When a mixed martial arts (MMA) gym moves in across the street from his office, Jonathan Gottschall sees a challenge and an opportunity. Pushing 40, out of shape, and disenchanted with his job as an adjunct English professor, part of him yearns to cross the street and join up. The other part is terrified.
Gottschall eventually works up his nerve and starts training for a real cage fight. He's fighting not only as a personal test but also to answer questions that have intrigued him for years: Why do men fight? And why do so many seemingly decent people like to watch? Gottschall endures extremes of pain, occasional humiliation, and the incredulity of his wife to take us into the heart of fighting culture - culminating, after almost two years of grueling training, in his own cage fight.
Gottschall's unsparing personal journey crystallizes in his epiphany, and ours, that taming male violence through ritualized combat has been a hidden key to the success of the human race. Without the restraining codes of the monkey dance, the world would be a much more chaotic and dangerous place.
©2015 Jonathan Gottschall (P)2015 Recorded Books
This is not your typical story of how a boring man became great, it is rather an exploration of the engaging topic of violence and evolutionary psychology, it presents answers to many questions that we as men have asked without an answer. Walking the talk the professor goes to look for answers in the literature and in the cage.
"Not what I was expecting"
I anticipated this would be a story of a soft professor who climbed into the MMA world and learned about life and love and had a few chuckles along the way.
I was wrong.
It's a much deeper look into masculinity and why men fight. I was fascinated and pleased with his treatment of it if only because as a man who regularly steps onto a jiu jitsu mat, I too feel the primal pleasure of the fight.
All sports bear the unnecessary weight of superstition, but mixed martial arts (MMA) moreso than any other. Partly this is owed to ‘the warfare analogue‘, native to every competitive exercise, being much less figurative—the loser of a fight experiencing, in as many cases as not, an end or preface to an end more approximate (and in closer proximity) to that of one’s life. Mostly, however, it is because martial arts are surpassingly the hard kernel of real-world, bona fide superstitions: systems and traditions of belief held orthodoxically or generically about the conscientious harness of energy with the body. The Professor in the Cage is author and scholar Jonathan Gottschall’s study of these collected and often contradicting combat disciplines, blow by blow, for fifteen months. Disciplines which, when set simultaneously in concert and at odds inside a steel cage, allow for seemingly limitless results, no matter how faithful an outcome may formerly appear.
The book, to its credit, is far from straight-arrow anthropology. Gottschall discourages the romantic notion, which devoted fight fans may entertain in an effort to pacify guilt or stigma, that it is one’s intellectual cupidity which principally drives his or her desire to fight, or (more likely the case) to watch fighting, and he holds it as unenlightened as to believe—as nonfans may—that it is a lack of intelligence or civility. The Professor in the Cage corrects for both these pandemic misconceptions, but not without correcting some of its own. Gottschall, upon first entering Mark Shrader’s Mixed Martial Arts Academy (located across the street from his English department office at Washington & Jefferson College), promptly finds his assumptions about fighting and fighters whited out.
Gottschall’s title, of course, implies novelty. The checker on the chessboard. Columbus discovering his New World. “The main objective of fighting sports,” he writes, “is to temporarily shut down the other guy’s brain,” so why, the reader wonders, would an academic join a brain-damage academy? Why join ‘the savages’? But one of the first lessons Gottschall learns is how unremarkable his lack of qualifications really is. (Even newly minted UFC heavyweight champion, Stipe Miocic, works full-time as a firefighter outside of training.) Violence, Gottschall argues, is simply an appetite that all men have (and here he explores why men and not women, disproportionately, are thus disposed). Oftentimes it is those who were victims in the past, he points out, or whose present vocation is so far removed from even a whisper of such indulgences, that are more likely to strap on the gloves.
