Her methods may not be conventional, and her manner not exactly Miss Marple, but she's got warmth, wit, and canny intuition on her side, not to mention Mr J.L.B. Maketoni, the charming proprietor of Tlokweng Road Speedy Motors.
And Precious is going to need them all as she sets out on the trail of a missing child, a case that tumbles our heroine into a hotbed of strange situations and more than a little danger.
Delightfully different, The No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency offers a captivating glimpse of an unusual world.
©1998 Alexander McCall Smith; (P)2003 Isis Publishing Ltd
Some lovely observations about the place, but it's largely really simplistic. The characters aren't complex, the dialogue between them is really childish - it makes the people sound very naive and simple minded. There are many broad generalisations being made about the different ethnic groups and about men and women in particular.
Given that this is a book written by an Englishman about African people, the naivety of the characters feels condescending. There's a running theme about the 'good old days' and what 'real Africa' is and should be. I think those types of themes need to be handled carefully especially when written by an outsider, and nuance is important. This lacked that, and it came across as a simplistic view of a complex place and people (as if Africans should all be child like and sit around watching cattle).
The narrator added to this feeling, a very British primary school teacher accent and tone. An actor from Botswana would have been perfect, or at the very least someone who could sound like Precious Ramotswe.
"The No.1 Ladies' Detective Agency"
Lovely book, easy to listen to, very entertaining. Innocent.
"An enjoyable listen"
Had heard of a number of others who had read/listened to this book, so although the title had originally put me off, I decided to try it myself.
I was glad I did - this was a thoroughly enjoyable story and the narrator did a good job of bringing it to life.
Definitely agree - easy listening! Being from South Africa, is was a good reflection of "ubuntu" and the lead characters approach to detecting was, at many times, cute!
somehow I couldn't believe a word from 'the lady'. Very black and white, all men are cheaters or stupid.
"Better than on television!"
I thoroughly enjoyed listening to this Audiobook, having already watched the series on television. It captivated my attention and I found jobs to do that allowed me time to finish listening to it. The story gave a view into a totally different world to mine which I found fascinating.
"A Pleasant Renewal of an Old Aquaintance"
I loved listening to this recording. I was a fan of the original book and having re-aquainted myself with it I realise that these characters/stories were just made to be read aloud. It was a bargain too, well worth the price.
Having listened to the incomparable Adjoa Andoh narrate the rest of the series, it was a bitter disappointed to discover that Hilary Neville is incapable of even pronouncing 'Gabarone' correctly. I was unable to listen for more that 2 minutes and regret my purchase immensely!
This book was sooo good I blasted through it in one day - also had to find places to go and things to do in order to listen to it all.... captivating...
The TV series spin off of the books are good fun but this is insightful too... well worth a download.
were rty er tyrt y rt rt yr ty rt yr ty rtr ty rt uyt utyu yu e erty r ety rty rt y rtyer t er tyrt yr ty
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.