no listener reviews for this title yet.
I was caught up in the rhythm and language of this book from the first paragraph...In its original form. Too much is lost in the edited version. Oprah has a very rich voice, but I think the maturity and depth is wrong for this book. I hope Audible will post a different version when/if one is available.
"Like the wings of a dark bird on a September night"
This book has more adjectives then a democratic convention. Fluff that takes it's time getting to the point. I found the story interesting but was VERY disappointed that 1) it is the abridged version 2) it isn't true. (my fault for not checking) Top that off with Oprah's reading. I've nothing against Oprah but there is a time and a place for everything. It's hard to get the feeling that a teenaged blond white girl is telling the story who has a voice and accent like Oprah's. Everyone in the story had a "unique" accent that didn't fit (or even come close to) the background they were supposed to be from. This is just a bad match.
"I stayed up late just to see what happened next..."
This was my first listen at Audible, and I loved it! True enough, I do wish it was unabridged, it did leave out a bit, but I loved the drama, and even the garden language, I definately enjoyed! I stayed up after my late three hour drive just to hear more...I would rate a must listen!
"not the real version"
I bought the paper back book and read about a 1/4 of it- today I had to make a very long drive so I decided to download the audiobook and finish it that way. well this was not the same as the novel I bought. this is edited and numerous chapters and characters left out. I think it may be the screenplay version not the real, good, version. I wish that would have been included in the information section because then I wouldn't have wasted my money. I listened to it anyway because I didn't have anything else prepared. very disappointing. I would suggest to everyone to buy the book rather than listen to this dulled down version
"Great book, dissappointed about it being Abriged."
The book, yes, this version, no. I felt there was a lot that was missed by having it abriged.
"Glad I read it."
I had seen the movie several years ago and decided to read the book. Excellent story.
"Beautifully written, wonderful performance!"
I read this book some years ago when it first came out, then read it again. It is poetically written and a complex and interesting storey about a daughter's relationship with her insane and controlling mother. I feel I know these characters. I was born in LA and lived West Hollywood until I was twelve...the author is right on target. Oprah's reading of this book is absolutely the best. Her beautiful voice and the way she rounds out the words make this experience like a 6 hour poetry reading. I have hundreds of audible books in my library and this is now in my top 3 favs. Rum Diarys read by Campbell Scott and Raveling read by Eric Stoltz are the other two.
"Such a beautiful book"
This book was so well written and was such a beautiful story. It was heartbreaking and charming all at the same time.
First time coming across a Janet Finch book. Well-written. Oprah is amazing with the audio!!!!
"Oprah Winfrey magnificent read"
The story was fabulous but Oprah reading it added so much to it for me, sometimes I didn't even recognize her voice, I loved it so much. Great, great read.
Her own take on the characters, bringing them to life. It was truely fabulous
I'll come back to this one. It wouldn't be so much any of the characters but Oprah and then to talk about the book and the parts we liked/disliked etc.
I have yet to have a bad read from any of the audible books regardless of author or reader.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.