A writer able to present the facts with a fabulist’s flare, Gottschall uses mixed martial arts as a kind of literary chariot through man’s history of violence. Because, under these lights, surely, why men fight is not nearly the conundrum that “why don’t they“ is. As for why we watch, Gottschall believes the driving ecstasy of fighting is its being “a genre of staged tragedy”, such as bullfighting was for Hemingway and boxing for Oates. “If boxing is a sport,” Gottschall quotes Oates as saying, “it is the most tragic of all sports because more than any human activity it consumes the very excellence it displays.” Reflecting on, as in the introduction to this review, the simulational talent of an MMA canvas to manifest not only displays of athletic pyrotechny but the circumstances of said athletes’ demise—unconsciousness here generated by choking as well as striking—this is all the more apt.
“A fight,” Gottschall concludes, “is drama sweated to the bones—an enactment of the whole human tangle, with everything lovely and terrible on display.” And with mixed martial arts’ continued rise in popularity, per annum, those stage lights now double as microscopes. There is little tolerance on the modern fightscape for what Gottschall calls “the myth of the martial arts”, the notion that any of these disciplines represents the perfect and sacred schematic for mano a mano combat; the last twenty years have without question illuminated flaws and strengths both relative and respective. As does The Professor in the Cage—which, in keeping with the traditions it grapples, is an education on mind even moreso than body. This, however, in no way keeps the book from earning its title as one of the most engaging, down-to-earth examinations of sport and human violence one will find.
(Quincy Dunn-Baker's narration, by the way, is engaging from start to finish and absolutely perfect for the material.)
"makes you want to fight someone"
... but in a good way. I have always wanted to do what Jonathan did for this book and it does make me want to get out there and try it even more now.
The writing is aggressive but it's real and intense. He talks and references how men really talk and sometimes it's rude but it's the last remaining scraps of manliness I think.
if you are thinking about doing mma this is definitely a book to read or listen to.
Great book and great reader. I knocked it out in just a couple of days. Couldn't wait for my free time (making the drive to school each day) so I could listen to more!
"Entertaining, educational and gripping"
This was one of the best books i have bought on audible. out of many on many different topics. The personal story was very honest and well told, the historical anecdotes were very fitting, not to long or to short, well founded and objective. The narration was great, well paced and engaging. A great book overall for anyone who are interested in fighting, bot for novice and medium experienced people like myself. The only thing that bothered me was the author complaining about his age, at 39 you are not an old man, i know people fighting since their 20s up to their 60s, i am myself 35 and i will fight my first mma fight this year. However the book was great and for those who like it should also purchase "the way of men" by Jack Donovan thst more deeply explain the foundation of masculinity.
"Contemplation on Violence"
A true thinking man explores how & why our species never ceases to fight. A worthy listen. Well narrated.
"An entertaining quick read. Fun way to learn more about MMA and UFC."
A well written book with good comedy throughout. He occasionally seems to over-dramatize and exaggerate points. Some of his points are biased and he comes off as overly certain about topics that are still widely considered to be controversial.
I will say I am much more interested in MMA after reading this and I have a new found respect for it. I found myself watching plenty of you tube videos.
I would definitely recommend this to anyone who is competitive or enjoys competitive sports. I'd also recommend it to those who want a fun way to learn a little more about MMA and UFC.
"Dive into the history, and reality, of fighting!"
No Question I Would! The authors story is brilliantly interleaved by fascinating accounts of violence throughout history, from dueling, to honor cultures, to our primate cousins.
If you've ever read any "martial arts" books or magazines, or ever attended a martial arts class or seminar, this book will change the way you see that world.
Definitely the author, the "professor in the cage", who not only studies the history and biology of male on male violence, but actively sought out the violence he studied. The real life character development over the course of the book is both true to life and inspiring.
This no-nonsense, pseudoscience busting work really puts the screws to the magic and fantasy of martial arts that become detached from real tests of aggression. Martial arts fans with a long history of training without taking a lot of real punches will find a hard truth in this book.
"Superb writing and narration"
One of the finest audiobooks I have listened to yet. Gottschall's ability to seamlessly weave his personal narrative around a thorough literary analysis of the psychology and history of fighting was brilliant. Not only is this audiobook highly entertaining, it also adds to the body of knowledge on the subject of fighting and what it means to be "a guy".
A brilliantly constructed insight into the mindset of the modern man and fighter. Thank you Jon Gottschall
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.