Like most families, they had their secrets...
...and they hid them under a genteelly respectable veneer. No onlooker would guess that prim Vera Hillyard and her beautiful, adored younger sister, Eden, were locked in a dark and bitter combat over one of those secrets. England in the '50s was not kind to women who erred, so they had to use every means necessary to keep the truth hidden behind closed doors - even murder.
©1986 Kingsmarkham Enterprises Ltd (P)2014 Audible, Inc.
I loved this book. The characters and behaviour were fascinating set in a time when pretence of social position was vitally important to many people. It left me wondering who indeed was the real mother of the child. I am definitely going to read more by Barbara Vine. Highly recommended.
"Even better in audio form"
This has long been one of my favorite books. I've read it many times and recommended it to many other people. But it has been a few years since I last read it, and the narration, which I listened to while driving to and from NYC is wonderfully excellent.
This book requires a lot of thought, and is a perfect match for the audio format. Having the extra time to really appreciate the subtleties, mysteries, and deep character development is the strength of this format. You'd miss much of this when only reading. The narrator is top knotch, nailing the nuances and exploring the maturation of the main character over time. I can't recommend this one enough.
"Well-written, absorbing psychological mystery"
I bought this on the basis of audible reviews and was not disappointed. This is not an edge-of-your-seat mystery. It unfolds slowly and moves deeper and deeper into the characters, their histories and their motivations. It is beautifully narrated by Harriet Walter. If you're looking for something to lose yourself in and spend some time with, I recommend it.
"Family secrets and lies"
And shocking revelations! Really, what more could you want? This book was fantastic, the story twisty and gripping, and the narration lively. Absolutely recommended!
"Great story, fabulous narration!"
I wasn't sure about this story for the first couple of chapters but any book narrated by Harriet Walter's is worth a listen so I carried on and I'm so glad I did. This mystery is so cleverly written and the characters are brought to life so perfectly by the narrator. This is my first Barbara Vine novel but it certainly won't be my last.
"Performance Outshines the Story"
Story is drawn out and the mystery or twist is easy to surmise. Overly detailed at times, especially when describing clothes or interior design elements. If Jane Austen had written a politely "shocking" novel, it would be this one.
However, it is well read and performed. The performance was the only thing that kept me listening.
A few mispronounced words in the performance, but otherwise a nice job at giving each character a voice that fit. The story had a lot of interesting characters, but did very little with them in either growth, or action. I like the language very much.
I found the beginning of this book boring but I stayed the course and glad I did.
"A psychological can study of a maladaptive "
This novel started out slow, but stick with it - you will be glad you did. The pace isn't fast, but you'll be deeply drawn into the story of a dysfunctional English family during the Second World War and their very unique history, relationships and secrets. A highly satisfying case study of human psychology and what motivates us all.
"fascinating family intrigue"
This is more an interesting and complicated look at the psychological workings of a family divided than it is a mystery.......though there are and remain several mysterious parts to the whole. It takes a while to get into the story, but as it continually unrolls it is more and more intriguing, drawing the listener deeper and deeper into the family machinations. The continuing family revelations experienced by the protagonist make sense of the title....A "Dark Adapted Eye" can see things that were formerly hidden in the darkness.
of repressed women, different generations. Every family has a secret (if not several) that is not completely known by all members within the family. I liked this story because it reads very true to life, in that things are not at all what they appear to be--that sometimes it's easier to fool someone you love than a stranger.
"Compelling exposure of a family’s secrets"
The author’s forte is in her depiction of human relationships whether writing detective fiction as Ruth Rendell or in her more psychological novels as Barbara Vine. This book is not a detective story and from the beginning we know that Vera has killed her sister Eden. The whole book is a detailed unravelling of why this occurred through the voice of Faith: the niece of the victim and perpetrator. Most of the characters are flawed and not particularly likeable but the narrative is utterly compelling and I was drawn into a hot-house of emotions among family members and their their dysfunctional relationships.
This is justifiably rated as one of the author’s best books and made a great listen.
Harriet Walter is an accomplished narrator and skilfully portrayed both young and old, male and female.
This book is often rated as Ruth Rendell's best, and I agree. It's so much more than a crime novel; and Ruth Rendell is so much more than a crime writer. It's not for nothing Jeanette Winterson calls her mother.
Having read the preview, I did hesitate, as I wondered whether it would be too unsettling at night going to sleep listening to the 'voice' of a victim/ criminal without Inspector Wexford as a sane, down-to-earth intermediary, but it wasn't the case at all. The narrator of the story is an ingenue, and it was performed wonderfully by Harriet Walter.
"Horribly plausible - beautifully written"
This densely plotted tale shows how family jealousies, snobbish attitudes and social taboos create a toxic brew. murder becomes the plausible, almost banal outcome. Beautifullly written and sensitively natrated.
"Typical Barbara Vine excellent!"
Harriet Walter reads beautifully. Look forward to another one. As always Vine never disappoints. I have been reading her books for years.
"What a find! Barbara Vine at her best"
Couldn't stop listening to this. She is so good at drawing you into the dark secrets of a family.
The narration is superb too.
Very good indeed
"Brilliant story, with dark and complex characters"
A brilliant, dark, thought-provoking story with some of the most well-realised and complex characters I’ve ever come across. Whatever ‘crime’ novels or ‘detective fiction’ or ‘thrillers’ are usually supposed to be, for me this utterly transcended those genres. As the narrator comments, we know from the start who the killer is and how the murder was done. Instead of focussing on that, Barbara Vine (Ruth Rendell) unfolds the psychology of the Hillyard family with a perceptiveness that sometimes takes your breath away. It made me think that other books I’ve read with supposedly ‘deep’ or ‘complex’ characters are quite flat and obvious by comparison. There are lots of twists in the plot, but they never felt like contrivances or clever tricks. They come about as Faith, the character who narrates the story, grows gradually wiser and more perceptive about the secretive ways of her two aunts – as her ‘eye’ adapts to understand their dark behaviour, to paraphrase the title. Harriet Walter was an excellent reader, appropriately understated in her delivery but giving distinctive, memorable voices to the characters, many of whom are painfully repressed and reserved. This is the first Barbara Vine/Ruth Rendell I’ve read or listened to, and I’ll certainly read more now.
Lots of descriptions, not much happening. I fell asleep after about 10 minutes of listening to this.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.